Never fear ... we wouldn't consider putting a lockout on our weekly readers mailbag.
John Kuntz / The Plain DealerLawrence Vickers may not have much of a future left with the Browns, thanks to the West Coast offense, says Tony Grossi. Hey, Tony: What's Lawrence Vickers' status? Why haven't the Browns tendered him? Or have they already? -- Terry Carbetta, Ashland
Hey, Terry: The Browns have not confirmed any of their tenders -- just the players they signed to new contracts. There is no sign that Vickers has been tendered. I believe the Browns are parting ways with him and plan to use Peyton Hillis as the fullback in the West Coast offense.
Hey, Tony: Matt Roth has been a pretty decent player for us since we picked him up. Where does he fit, if anywhere, on a 4-3 defense? Is he big enough to play end? -- John Timperio, Cambridge, England
Hey, John: Roth certainly is big enough to play end, but he is unsigned and is looking forward to experiencing unrestricted free agency.
Hey, Tony: What would you think of the Browns picking Robert Quinn in the first round and Marvin Austin in the second? It could be the best draft Butch Davis ever had for the Browns. -- Bruce Fagerstrom, Jamestown, N.Y.
Hey, Bruce: Good one. Throw in QB T.J. Yates in a late round, too.
Hey, Tony: Mike Holmgren said he'll be drafting a QB at some point in the draft. Any chance he'll take Texas A&M's Jerrod Johnson? He looked phenomenal before he had to have surgery on his throwing shoulder last off-season, and wasn't at 100 percent when he played so poorly last season. -- Cameron Christie, Allen, Texas
Hey, Cameron: He'd be an excellent prospect to develop. I know the Houston Texans are very high on Johnson and have a bead on him.
Hey, Tony: You recently opined that by the time Brady Quinn reached his third NFL season he was "ruined." Before the 2007 NFL Draft, didn't Notre Dame coach Charlie Weis tell his good friend Browns coach Romeo Crennel that Quinn was NFL ready? What happened? -- Bob Paulson, Solon
Hey, Bob: Yes, that's what we were all told. I really think the Browns did a poor job of committing to Quinn. They sat him behind Derek Anderson in his first year. When Anderson had that fluke 2007 season, Quinn's development was further stymied. When Quinn entered his third season, the Browns changed coaches and offensive systems and again failed to commit to him. Quinn definitely regressed, rather than progressed. Phil Savage used to say when a team picks a QB in the first round, everyone in the organization has to be committed to him. That wasn't the case with Quinn.
Hey, Tony: As a compromise to the NFL 16/18 game issue -- why not just keep 16 regular-season games and make the last two exhibition games a little meaningful such as counting them as "half-games" or using them as tie breakers to move up in playoff position and or to get a better draft position? That would add a little meaning for the fans/TV but not cause coaches to overuse starters. -- Howard Gordon, Cleveland
Hey, Howard: The driving force behind the expanded 18-game season is to create more revenue by charging the networks more money for two more weekends of the regular season. Your idea would not bring in more revenue to the league.
Darron Cummings / Associated PressIs Patrick Peterson such a can't-miss prospect that the Browns couldn't afford to pass him by in the draft? Tony Grossi isn't so sure. Hey, Tony: I get your reasoning for taking a DL in the first round this year, but it always seemed to me that DL was the biggest boom/bust crapshoot. Examples are everywhere. Patrick Peterson, on the other hand, seems like the closest thing to a "can't miss" we've ever seen. If, by some fluke, he was there, don't you have to take him, and take a DL in round 2 in this DL-rich draft? -- Jonathan Kirk, St. Louis, Mo.
Hey, Jonathan: Given the Browns' dearth of defensive linemen, I would say no. If Peterson, in fact, is the best player in the draft, then the defensive lineman available at No. 6 is not going to be that far behind. There's no guarantee the Browns can still find an instant contributor on their defensive front in the second round. If so, he may be the 15th-best at the position. On the other hand, they might be able to take the fourth- or fifth-best cornerback in the second round.
Hey, Tony: We hear plenty of talk about a player "moving up/down the draft boards" with his performance in the combine. In your experience, draft position aside, does a good/bad combine ever translate to the field? That is, are players who tend to up their status in the combine not necessarily become better players, and players who lower their status turn out to be likely busts? Bottom line, how much does the combine really tell scouts about their potential on the field? -- Terry Allen, Washington, D.C.
Hey, Terry: There are probably more examples of players who upped their status with good combines who turned out to be unproductive players. Vernon Gholston comes to mind. I think the best personnel evaluators put far greater credence in a player's history of production on the field than on combine performance.
Hey, Tony: Do you know if the Browns have any interest in former Oakland CB Nnamdi Asomugha? He might have three good years left as a solid corner. Either Eric Wright or Sheldon Brown could then cover the slot, or Brown could move to safety. -- Brent DePue, Hilliard
Hey, Brent: The Browns are committed to building through the draft. Emptying the vault for Asomugha ($10 million to $12 million per year) doesn't make a lot of sense for a team that may need two more years of solid drafting to compete for the playoffs. I don't think adding Asomugha expedites the process for the Browns.
