Personnel questions and -- surprise -- more worries about the draft (and the lockout) dominate this week's mailbag for beat writer Tony Grossi.
Joshua Gunter / The Plain DealerThe Browns believe Ahtyba Rubin will be a productive -- if not dominating -- player in any defensive format, which is why he's certain to be a foundation of Dick Jauron's 4-3 design. Hey, Tony: Everyone has Ahtyba Rubin locked into one of the tackle spots, but is he going to fit a four-man line? Do the coaches have any reasonable explanation why he won't be as out of place as Corey Williams was in a three-man line? -- David King, Joelton, Tenn.
Hey, David: Playing tackle in the 4-3 is not a big adjustment for a nose tackle in the 3-4. With his emergence as an interior pass rusher last season, Rubin may be even a better player in a four-man front. Williams was an interior penetrator in Green Bay's four-man line who was a square peg crammed into a round hole as defensive end in the Browns' two-gap three-man line. Worst possible transition.
Hey, Tony: How does the Browns' schedule compare to last year and to their divisional rivals? Easier, harder, about the same? -- DA Pimley, Centreville, Va.
Hey, DA: It's not whom you play in the NFL, it's when you play them. A couple thoughts on the schedule. 1. As usual, they were given a favor of starting at home and playing three of their first four at home. Every coach would love that to trigger a fast start. 2. Two trips to the West Coast in the span of 14 days is not good, especially when followed by another trip to Houston. 3. Three road games in a row is never a good thing. 4. Playing five division games in the last six weeks is the weirdest scheduling I've seen.
Hey, Tony: All the QBs in the 2011 draft are under the microscope on all different angles. Since Bernie Kosar did not go through the draft in 1985, what do you think the pundits would have said about his skill sets and where he would have fallen in a draft back then? His delivery, lack of mobility, only two years of playing, etc. thanks. -- Rod Sauer, Athens
Hey, Rod: Kosar failed at all the athletic tests, but excelled at reading defenses, throwing accuracy, leadership and toughness -- all the things great quarterbacks must have. He would have been described as a winner.
Hey, Tony: I really like what I'm seeing in some recent mock drafts. There is a potential for one of the top two QBs falling to sixth, giving the Browns a great chance to trade down with a team such as the Redskins. This would give us a shot at the likes of a Robert Quinn or Julio Jones and still pick up some additional compensation. What are your thoughts? -- Chris Clark, Columbus
Associated PressIf Missouri quarterback Blaine Gabbert is still on the draft board when the Browns' selection comes up, many fans are hoping the Berea front office can take advantage of a team -- such as the Redskins -- in need of a new face behind center. Hey, Chris: If A.J. Green is off the board ahead of them, I think the Browns would welcome your scenario. To get Quinn or Jones and an additional second-round pick no doubt would be considered a better value than using the sixth pick on someone other than Green.
Hey, Tony: In your analysis of the top of the draft, do you see any of the defensive players that may be available at six as solid, potential Pro Bowl pass rushers? If so who do you favor or do you favor a WR? -- Carl Salzano, Mentor
Hey, Carl: Most of the possible defensive linemen available at No. 6 scare me as high-risk players. I don't buy the hype about Robert Quinn. I'm petrified at the thought of taking Da'Quan Bowers and seeing him limp off the field with a bum knee. And Nick Fairley looks like the reincarnation of Gerard Warren. I would lean toward A.J. Green or Julio Jones.
Hey, Tony: Why is the media giving the Browns a free pass when it comes to their policy requiring season-ticket holders to pay in full by May 1 when there is no guarantee of a 2011 season? Other organizations such as the Giants have granted extensions until a new CBA is agreed. Once again the PSL/season-ticket holders are being taken advantage of and nobody seems to care! -- Bill Krempasky, Sagamore Hills
Hey, Bill: The Browns are a private company and can elect to run their business the way they want. You as a customer are free to take your business elsewhere. I don't see a role for the media in this issue. I'm sure I would have a different opinion if I were a season-ticket holder.
