The mailbag is overflowing with questions about roster moves and possible choices this month.
Lynne Sladky / Associated PressIs Andrew Luck worth another win-starved season for the Browns? One fan thinks perhaps, but doesn't get any support from Tony Grossi. Hey, Tony: Not to sound like a conspiracy theorist, but would Mike Holmgren consider the upcoming season a transitional year for the Browns and attempt to set himself up for a run at Stanford QB Andrew Luck? Holmgren was never a strong McCoy supporter and even publicly wavers on him now. He hired a new coach who has never held that position before. He's authorized a complete rebuild and re-scheme of the defense when both player movement and off-season activities have been shelved for the time being.
Luck supposedly carries a scouting grade similar to that of Manning and Elway and is a West Coast guy, a la Holmgren. This isn't suggesting Holmgren would purposely build a team to lose games, but would it be outside the realm of reasonable thought to consider he understands his fall-back position and has acted accordingly? -- Leslie Marchak, Sagamore Hills
Hey, Leslie: Nobody can lay a path that guarantees drafting Luck in 2012. What if he has a career-threatening injury? What if he changes his mind and decides to pursue a career in business? What if the draft is deemed an antitrust violation and all college players enter the NFL as free agents? Also, your characterization of Holmgren not being a strong supporter of McCoy is off base. Holmgren is McCoy's biggest backer.
Hey, Tony: If the NFL doesn't figure out the labor situation by the draft, can teams only trade picks this year for other picks this year? Or can they creatively trade "future considerations" like baseball does? -- Chris Zanon, Canton
Hey, Chris: Only draft picks can be traded. These can include future draft picks. But future considerations will not fly.
Hey, Tony: What happens if the lockout ends and all parties agree on the first week of September? How many practice days will elapse before the first regular-season game? Do you think there will be a three-week period for rookie evaluation and team practices before the start of meaningful games? That could mean even if the lockout ended the first week of September, it could be October before we had a real game. -- Nathan Cornell, Minneapolis, Minn.
Hey, Nathan: If the lockout ends the first week of September, I am sure the start of the season will be delayed by a few weeks. If that is the case, the season will be shorter -- as in 1982 and 1987 -- and ticket-holders would be refunded for unplayed games. The exact timetable of a season re-start can not be determined at this point.
Hey, Tony: I believe Dane Sanzenbacher will become a star in a pass-first offense in the NFL. While his 40 time is similar to Brian Robiskie's, he showed much more explosion with the Buckeyes. Is he a good fit for the Browns in the later rounds? -- Aaron Howell, North Canton
Hey, Aaron: Any receiver who 1) catches the ball and 2) accelerates for yards after the catch, is a good fit for the West Coast offense. He doesn't necessarily have to be from Ohio State to qualify.
John Bazemore / Associated PressAre there any sure things in the draft? Georgia receiver A.J. Green seems to be one of the safest selections available. Hey, Tony: With all of the gaping needs we have, is there really any way to be upset for drafting the best available player at one of those needs? Of those players, who do you feel will be the biggest potential to bust? -- Vin, Akron
Hey, Vin: I keep hearing that A.J. Green, Patrick Peterson and Von Miller are the safest picks in the top 10. That would make all the others potential busts.
Hey, Tony: Concerning the salary cap ... what happens when a NFL team doesn't use all of its available cap space? Is it true that some NFL owners write off player salaries and other expenses as business losses? -- Shaylin Butler, Pemberton, N.J.
Hey, Shaylin: When there was a cap, there is nothing that says a team must spend to the cap limit. Typically, teams leave room for unforeseen circumstances, such as a star player being lost for the season. Saving room gives such teams flexibility to fill such needs. My answer to your second question is owners write off all appropriate expenditures for tax purposes.
Hey, Tony: With no free agency, I see this as the perfect year to trade down in the draft and get extra picks. If either of the top QBs is still available, I think we should be able to get a second round pick and stay in the top eight or a second and a fourth and stay in the top 12. -- Chris Crandall, Fort Myers Beach, Fla.
Hey, Chris: Yes, I do believe the climate is right to trade down. In my opinion, moving to No. 12 would be too far. Ideally, they would drop one to four spots, at most.
Hey, Tony: I know you reported Josh Cribbs may be used as a receiver, but what are the chances that he's used as a running back? The Browns need someone along with Hillis and Hardesty and Josh is big with breakaway speed in the open field. -- Steve Bohnenkamp, Geneva, Ill.