Hey, Tony: What do you think the Browns will be in the free-agent market for (besides a lot of defensive help). Do you think they will be as active as they have been in the past, or are they committed to build through the draft and sign free agents to supplement the roster? -- Ralph Reis, Ft. Mitchell, Ky.
Hey, Ralph: GM Tom Heckert has said he does not expect the Browns to be very active in free agency. Given the need at defensive line, I could see them spending for a player there. But I honestly don't see them adding more than one starting-caliber player otherwise. Possibly a couple of backups.
PD file photoMontario Hardesty may be a revelation in his second season with the Browns, but the team can't assume he will be a reliable backup to Peyton Hillis. Hey, Tony: I am a little surprised no one is concerned about our running back situation. It seems we are in desperate need of a solid backup and might not be able to get one through free agency. Obviously we need to fill a couple holes in the draft before we start considering picking one, but you do see it as a need, right? We can't bank everything on Montario Hardesty, can we? -- Eliot Clasen, Cape Coral, Fla.
Hey, Eliot: You're right. I can see a veteran backup being added even if Hardesty returns to full health. The running back situation behind Hillis last year was a joke.
Hey, Tony: Is Marcus Benard going to be a pure DE or is he going to play a hybrid role ala Jamir Miller? -- Chris Zanon, Canton
Hey, Chris: Looks like Benard will continue to play as a situational pass rusher only.
Hey, Tony: Commissioner Roger Goodell insists the preseason matches don't feature the quality fans deserve, so he believes switching two of them for games that count is preferable. He refuses to consider lower ticket prices for preseason games. What I have not seen discussed is that isn't it logical to presume that with fewer preseason games, the initial regular games will be of an inferior quality, because of less preparation? Is there any consideration -- if the regular season goes to 18 games -- of starting the season earlier, when those two preseason games would have been played? Football in late August and early September is preferable to football in February. It makes more sense to me. -- Erol Altug, Stony Brook, N.Y.
Hey, Erol: If Goodell is successful in orchestrating a change to a 2-18 format, the season would continue to start the weekend after Labor Day. That's what the networks want. Another bye week also would be added, which would drag the regular season well into January and the Super Bowl into late February. While Goodell has used the "poor product" argument to shorten the exhibition season, the true driving force of his plan is to create more revenue by selling two additional weekends of regular season football to the network.
Hey, Tony: What dollar amount, if any, is guaranteed to quarterback Jake Delhomme for the 2011 season? -- William McCormick, La Canada, Calif.
Hey, William: Nothing is guaranteed at this point. But, like any vested veteran of four or more years, as soon as Delhomme appears on the roster in the first week of the regular season, his entire base salary -- $5.4 million, in his case -- is guaranteed.
Hey, Tony: In the past, teams have either moved up or down in the draft based on trading picks, and also occasionally you have players thrown into the deal. With the current state of the CBA up in the air, how does this affect teams trading players in the draft? -- Brandon Hoehn, Delphos
Hey, Brandon: If a CBA is not arrived at, there can be no trades involving players.
Hey, Tony: If there is a lockout and the 2011 season is lost, how do they determine the draft order for 2012? -- Steve DeLong, Jacksonville, N.C.
Hey, Steve: The league has not addressed this possibility.
Hey, Tony: Assuming the two pre-season home game format stays, why could they not drop the price of the preseason ticket to a point where the stadium would fill up and increase the price of the regular season games to cover the difference? Everyone wins ... they would increase revenue and I'm not ripped off $250 for two seats to a preseason game as a season ticket holder.-- John Moore, Waukegan (home town of Otto Graham), Ill.
Hey, John: The NFL has scammed ticket-holders for years by charging, and receiving, full price for exhibition games. Owners see no reason to change that scam without additional revenue coming from additional regular-season games.
Hey, Tony: College football is on almost every day of the week. Any chance NCAA could move a big game or two a week in the void if there's no pro football? -- HoBo, Peyton, Colo.
Hey, HoBo: The NCAA will not mess with NFL Sunday, if that's what you're getting at. Besides, TV contracts are in place and couldn't be changed at this point.
Hey, Tony: Listening to the news about the NFL owners wanting more money for cost of stadiums. I didn't know that they put up any money. If they get more money, then no tax money should be spent on any new stadium. -- Donald Pasqualetti, Reading
Hey, Donald: I think team owners and the players union should contribute more money to the construction of new stadiums.
Hey, Tony: NFL free agency remains in a sort of purgatory until a new CBA gets completed. I would imagine every team would be able to focus almost exclusively on the draft. I see it playing out in one of two ways: either teams use the extra focus to land studs and find late gems or they overanalyze, fall in love with shuttle times and completely whiff. Do you feel this year is different in terms of focus on the draft? If so, does this bode well for Holmgren, Heckert, and the Browns braintrust? -- Tom Stiles, Plymouth, Minn.
Hey, Tom: I think the Browns are well positioned for the draft, irregardless of the CBA machinations. I wouldn't overanalyze it any more than that.