Hey, Tony: Does the pending rookie salary scale change teams' thinking regarding the draft? For example, would a team with a high pick like the Browns be more likely to go against "common wisdom" and draft the same position in successive years? -- Steve Cornelius, Avon Lake
Hey, Steve: Any change to the rookie salary pool has no impact on what a team might do in the draft. None.
Hey, Tony: How can us fans get our Browns to look at Dane Sanzenbacher for the slot? I realize that he may be a late-round pick, however, after watching him play on Fridays in Toledo, on Saturdays at OSU and in the Senior Bowl, he'd be higher on my draft board. He's a guy who just seems to be in always the right place at the right time. Am I stuck in dreamland and my man crush on Dane would not hold up in the NFL because the speed and size numbers just are not there, or could he fill the slot for my Brownies? -- Martin Extejt, Temperance, Mich.
Hey, Martin: Quoting from Dane Brugler's 2011 Draft Preview: "Sanzenbacher has consistent enough hands, but his lack of size and elite athleticism will keep him from being a consistent starter in the NFL. Ideal fourth WR who could emerge as a reliable slot target because of his field savvy, toughness, and receiving instincts." Brugler sees him being drafted in the fifth or sixth round.
Hey, Tony: At least one fairly credible Web site has the Browns selecting Temple defensive end Muhammad Wilkerson with the sixth pick. Rumors are he's shooting up draft boards and on YouTube videos he looks like a beast. What are your thoughts? -- Dave Torok, Independence, Ky.
Hey, Dave: The credible Web sites I respect most project Wilkerson as mostly a defensive end in a 3-4 scheme, but also as a tackle in a 4-3. I don't see the Browns shocking the world with this pick at No. 6.
Hey, Tony: If no agreement is reached with the owners and players, can NFL players sign with an Arena, Canadian or UFL team? Could investors start a new football league, and shut down the NFL if they can not reach a new CBA? -- Kenn Roberts, Columbus Grove
Hey, Kenn: There have been a few NFL players already who have bolted to the Arena League or United Football League. They have been borderline roster players, however, who haven't made much money yet and need the work for income. I don't see any established NFL player risking his long-term NFL career by playing in the other leagues for a few bucks. Historically, rival leagues spring up during times of NFL labor strife. However, as investment costs have escalated to stratospheric levels, the threat of a rival to the NFL has severely diminished. It would take a TV network starved for programming to fund the investment capital for a new startup league.
Hey, Tony: While the Browns will build through the draft, they need more than eight players, so they will have to do some free-agent shopping. Can you think of any pending free agents with links to Heckert, Holmgren, Shurmur and Jauron who will be available and may be of interest to the Browns? -- Rob Barnfield, Sydney, Australia
Hey, Rob: I intend to thoroughly analyze the free-agent situation after the draft process is completed. So much hinges on the labor dispute that it's premature to speculate at this point.
Chuck Crow / The Plain DealerThe lockout isn't helping Pat Shurmur in his first season as an NFL head coach, but there are plenty of league observers who believe he has what it takes to succeed. Hey, Tony: Without any off-season workouts/camps, etc., I don't have a very good "feel" for our new coach. From the time you've spent with him what are your impressions? Do you feel more comfortable with his offensive philosophy as compared to you know who from last year? Does he come across as a no-nonsense type coach who relates to his players? -- David Dobson, Myrtle Beach, S.C.
Hey, David: It's unfortunate that Pat Shurmur has been thrust into this miserable labor dispute in his first season as head coach. I can't imagine a worse set of obstacles to break in under. My initial impressions of Shurmur are positive. While Shurmur was an "under-the-radar" coaching candidate league-wide, everyone I've talked to in the NFL about him gives him high marks. But they are not nominating him for the Hall of Fame yet, either. The point is few know how Shurmur will turn out as a head coach. I like the fact he is from the offensive side. I like the fact he comes from a different coaching tree because what the Browns have tried for the past six years hasn't worked. And I like the fact that Shurmur, GM Tom Heckert and President Mike Holmgren share the same vision as to how to build a team and coach it.
