While the Tribe's once-powerful hitting lineup has waned, there has been an increase in another precious commodity in the organization -- pitching.
Chuck Crow l The Plain DealerThe Indians' pitching staff is young and mostly unproven, but there is plenty of potential. CLEVELAND, Ohio — It used to be a hitter's paradise. All the Indians did was hit and all they produced was hitters.
Let your memory work and the names quickly appear on the scoreboard in your head: Albert Belle, Kenny Lofton, Carlos Baerga, Omar Vizquel, Robbie Alomar, Jim Thome, Manny Ramirez, Sandy Alomar Jr, Eddie Murray, Paul Sorrento, David Justice, Matt Williams, Travis Fryman. They had so many hitters that there was no room for players such as Sean Casey, Brian Giles and Richie Sexson. They were traded and became productive hitters for someone else.
The era of swat has cooled in Cleveland. Last year it turned to ice. The Indians lost 93 games and finished 25th in the big leagues in team batting average (.248) and 26th in runs (646).
While the hitters have waned, there has been an increase in another precious commodity in the Indians' organization -- pitching.
No one is comparing it to 1954, when the Indians had a starting rotation of Bob Lemon, Early Wynn, Mike Garcia, Art Houteman and Bob Feller with a young left-hander named Herb Score waiting in the minors. But the Indians, in a sense, are just getting started.
Their big-league rotation is young; Fausto Carmona and Mitch Talbot are the oldest at 27. The rotation features two hard throwers in Justin Masterson and Carlos Carrasco, who were acquired in two of the three big trades that have rocked the organization since 2008. In the bullpen, they have closer Chris Perez, primed for a breakout year. He, too, was acquired through trade.
Down below things are bubbling.
PDTribe starter Fausto Carmona is one of the oldest pitchers on the staff and he's only 27. "It's the largest amount of pitching depth and options that we've had in a while," said Ross Atkins, in his fifth year as Indians director of player development. "It's significant how much depth we feel we have with pitching. It's not so much that we have one or two of them, but that we have such a large number of options that we feel can be contributors."
Former GM Mark Shapiro talked about having not just one or two prospects in the minors, but "waves of prospects." No one knows if the Indians will be able to surf on this wave, but they believe it's far more than a ripple.
Alex White, Drew Pomeranz, Jason Knapp, Carrasco, Zach McAllister, Kelvin De La Cruz, Nick Hagadone and Matt Packer are the curl on the wave.
White was the Indians' No.1 pick in 2009. The Indians paid him $2.25 million after drafting him out of the University of North Carolina. He pitched at Class AA Akron and Class A Kinston last year and will start this season at Class AAA Columbus.
"We like his competitiveness and the ability to go get a 96-mph to 97-mph four-seam fastball and his ability to sink it," said Atkins. "With a developing slider and split, he could end up at the front of the rotation."
White, 22, was a combined 10-10 with a 2.45 ERA (41 earned runs in 150 2/3 innings) last year. The right-hander still has to learn to use his slider and split and not rely only on his fastball. That's what happened to him this spring in his first real exposure to big-league hitters, and they hit .417 against him.
"He got away from using his pitches," said Atkins. "He's so competitive, he said 'I'm going down with my best' and stuck with his fastball too much."
Pomeranz, 22, was the Indians No.1 pick in 2010 out of the University of Mississippi. They paid him $2.65 million after taking him with the fifth overall pick.
The 6-5, 230-pound left-hander will start the year at Class A Kinston. He pitched only in the Arizona Instructional League last year after signing. He throws between 93 mph and 96 mph and his fastball jumps at the hitter late.
"He gets in the mid 90s real easy," said Indians pitching coach Tim Belcher.
The Indians foresee a rotation with White and Pomeranz as the tip of the spear.
"In the past Cleveland took some guys pretty high in the draft that I didn't think were good American League pitchers," said John Hart, former Indians general manager and current senior advisor for the Texas Rangers. "That's been a missing piece for Cleveland what with the loss of CC Sabathia and Cliff Lee."
Hart said White and Pomeranz have the ability to change that.
Bringing the heat
There was no accurate way to measure how hard Bob Feller threw on his way to becoming the winningest pitcher in Indians history. Various attempts to measure his velocity ranged between 100 mph to 104 mph. In honor of Feller, who died on Dec. 15, here are some of the hardest throwers in the Indians farm system.
1. RHP Bryce Stowell, Class AA Akron: 100 mph.
2. RHP Austin Adams, Class AA Akron: 100 mph.
3. RHP Jason Knapp, Class A Kinston: 97 mph.
4. RHP Alex White, Class AAA Columbus: 96 mph.
5. LHP Nick Hagadone, Class AA Akron: 96 mph.
6. Drew Pomeranz, Class A Kinston: 95 mph.
The readings for the Tribe's minor leaguers represent their highest clocking. Most of them pitch or "sit' below that.
Cleveland Indians 2011
"From where Cleveland picked in the draft, they got the best two guys," said Hart. "White slipped a little because people questioned his arm, but he's got plus stuff. I think he could be a solid middle to front of the rotation starter.
"Pomeranz was the best college pitcher on the draft board last year. He's a big-bodied left-hander with an out-pitch curveball and a fastball that's good enough. Cleveland, in its market, needs to hit with both these guys."
The Indians acquired Knapp, a 20-year-old right-hander, from Philadelphia in the Cliff Lee trade in 2009. He missed most of last year recovering from right shoulder surgery to remove bone chips and repair a frayed labrum. He made 10 starts at the end of last year in the Arizona Rookie League and Class A Lake County, striking out 47 in 281/3 innings.
Knapp probably will open the year in extended spring training. The Indians brought him to camp in January to increase his shoulder strength and will limit his innings this year because he threw so few last season. When he does join a team, it will probably be Class A Kinston.