Hey, Steve: I -- and many others -- have long advocated Cribbs as a third-down back as a means of getting the ball into his hands more easily and quickly. I understand there would be a need to hand him the ball, too, but I would never consider him a full-time back. The precise plans for Cribbs by the new coaching staff are stymied by the owners lockout.
Hey, Tony: Given that it's unlikely Pat Shurmur will utilize the Wildcat and that Josh Cribbs is so exciting and explosive a player, why wouldn't they use Cribbs like the Eagles, running an offense of similar style, use DeSean Jackson? -- David Cavallo, Washington, D.C.
Hey, David: If you mean getting the ball quickly into Cribbs' hands, I'd agree. But Jackson also runs a lot of longer, vertical routes, which I don't think are Cribbs' strong suit. I believe the Eagles' deep passing game last year was among the league's best.
Hey, Tony: How does the compensatory picks help the competitive balance in the NFL? It seems like the haves continue to benefit significantly more than the have nots. It requires that you actually have talent that someone else wants. The NFL makes it extremely difficult for bad teams to change their fortunes. What are your thoughts? -- Greg Potts, Massillon
Hey, Greg: You've hit on the one aspect of the NFL's system that, in fact, does benefit the "haves" for precisely the reason you state. In just about every other aspect, the league gets criticized for penalizing the good teams (tougher schedule, lower draft position, "Final 4" and "Final 8" free agency rules, etc.).
Hey, Tony: Troy WR Jerrel Jernigan seems like exactly what the doctor ordered for the Browns' offense. But he's probably not good value with their choice in the second round, and probably gone by the third. What do you think? -- Scott, Brunswick
Hey, Scott: Jernigan is a small (5-9) receiver with elite speed who was extremely productive. I've seen one service rate him No. 3 among receivers and project him to go no later than the second round.
Hey, Tony: All the talk about drafting a QB looks wrong to me. The Browns have 4 QBs on the roster now. Starter Colt McCoy, backup Seneca Wallace, old pro Jake Delhomme and Jarret Brown. What I read about Brown is that he has a gun for an arm. He sounds very raw but that will change with team activities. What is your take on Jarret Brown? -- Pat Gillis, Dayton
Hey, Pat: I have no take on Brown until I see him play. It doesn't matter how many QBs a team has on its roster. If it doesn't have one capable of taking it to the Super Bowl, the position is still one of need. The Browns have to decide if McCoy can take them to a Super Bowl. At present, they think he can.
Rick Wood / Milwaukee Journal SentinelIn Tony Grossi's rankings, Wisconsin defensive end J.J. Watt is one of the 10 top players available in the first round. Hey, Tony: I really enjoy your mock drafts. With the current labor situation, I believe the Browns should take the best player available. We do not know who will even be on the team next year and there is no ability to sign a free agent. Who do you think are the 10 best players available? -- Nick Brown, Pershing, Ind.
Hey, Nick: I think the top 10 players available are these, not in any particular order: A.J. Green, Julio Jones, Patrick Peterson, Marcell Dareus, Nick Fairley, Von Miller, Cam Newton, Prince Amukamara, Da'Quan Bowers and J.J. Watt.
Hey, Tony: If the NFL institutes a rookie wage scale with the new CBA, what effect would it have on the league's competitive balance? It seems teams like the Browns, Lions, and Bills always have high draft picks and a lot of salary cap tied up in unproven rookies. -- Andy Hummel, Wooster
Hey, Andy: It depends on the rules of the rookie wage scale. I haven't seen a definitive plan. Rookie contracts haven't affected the salary cap because the old system had a first-year rookie cap built inside the overall team cap. The problems arise after the first year when the roster bonuses and salary escalators kick in. The biggest reason for a rookie wage scale would be to cut back on the huge cash signing bonuses and future guarantees that rookie contracts now routinely include.
Hey, Tony: I was surprised at the number of fans who want to upgrade the offensive line. Not a bad thing, but while Tony Pashos is injury prone, Floyd Womack has played great for two years and I thought Billy Yates was very good till he was injured. How do you see the OL this year? -- Irish Dog, Perry
Hey, Dog: I tend to agree with you, though I would point out that both Womack and Yates are unrestricted free agents and we have no idea of their future. I think the overriding priority for the offense can be summed up in one word -- touchdowns -- not a particular position.