Hey, Tony: We read about college players getting into trouble due to actions by their agents (money, gifts, parties), [but] what does the NFL do to the agents? If a college player does not have an agent, and there is no season, does he have the ability to return to the college ranks if he is an underclassman? -- Mike, Union City, Pa.
Hey, Mike: Agents at the NFL level are regulated by the NFL players association. They have suspended some agents in the past for their actions. If there is no NFL season, teams retain the rights to the players they drafted. Unless, of course, the entire NFL system is turned upside down by the players' antitrust suit and they become free agents.
Hey, Tony: Is the lockout and the inability to sign free agents a factor in who teams will select on draft day? Usually by now teams have filled some of their holes via free agency and have a better idea on what positions to target in the draft. I believe a good receiver is necessary to further Colt McCoy's development, but also because they have the potential to make the other receivers more productive. I also agree with you that we should not trade down more than a few spots and only for a second-round pick. I am not against drafting Peterson at six and having two young shutdown corners. I think the tandem of Hanford Dixon and Frank Minnifield was a significant part of the Browns' three trips to the conference finals during the 1980s. Don't you think we can fill a couple of defensive line positions through free agency? -- Paul Naudain, Portland, Ore.
Hey, Paul: I agree with just about all your points. I will make this point again about Dixon and Minnifield because I think it's important to note. Dixon was a first-round pick. Minnifield was signed from the United States Football League and didn't cost the Browns a draft choice. When you devote two top-10 draft choices in a row to the cornerback position you are stalling your growth at other areas. Totally different circumstances in 2011 than in 1984.
Hey, Tony: I have not heard Casey Matthews' name mentioned much in all this draft talk. Where do you see him going in the draft? I would hope the Browns would have a shot at him in a later round. -- Alan Kraus, Delta, Ohio
Hey, Alan: Most experts have Matthews going in the third round.
Michael Conroy / Associated PressJulio Jones is considered by some draft experts as more physical than Georgia's A.J. Green, and therefore a better choice for a West Coast offense featuring crossing patterns. Hey, Tony: I happened to see The Baltimore Sun's 4/17 mock draft. The writer, Jamison Hensley, predicts the Browns will pass over A.J. Green because "he doesn't fit into the Browns' West Coast Offense." What skills does a receiver need to fit in the new offense? Does Green have them? -- Stan Himes, West Des Moines, Iowa
Hey, Stan: Green can fit in any offensive system. The writer must have been referring to frequent analyses of Julio Jones being a more physical player and thus adept at running the crossing routes in the WCO.
Hey, Tony: How crazy am I for thinking that the Browns should consider taking Kyle Rudolph with their No. 2 pick? He is probably a future All-Pro, a great blocking and catching tight end. He would be a solid, extend-the-field receiver and run-blocking guy who would really fit the offense. -- Greg Foust, Akron
Hey, Greg: You used the word crazy. I think the Browns are OK at tight end with Ben Watson and Evan Moore. They need more touchdown-makers.
Hey, Tony: Did you know that a letter from NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell to the Congressional Black Caucus is posted in its entirety on another sports Web site? In his letter to the caucus, Goodell outlines the last proposal to the NFLPA before the union walked away from the negotiations and decertified. Presuming Goodell is being honest and forthright in his letter, it seems all of the players' publicly stated demands were met by the owners. Goodell wrote that the proposal included lifelong health insurance (including free neurological exams, joint replacement surgery and rehab, and other benefits at no cost to the player/retiree), extended benefits for players diagnosed with a brain disease, a significant pay increase to retirees, and up to $1,000,000 of the players' contract guaranteed (even in the event of injury) -- all without any contribution from the players themselves or the union. So I guess my question is this: What exactly are the players looking to receive in a new CBA that hasn't already been offered to them? And in your professional opinion, what will it take to end this lockout? (And please don't reply money. That's a lazy answer.) -- Tim, Winter Haven, Fla.
Hey, Tim: My take is the players want to preserve their present percentage of shared revenue in future revenue growth. The owners want to reduce it. That's not a lazy answer. It's the truth.