Joshua Gunter / The Plain DealerA weight limit in pro football? Seems like Ahtyba Rubin and his friends might have a pretty good reason for a lawsuit against the NFL. Hey, Tony: I have a question related to player safety. Why not institute a maximum weight limit? Say 225 pounds, maximum, for linemen. If players are really concerned for their safety, this would be a simple solution. -- Bruce, Mentor
Hey, Bruce: Then you would have 300-pounders suing the NFL for discrimination.
Hey, Tony: Tell me we are not going to bypass a top notch receiver in the first round for a D-lineman. Haven't we seen this before? If A.J. Green is there, just draft him! You can get D-linemen in the second, third and later rounds and free agency! -- Matt Jones, Middleburg
Hey, Matt: I can turn it around and say the good teams find receivers in any round. If Green is rated clearly ahead of any defensive lineman on the Browns' draft board at the time of the No. 6 pick, I think the Browns will take him.
Hey, Tony: You've said that if there's a lockout, the Berea facilities won't be available to players. How far does this go? Will the janitorial night shift be able to use the facilities? Where would players be expected to go? -- Mr. P, Worthington
Hey, Mr. P: Players will be locked out. Other employees will continue to do their jobs.
Hey, Tony: I just watched the Auburn Pro Day on espn.com and I saw Tom Heckert, Pat Shurmur, Gil Haskell, Mark Whipple and a couple others paying really close attention to the Cam Newton workout. Do the Browns really have any interest in him? -- Dan Desai, Westlake
Hey, Dan: Yes, they have enough interest to schedule a private workout with him.
Hey, Tony: Talk to me about why Mickey McBride has never been considered for the Hall of Fame? He founded the Browns, hired Paul Brown, and bankrolled (visionary move) players while they were serving in the war in exchange for their services in the post war era. On top of that, in his seven years as owner, the Browns appeared in seven consecutive world championships (winning five), compiled an 83-11-4 (including playoffs) record, and made the successful transition from the AAFC to the NFL. -- Lange, Washington, D.C.
Hey, Lange: In my 14 years on the selection committee, McBride's name has never come up for consideration. It seems to me owners have to do more than "own" to be considered as "contributors" for the Hall. Some owners merely pay the bills. Others immerse themselves in league activities and actually contribute to the growth of the game. I'm sure McBride was an outstanding founding owner. Rightly or wrongly, that doesn't automatically qualify him for the Hall of Fame.
Hey, Tony: I know people always talk about this, but do you think it is a good move for the Browns to trade down during the draft? The 12th pick is the farthest I would trade. If Newton and Blaine Gabbert are both off the board, it won't matter. If either of them are left, I can see San Francisco, Tennessee, Washington or Minnesota all trying to move up to secure a quarterback. With this idea, we could still get a great DL or at worst Julio Jones as well as pick up a second or third round pick. -- Greg S, Chicago, Ill.
Hey, Greg: Trading down always is enticing to a team that has multiple needs to fill. I'm not averse to it. I agree that the Browns should not drop lower than 12th in a trade down. And the price has to be appropriate -- not a sixth-round pick, like the Browns received (twice) in 2009.
Hey, Tony: The Browns have had a couple of good linebackers over the years (Galen Fiss and Clay Matthews come to mind) but never in their history have they had someone who incites fear into opposing offenses. I'm referring to a Sam Huff, Ray Nitschke, Willie Lanier, Dick Butkus, Jack Lambert, Ray Lewis or even a James Harrison-type player who can reap absolute havoc on an offense. Joe Greene once said the only guy he was afraid of in the NFL was Lambert. Is there anyone in this year's draft who fits this mold? Also, who essentially did we take two years ago instead of drafting Clay Matthews III? -- Bill Carothers, Chagrin Falls
Hey, Bill: In the 2009 draft, Matthews was taken 26th by Green Bay. The Browns initially owned the fifth pick, traded down to No. 17, traded down again to No. 19, and then traded down again to No. 21. They ultimately chose center Alex Mack after passing on Matthews four times. Four times! The top defensive prospects who potentially strike fear in opponents are Clemson defensive end DaQuan Bowers, Alabama defensive tackle Marcell Dareus, Auburn defensive tackle Nick Fairley, North Carolina defensive end Robert Quinn, California defensive end Cameron Jordan, Wisconsin defensive end J.J. Watt and Texas A&M linebacker Von Miller.
Hey, Tony: Should the Browns be looking at every top receiver early in the draft, or should they specifically be targeting speed? -- Paul Thiel, Crescent Springs, Ky.
Hey, Paul: To put it in simplest terms, they need a guy who can catch a pass and run away from defenders while maintaining possession of the ball.
Hey, Tony: Since Holmgren and Shurmur have repeatedly stated that Colt McCoy is the starter, is the report that the Browns will be working out Cam Newton a ploy to get a team to trade picks to the Browns to move up? The Browns could conceivably add at least one, if not two more picks in the top 100 if they trade down two or three spots. Is that a realistic scenario? -- Kevin, Chicago, Ill.
Hey, Kevin: I think the Browns are open to anything with the No. 6 pick. They intend to work out all the top quarterbacks to make sure they are not passing on the next great NFL passer.
-- Tony