Hey, Tony: Let's assume the best case scenario that Montario Hardesty is fully recovered from injury and he and Peyton Hillis make a great 1-2 combo. The Browns will still be very thin at running back. With the top picks likely to go to defense, are there any free-agent running backs you feel might be good signs for the Browns to add depth or versatility? -- Rich Smith, Columbus
Hey, Rich: There are always running backs waiting for their phone to ring. There's also a few dozen left undrafted. It's premature to speculate on veteran backs who will be free agents because of this crazy labor timeout.
Hey, Tony: Does The Plain Dealer uses Wunderlich tests in screening prospective sports writers? What was your score? I know that my OU degree always outshined any test scores, after they asked, "where is that located." -- Ron Scheurer, Mansfield
Hey, Ron: I took the Wonderlic one time in the painfully slow period during one Browns draft in the 1980s. I think my score was 30. But I'm much smarter now and would be willing to take it again.
Hey, Tony: Did Phil Dawson sign his tender? -- Bob Steward, Erie, Pa.
Hey, Bob: Dawson did not sign his franchise tender before the NFL lockout brought a total shutdown to all player transactions.
Hey, Tony: Terry Pluto stated that we currently do not have any defensive ends for the 4-3. I know we need both/everything (defensively speaking) but why is tackle slightly more paramount than end? -- Eric Cook, Glendale, Ariz.
Hey, Eric: Who said tackle was more important than end? Depends on the coach and his scheme. Look at this way: In the four-man front, the end's primary responsibility is to rush the passer. That puts a higher premium on the end position. The only bona fide starting defensive line player currently on the roster is tackle Ahtyba Rubin.
Hey, Tony: If the labor lockout continues beyond the draft, would you consider trading 2012's first round pick for Kevin Kolb? -- Chris Crandall, Fort Myers Beach, Fla.
Hey, Chris: No.
Tracy Boulian / The Plain DealerIf Josh Cribbs emerges as a significant contributor as a wide receiver, does that eliminate the Browns' need at the position? Hey, Tony: With better coaching and a new receiver-friendly system, are our present receivers, including Josh Cribbs, good enough to warrant not taking a receiver in the draft? -- Mike Greenlee, Saint Paris
Hey, Mike: You might argue against taking one in the first round, but they've got to take one soon after.
Hey, Tony: I've always been curious about the behind-the-scenes moves needed to pull off a draft day trade. Say the Redskins want to move up a couple spots to the Browns' No.6 position to grab a QB. What is the general strategy? Will they try to make the deal early on the clock? Will they wait to try to gain leverage? Will the Browns tell them if other teams are interested in the spot too? If so, will they reveal the teams? Will they talk a few days in advance? -- Zack Hill, Arlington, Va.
Hey, Zack: All of that is possible. I've known the Browns to rearrange a draft-day trade the day before the draft and also known them to pull one off with their time on the clock winding down. Most times teams don't reveal whom they intend to take. But in the case of the Browns' trade with Baltimore in 2006, Ozzie Newsome told Phil Savage he wanted Haloti Ngata and Savage said he could have him for a sixth-round pick. Tsk, tsk.
Hey, Tony: The Browns have stated they will refund my 2011 season ticket purchases when games begin to cancel. Has anyone stated anything about PSL contracts and how they might be affected? I will not be planning to renew if one single game is cancelled. They can bank on it. -- John Moore, Waukegan, Ill.
Hey, John: I don't believe PSL contracts are affected by canceled games. My question about PSLs is this: If you don't renew your season tickets, don't you effectively blow the money you invested in the PSLs? Nice racket, huh?
Hey, Tony: It is a given the defensive line needs a lot of help, and this is a deep D-line draft. But with the league being quarterback driven these days, don't the Browns have to take A.J. Green, if he is still there, to ensure the growth and development of Colt McCoy, and then use remaining picks on the likes of a Christian Ballard, Marvin Austin, or Drake Nevis to solidify the defensive front? -- Matt Krystofik, Dayton
Hey, Matt: That's one line of thinking, yes.
Hey, Tony: My wife and I pride ourselves in being in our seats before kickoff. With the new kickoff rule maybe we should enjoy one more beverage before getting to our seats. Pretty soon games will look like controlled scrimmages. Don't you think there should be some sort of trade off for a non-returnable kickoff? -- Dale Galbraith, Barberton
Hey, Dale: My answer was to spot a touchback at the 30-yard line, which would greatly reduce the incentive to kick the ball out of the end zone. Coaches griped about a 25-yard spot and the 20-yard spot was retained. To me, it's a terrible rule, but we'll see how it works out.
