It's hard to make any major judgments on McCoy, other than he deserves a chance to be the starting quarterback from the opening of minicamp.
Joshua Gunter / The Plain DealerThe confidence expressed by Mike Holmgren and Pat Shurmur in second-year quarterback Colt McCoy is exactly what the franchise needs right now, says Terry Pluto. CLEVELAND, Ohio -- A month of madness is about to begin, but as always, Terry is talkin' ...
About the Browns ...
1. It's good news to hear Mike Holmgren tell The PD's Tony Grossi: "I believe in the young guy [Colt McCoy] we have. ... It works best if you can identify 'the guy,' let him know he's 'the guy,' and train him appropriately to be 'the guy.' It's nice to have all this competition and all this stuff, but it doesn't work very well.
So if you believe in a young man, believe he's 'the guy,' then you have to go with it."
2. Later in the week, coach Pat Shurmur and General Manager Tom Heckert expressed their confidence in McCoy, letting fans know the organization is together on the quarterback question. Realistically, it's hard to know if McCoy will be "the guy" in three years. McCoy will be the team's 10th opening day starting quarterback since 1999. That is a big reason the Browns have had only two winning seasons in that time.
3. McCoy played eight games, completed 61 percent of his passes, threw six touchdowns and nine interceptions. His rating was 74.4. Six of his eight starts came against playoff teams. Five of his nine interceptions came in two games against the Steelers. Baltimore (15-of-29 passing, 3 INTs) also made him look bad.
4. Former coach Eric Mangini said more than once that he couldn't remember any rookie quarterback facing such a demanding schedule so early in his career. McCoy played against Pittsburgh (12-4), Baltimore (12-4), New England (14-2), the Jets (11-5), New Orleans (11-5), Jacksonville (8-8) and Cincinnati (4-12). Mangini often praised McCoy's poise, which he displayed despite the onslaught he endured each week. Four of his eight games were against defenses ranked in the top five.
5. For a rookie quarterback coming from a top-ranked college program and going to a losing NFL team, there is an element of shock as he watches video each week of the next opponent. At Texas, McCoy knew his team often had the most talent on the field. It helps a quarterback's confidence. But that's not the case here, and certainly not in the games McCoy started. Yet Mangini and the other coaches said McCoy didn't seem overwhelmed.
6. My point is it's hard to make any major judgments on McCoy, other than he deserves a chance to be the starting quarterback from the opening of minicamp. Holmgren's comments about the need to "identify the guy" and work with him as the starter is correct. You can always switch to a different "guy" later.
7. Perhaps no other position in team sports undergoes more scrutiny and requires being a team spokesman more than the quarterback. It's why having the coaches' confidence is critical. Derek Anderson never seemed comfortable in the spotlight. Jeff Garcia often looked for reasons to place blame elsewhere -- a real negative. McCoy sounds like a veteran when he handles questions from the media.
8. In 2009, Mangini tried to have a competition between Anderson and Brady Quinn -- because he really didn't believe in either. Quinn ended up as Denver's No. 3 quarterback in 2010 and Anderson started for Arizona in what ESPN.com called "the worst quarterback situation in the NFL." But spending training camp with no one knowing who is the starting quarterback doesn't help a bad situation.
9. Did you notice Oakland nailed former Browns linebacker Kamerion Wimbley with its franchise tag? That means he will be paid about $10 million. Wimbley had nine sacks in 2010, his most since 11 with the Browns as a rookie in 2006. When the Browns traded Wimbley for a third-round pick, it seemed as if they gave away a solid player for an iffy draft pick. Not having to pay Wimbley's salary, the Browns were able to sign free agent linebacker Scott Fujita. But just as important, they used that third-rounder to draft McCoy.
10. I sense there will be a lot of rumors, hints and reports that the Browns will go for a receiver in the first round, but in the end, they will probably take a defensive player. This draft is supposed to be strong where the Browns are so weak -- the defensive line. Checking a list of Heckert's first-rounders with the Eagles, you find two wide receivers, one offensive tackle, two defensive tackles, one defensive end and one cornerback. His first two picks with the Browns were defensive backs.
Marvin Fong / The Plain DealerIs it possible that the Cavaliers may have more reason to enjoy the rest of the season than anyone had anticipated? About the Cavaliers ...
1. Here's something I never thought I'd write even a few days ago, what if the Cavs actually win some games? Most of us have assumed they'd finish with the NBA's worst record; a 26-game losing streak will lead to that thinking. But they have won three of five, beating the Knicks, Lakers and Clippers. On nights when they don't play hard, Byron Scott calls them out in public and pushes them in private practices. Having the NBA's worst record is no longer a given. Yes, that could hurt the Cavs' draft position.