"He's definitely a guy," said Atkins. "He's been up to 97 mph to 98 mph with an above-average slider. He has the physical strength to haul innings and an incredible head on his shoulders for a young pitcher."
A big league scout said the Indians took a "flyer' on Knapp in the Lee deal.
"He shows potential," said the scout, "but he still has development to go.
"The Indians, like most clubs, are stockpiling arms. White and Pomeranz give them two quality arms that should be able to move through the system quickly."
Said Hart, "When they made the Lee deal, Knapp was the biggest upside guy in it. He's been hurt. If a guy is limited for a couple of years, you've got to wonder what it means."
The Indians acquired Carrasco, 24, in the Lee deal. He made the Indians' Opening Day roster this spring and will start the second game of the season Saturday against Chicago at Progressive Field.
Manager Manny Acta says the right-handed Carrasco may have the highest ceiling of any pitcher in the organization.
"I believe he's going to be a good major-league pitcher," said Acta.
McAllister, 23, came from the Yankees for Austin Kearns at the July 31 trading deadline last year. He's 6-6 and 240 pounds and will start the year at Class AAA Columbus. His father, Steve, is a scout for Arizona.
Tribe roster breakdown
Starting rotation (five): Fausto Carmona, Carlos Carrasco, Justin Masterson, Josh Tomlin, Mitch Talbot.
Bullpen (seven): Chris Perez, Tony Sipp, Rafael Perez, Vinnie Pestano, Chad Durbin, Frank Herrmann and Justin Germano.
Catchers (two): Carlos Santana and Lou Marson.
Infielders (six): Matt LaPorta, Orlando Cabrera, Asdrubal Cabrera, Jack Hannahan, Adam Everett and Travis Hafner.
Outfielders (five): Austin Kearns, Michael Brantley, Shin-Soo Choo, Travis Buck and Shelley Duncan.
"Guys like McAllister and Jeanmar Gomez (another starter at Columbus) provide depth for the back end of the rotation," said the same scout who commented earlier about the Indians stockpiling arms.
De La Cruz, Hagadone and Packer offer balance to the foam at the top of the wave as left-handers. De La Cruz and Packer are expected to be in the Class AA rotation at Akron. Hagadone will probably be in the Akron bullpen.
The 6-5, 190-pound De La Cruz, 22, missed most of the 2009 season with an elbow injury.
"De La Cruz is definitely in the mix," said Belcher. "He throws in the low 90s and has room to grow. He could really be a monster. He could be bigger than Pomeranz or Hagadone. He's got the shoulders to carry it."
He's the only 6-5 lefty in the Tribe organization who can do a standing back flip. Just ask him.
The Indians acquired Hagadone, 25, and Masterson, 26, from Boston for Victor Martinez in their 2009 fire sale. Atkins called Hagadone's 2010 season "his hiccup year" as he was coming off Tommy John surgery in 2008. He struck out 89 and walked 63 in 85 2/3 innings at Kinston and Akron. Like Knapp this year, Hagadone's innings were limited in 2010.
The 6-5, 230-pound Hagadone can hit 96 mph, but usually pitches in the low to mid 90s.
"There was a huge buzz around Hagadone a couple of years ago when he was with Boston," said Hart. "He was throwing 96 mph to 97 mph, just what you want to see out of a big left-hander.
"His stuff isn't playing as big as it was two years ago because, like Knapp, he got hurt. It might be a safe bet to put him in the bullpen."
The Indians drafted Packer, 23, out of the University Virginia with the 32nd pick in the 2009 draft. As a sophomore in college, he led the nation in ERA, but struggled as a junior and slipped in the draft. Last year he led the Tribe's minor-league system with a 2.04 ERA and was fifth in strikeouts with 123 in 132 2/3 innings at Lake County and Akron.
"He's a lefty along the lines of Scott Lewis and Jeremy Sowers," said Atkins. "We just hope he's more durable."
GM Chris Antonetti said the Indians have intentionally tried to bring as much pitching into the organization as possible.
"We understand the importance of pitching depth and feel we have several layers of it," said Antonetti.
Here's what Antonetti is talking about:
The rotation at Columbus will be David Huff, Jeanmar Gomez, Corey Kluber, White and McAllister. Huff and Gomez already have big-league experience with the Tribe. In the Columbus bullpen, they'll have Jensen Lewis, Zach Putnam, Josh Judy and Jess Todd who can help the big-league club.
There's more.
At Akron, the rotation will be De La Cruz, Packer, Austin Adams, Joe Gardner and Scott Barnes. The organization considers them all prospects.
In the bullpen they have Hagadone and Bryce Stowell.
Adams and Stowell have hit 100 mph. Stowell was in big-league camp, but struggled to throw strikes. Adams and Gardner are starting, but their path to the big leagues might be faster as relievers. Gardner is a sinker-slider pitcher.
The Indians also have lefty T.J. McFarland, 11-5 at Kinston last year, and right-hander Hector Rondon. McFarland should reach Akron this year, while Rondon is idling on the runway as he recovers from Tommy John surgery. He was one of the team's top prospects until injuring his right elbow at Columbus last year.
"I think they're putting together a good group of pitchers," said Jim Callis, executive director of Baseball America, the bible of minor league baseball, scouting and the draft. "Drew Pomeranz and Alex White are solid.
"The Indians have the have been very aggressive over the last few year in getting pitching on all three levels -- international, trades and the draft."
Added Hart, who built the great Indians teams from 1995 through 2001 on hitting and strong bullpens, "I think the light the Indians see at the end of the tunnel isn't a train. I think it is a light. I think in the next few years you're going to see Kansas City and the Indians take big strides in that division."
To reach this Plain Dealer Reporter: phoynes@plaind.com, 216-999-5158