Hey, Tony: How serious are the Browns about developing Jarrett Brown? Does he become the third active QB and will the Browns end their relationship with Jake Delhomme? -- Terry Carbetta, Ashland
Hey, Terry: Brown was signed because somebody likes something about him. I wouldn't award him a roster spot just yet. I believe the Browns will also draft a developmental quarterback. That would put Delhomme, Brown and the rookie in competition for the No. 3 role.
Hey, Tony: Do the Browns look at local products such as WR Cecil Shorts from Mount Union and WR Joe Morgan and DT Tony Reed from Walsh? Who scouts these local players? -- George Condoleon Canfield
Hey, George: They have area scouts who are responsible for certain geographical areas, and then those players are cross-checked by other members of the personnel department.
Hey, Tony: We all know the restrictions on trading players in this year's draft due to the labor situation. Is it allowed, and would it be possible, for teams to make prearranged trades to be consummated after an agreement on a CBA? For example, if the Vikings want to trade Sidney Rice to the Browns for a second-round pick and fourth-round pick (I dream), could the Browns select the players the Vikings want and then deal the rights of those players for Rice after a new CBA is reached? -- John, Dayton
Hey, John: No, something like that cannot take place.
Hey, Tony: I thought when teams play each other from other conferences, they rotated locations, so every eight years you would see the other teams. With that, how is it the Browns play at Arizona and here vs. Seattle in 2011, the same setup as 2007? -- Brian Tomlin, Fairview Park
Hey, Brian: Teams on the West Coast always fly the most air miles, and they've not been happy about it. A few years ago the NFL sought to accommodate their concerns by tweaking the schedule a bit each year to lessen their air miles. Occasionally these tweaks result in the Browns playing the same team at home or on the road that they played four years earlier. So don't assume anymore that teams automatically alternate game sites against interconference opponents.
Hey, Tony: Now that the schedule has been released, why do games that feature West Coast teams coming to the eastern time zone (for example, Seahawks at Browns) start at 1 p.m. and not 4 p.m.? Just seems logical (a 1 p.m. game here is a 10 a.m. start time for fans in Seattle) for the fans of both teams to be able to enjoy the game. Plus I like the 4 p.m. start time over the 1 p.m. start time, I can get more done at home before the game than I can after on a Sunday. -- Matt R, Akron
Hey, Matt: Start times are entirely dictated by the whims of the networks. If a network would rather have Team A playing at 1 o'clock for its Eastern audience, then the Western audience will have to tune in at 10 a.m.
Hey, Tony: I immediately eliminate A.J. Green from consideration. Here's my reasoning: Given the recent rules changes that reduce the run-back opportunities on kickoffs, I think shifting Josh Cribbs' focus to WR would maximize his ability. Cribbs is a dynamic enough playmaker if he shifts to full-time WR the Browns get a needed playmaker on offense and plug one of the holes on defense by drafting LSU CB Patrick Peterson or a DL. I know you don't favor drafting a WR anyway, but what do you think about modifying Cribbs to maximize his ability? -- Jonathan Saurage, Chicago
Hey, Jonathan: I think Cribbs will benefit from the new offense. Maybe the Browns are thinking the same as you. I just think Green is a playmaker on offense the Browns currently don't have. And he comes with much less risk than the D-linemen rated high in this draft.
Hey, Tony: Do you know if Greg Little of North Carolina is being considered by the Browns for the third round? I know he only played one full season as a wide receiver and would be a developmental-type player, but he is freak. -- Tommy O'Brien, Streetsboro
Hey, Tommy: Yes, Little is a physical freak. The Browns have visited with him.
Hey, Tony: Just for argument's sake, let's say the entire 2011 NFL season is canceled. What would happen with the 2011 draft picks? Also, what would happen with the 2012 draft? -- Kevin Kropf, Brunswick
Hey, Kevin: Note to everyone: Please clip and save this answer. The NFL has not addressed this doomsday scenario. At some point, it may have to. We will surely report it when it happens.
-- Tony