Hey, Tony: The general thought is that it would be best to draft a defensive lineman at No. 6 as this is the greatest need; selecting a quarterback would be crazy. Since last season it seemed almost impossible to go three or four games with the same quarterback because of injury, what is so bad with taking the best quarterback at 6? If we are on the fourth-string guy by game seven, maybe picking a quarterback does not sound so bad and of more value than any linemen at that point. -- Chuck McDermott, Columbus, Ind.
Hey, Chuck: To me, the only way the Browns should take a quarterback at No. 6 is if they feel he is more qualified than Colt McCoy to take the team to the Super Bowl. If they are unsure, they shouldn't take him.
Hey, Tony: Can Green Bay use the draft format to their advantage by not making their pick on the first day? They will then have almost a full day to listen to offers to trade draft positions. They will still be on the clock when things pick up the next day and, as long as they get their pick in as soon as the draft resumes, have lost nothing. -- Steve Yates, Rochester, N.Y.
Hey, Steve: I honestly don't know if that's allowable. My best hunch is that the round is not complete until a 32nd selection, and that the owner of the No. 33 pick -- New England -- would be allowed to leapfrog Green Bay and make a selection. But that is a guess. Since the NFL chopped up the draft over three days, there are some "what ifs" that have not been answered, such as the one you present.
Hey, Tony: Though I am very much pro-player, I am also aware NFL athletes often choose to wear as little protective padding as possible. Given the safety discussions, perhaps it is time to research/release data on the correlation between concussions and those not wearing mouthpieces. Seems one sees more mouthpieces on NCAA basketballers than in NFL mouths. -- Mark Leonard, Charlotte, N.C.
Hey, Mark: Making mouthpieces mandatory has been long advocated by former Browns tackle Doug Dieken. I have heard him ask this question to coaches and league officials and each time the answer is a blank stare. When the league talks incessantly of concussion safety measures, it never, ever, brings up mandatory mouthpieces. And yet studies have shown mouth guards help prevent concussions.
Hey, Tony: I've never been overly impressed with Josh Cribbs the receiver, but he is (was) a force on special teams not only in the return game and covered kickoffs and punts very well usually leading in special teams tackles. I know there hasn't been talk of it, but do you think he could benefit from a switch to defense and possibly play safety? In my opinion he would make much more of an impact. -- Jamey Majoros, Concord
Hey, Jamey: Former coach Eric Mangini talked for two years of experimenting with Cribbs at safety -- for emergency purposes, not for a full-time switch -- but nothing came of it. Myself, I think Cribbs' skills are better suited as a third-down receiving threat out of the backfield.
Hey, Tony: With Wade Phillips transitioning the Texans' defense into a 3-4, is there any chance the Browns could pursue some of their defensive linemen? Amobi Okoye is still only 23 and adding an end like Da'Quan Bowers could jump start our move to the 4-3 while allowing us to explore other options, namely receiver and right tackle, in the later rounds. -- Tom Mitro, Orlando, Fla.
Hey, Tom: Okoye is an enigma. He had a decent rookie year but has regressed ever since. I'm sure when the labor impasse is resolved, the Browns will aggressively pursue defensive linemen on other rosters. Because of the age, as you stated, he should be looked at.
Hey, Tony: If the CBA agreement is not settled, will trades be allowed during the draft? -- Frank Kovach, Johnstown, Pa.
Hey, Frank: Trades can involve only present or future draft choices. No players.
Hey, Tony: The player association is telling rookies not to participate on draft night, so that they wont shake hands with owners. It's a spit in the owners' faces -- the guys that will be signing their pay checks! What's up with that ignorance? -- Mike Love, Merritt Island, Fla.
Hey, Mike: The NFLPA has since backed off on plans to ask for a boycott of the draft, ostensibly because of the avalanche of negative publicity the story received.
Hey, Tony: Did anything ever come of the investigation of the alleged incident with the 8-year-old boy and his dad getting roughed up after the Jets game? -- Joe Bailey, Newark, N.Y.
Hey, Joe: Not that I'm aware of.
Hey, Tony: More players seem to be speaking out about getting a raw deal this time. The players make a lot more money than the average fan. Owners are owners, they made their business and the owners are entitled to be successful without giving away a majority of the income they have earned. Do the players realize that this makes them look greedy and selfish and the general feeling is that fans are going to turn on players for being that way? Why doesn't anyone call the players out on being money-hungry parasites that need to learn their place -- that is below the owners, for that matter below the fans, not on top of the NFL. -- Matt R., Akron
Hey, Matt: To clarify one key point: the players simply want the same deal they have. The owners are the ones locking them out to force a new deal more favorable to them. The owners know their sport's revenue will multiply in coming years and they want to put a cap on the percentage of new growth shared with the players.
