Owners approved modified changes to kickoffs at league meetings Tuesday that will lead to more touchbacks and minimize the impact of Cribbs and other explosive kick returners.
NEW ORLEANS — NFL players and management don't agree on much during this period of labor strife. But the Browns and return specialist Josh Cribbs agree the changes to the kickoff rules stink.
Owners approved modified changes to kickoffs at league meetings Tuesday that will lead to more touchbacks and minimize the impact of Cribbs and other explosive kick returners.
Almost immediately upon the news breaking that the changes were official, Cribbs sounded off on his Twitter account and in multiple interviews with news organizations.
"It's just eliminating a lot of the opportunities for returners to make their names in the NFL," Cribbs said on ESPN. "It was already tough for a lot of guys like me. This is eliminating future opportunities as well."
The changes move up the kickoff line 5 yards to the 35-yard line and prohibit players on the coverage team from getting more than a 5-yard running start on kickoffs. Kickoffs out of bounds will continue to be brought back to the 40-yard line or at the spot the ball went out, and the two-man blocking wedge was not eradicated.
The key modification, however, is the 20-yard line will remain the spot after a touchback.
In other words, touchbacks will be easier to achieve for teams afraid to kick to Cribbs, and there is no disincentive for doing it. The original proposal brought back touchbacks to the 25. It was restored to the 20 after coaches complained that was too great a giveback in field position.
The Browns were one of six teams that voted against the changes. The rules passed with two votes to spare.
The changes were made to reduce injuries. Without providing data, league officials say injuries were increasing significantly, and coaches and players were calling the kickoff one of the most violent plays in the game because of high-speed collisions.
"I commend their reasoning behind it," Cribbs said. "They're trying to make the game safer, but they say the kickoff coverage can't go past 5 yards, only get a 5-yard head start. That's still room for injury. All you're eliminating is kickoff return units and a big way teams can win and lose football games."
Cribbs contends the league is feigning interest in player safety to advance its agenda of expanding the season to 18 games.
The average landing spot of kickoffs last year was about the 6-yard line. Proponents of the changes say most kickoffs still will fall short of the end zone and be returnable. But even they expect touchbacks to increase from last year's rate of roughly 20 percent of all kickoffs.
In defending his team's vote for the changes, one AFC team official said, "Would I rather give [Browns quarterback] Colt McCoy the ball at the 20 or put the ball in Cribbs' hands?"
The length of kickoffs typically decreases in the cold months, especially in venues such as Cleveland Browns Stadium. But whenever the Browns play in dome stadiums, opponents will kick for the touchback. They have games in Houston's Reliant Stadium, whose retractable roof is almost always closed, and Indianapolis' Lucas Oil Stadium in 2011.
Browns fined? The NFL would not confirm the Browns were one of five teams fined for violating league rules by meeting with players prior to the lockout.
The rules -- on the books for years -- went virtually unenforced until the current labor dispute.
The Browns contend players were just getting acquainted with new coach Pat Shurmur. The club did acknowledge Shurmur gave McCoy a copy of his playbook, but the rules do not specify that as a violation.
Other action on rules: The aggressive crackdown on illegal hits against defenseless players -- which would include suspensions -- was tabled until league meetings in May to clarify and streamline what is allowed and prohibited.
The replay rule was modified to allow the replay official in the stadium booth to have jurisdiction over all scoring plays and not require a coach to use a challenge. This is only on plays ruled a score by the on-field officials, however. If an official rules a play in the end zone was not a score, a coach will have to challenge it. The proposal was modified so coaches can still be granted a third challenge in a game if they have two successful challenges.
The league formally wrote a rule that bans a team from coloring its field blue or red or anything but "a league-approved shade of green."