Hey, Tony: Normally rookies wouldn't be able to participate in team activities other than rookie OTAs until they've signed a contract. With the lockout in place can drafted rookies participate in organized player practices? If we drafted AJ Green, would he be able to practice plays with Colt and other players during the lockout? -- Jeremy Skatzes, Columbus
Hey, Jeremy: My gut feeling is no. Even if they were allowed, it might be ill-advised for them to participate because they will not be under contract. A twisted ankle or more serious injury might lead to a loss of money in their eventual rookie contract.
Hey, Tony: I'm a bit of an optimist. I am hopeful that the two Mitchells can contribute next season (assuming Jayme resigns). Am I mad? Also not being from Cleveland, who are their biggest rivals? -- Gerard Fitzgerald, Cork, Ireland
Hey, Gerard: I have a feeling Carlton Mitchell, the receiver, will be given a real opportunity to show his game. Jayme Mitchell, the defensive end, is unsigned, but was called the team's best pass rusher -- though he was unused -- by GM Tom Heckert. The Browns' biggest rivals currently are Pittsburgh, Baltimore and Cincinnati. At various points in their history, they have had strong rivalries with Detroit, Dallas, the Giants and Denver.
Hey, Tony: If a rookie wage scale is put in place, how will the player's draft position factor in his salary, if at all? -- Dan Kubacki, Erie, Pa.
Hey, Dan: Details of the proposed rookie wage scale have not been disclosed.
Hey, Tony: How serious are the Browns about drafting Colin Kaepernick from Nevada? I understand they have a workout scheduled for him. With an arm like he has and his athleticism, he seems like he could be a good value pick. -- Glenn Studevant, Tucson, Ariz.
Hey, Glenn: He is an intriguing prospect who will garner enough attention, I believe, to be taken in the second round. He probably has the best arm in the draft, but needs work on a lot of facets of the position.
Hey, Tony: The NFL Players Union is officially decertified. Fine and good, as it allows the players to file the lawsuits that are now rampant in the news. However, when this mess is finally resolved, can the players re-activate their union at the snap of a finger?
If so, it seems the players have the best of all worlds: They can decertify themselves at a moments' notice, then turn right around and recertify themselves like nothing has happened. Seems to me that once they decertified themselves, that's their poison they choose. They shouldn't be allowed to flipflop back and forth. -- David Bowles, Colorado Springs, Colo.
Hey, David: I'm not schooled enough in labor law to totally understand why the union can recertify. It did so in 1991 because the NFL wanted it to and signed off on it. The owners want the players union to exist, because an agreement with a union allows the league to impose collectively bargained rules that may, in fact, violate antitrust laws. Recertifying the union is also beneficial to the players. Without a union, many of the rights and benefits the players now enjoy could be removed. For instance, without a union maybe teams negotiate benefits with star players, but not all players.
Hey, Tony: Have you made up a list of "I wouldn't touch with a 10-foot pole" for the upcoming draft? My list would include Jake Locker, Da'Quan Bowers, Cam Newton and Robert Quinn. -- Raymond Dumont, Foley, Ala.
Hey, Raymond: I have not yet made up my 10-foot pole list. Without the insider info on medical, character and arrest reports, it's hard to know exactly whom to avoid. Whereas, some veteran players' body of work in these areas are well-known.
Hey, Tony: Always enjoy reading your columns when I get the chance in Bronco country! How can Bowers not be a bust just like Courtney Brown? He was a "can't miss" and we took him No. 1 and was one of the biggest busts of all time! I could make the same argument for taking A.J. Green or Julio Jones because of "that kid from up north" in Braylon Edwards. If on the board, I'd take Patrick Peterson from LSU. He and Joe Haden could make the best tandem of CBs in the AFC North! -- Dave C, Denver by way of Mentor
Hey, Dave: You have a negative style of drafting. Don't take this guy, don't take that guy, etc. You eliminate so many players, you may not have any left to take at No. 6. As for Peterson, I offer this example: The best tandem of cornerbacks in the AFC North -- by far -- belongs to the Cincinnati Bengals. They finished 4-12 last year.
-- Tony