2. It's hard to know if Baron Davis is sincere when he posted on his Facebook page about being excited to join his new team. Give the L.A. native credit for being smart and accepting the fact he's been traded, rather than immediately causing problems -- as some players in his position would.
3. Less than 24 hours after the deal with the Clippers was announced, Davis spoke to Cavs General Manager Chris Grant and coach Byron Scott, saying all the right things. All that can change, but it seems Davis, 31, has learned a few things along the way -- as the younger Davis would have screamed publicly or pouted about leaving his hometown.
4. The Cavs will probably start Davis, once he settles in. Scott knows it's important for the veteran to be in the lineup. But Davis can split time with point guard Ramon Sessions. Davis has a grumpy knee that has been acting up, and he made noise with the Clippers about playing too many minutes. In his past 10 games, he has been averaging 35 minutes, scoring 16.3 points on 42 percent shooting with 7.6 assists.
5. Here's what Celtics coach Doc Rivers told reporters about rookie Luke Harangody after he was traded to the Cavs: "I love Luke because every day he did the same thing -- he played hard like a kamikaze. I was most afraid of him in practice with our guys ... But I love him, the way he played, and he never complained. He just did his job everyday."
6. Rivers on Semih Erden, also traded to the Cavs: "He's going to be good player. I don't think people realize how injured Semih was, not only with the groin, but his shoulder. He's probably going to need surgery on both. But he knew we were down and he played. That was pretty cool."
7. Yes, Erden has been playing with injuries, and the Cavs are aware the shoulder could be a problem. But they expect him to make it through the season, and not to have any long-term problems if he has shoulder surgery. The 7-footer from Turkey should see a lot of time as a backup center this season.
8. The Cavs also think Harangody can help as a bench player. He's 6-7, 240 pounds. His height is best for small forward, his weight and strength better suited for power forward. That's why he dropped to the No. 52 pick despite being a 22-point scorer and averaging 10.2 rebounds over his last three years at Notre Dame.
9. Talking dollars: Harangody and Erden are both under contract next season for about $500,000. When the Cavs acquired them, they had to cut Leon Powe -- and they paid him the remaining $200,000 on his contract. Finally, Davis has $12 million of his $14 million salary in 2012-13 guaranteed.
10. Just 48 hours after being out-rebounded by 20 by Houston, the Cavs turned around and outrebounded the Knicks by the same margin -- which is staggering in the NBA. The key is J.J. Hickson, who can be an elite rebounder when motivated. He had 15 against the Knicks and Lakers, 14 against the Clippers. He's had at least 14 rebounds in 11 of his last 22 games.
About the Indians ...
Chuck Crow / The Plain DealerMatt LaPorta has been receiving some defensive instruction from Mike Hargrove in Indians training camp, but it's LaPorta's bat that is going to determine his true value to the Tribe in 2011. 1. I know this is the kind of hopeful (perhaps wildly so) note you read early in spring training, but Matt LaPorta has impressed the Tribe by losing weight, adding muscle and swinging with more power. Much of last season, LaPorta failed to use his hips and legs in his swing, waving at pitches with his arms. Part of the problem might have been that he hadn't fully recovered from hip and toe surgery after the 2009 season. So maybe he will begin to resemble the guy who was leading the minors in homers when the Indians traded for him in 2008.
2. Even more upbeat spring stuff: Lefty Drew Pomeranz impressed coaches with his scoreless inning during the intrasquad game. He was the team's top pick in 2010, but signed late and didn't pitch in the minors last summer. At 6-4 with a fastball averaging 93 mph and an impressive curve, the Indians want fans to know he's not the typical soft-tossing lefty starter that has recently passed through Progressive Field. He is expected to open the season at Class A Kinston, then move to Class AA Akron -- the same path 2009 top pick Alex White followed in 2010.
3. Guest instructor Kenny Lofton has been working with Shin-Soo Choo and Michael Brantley on base running, and bunting for hits. Lofton was never effective when trying a sacrifice bunt, but he'd drop down five to 10 bunts a season for singles.
4. In my arcane campaign for the Indians to get off to a decent start so I can at least pretend this could be a fun season, I offer this: ESPN's Buster Olney looked at the schedules of American League teams for the first six weeks of the season and it's good news for the Tribe. Only 12 of 34 games are against teams that had winning records last season. It's the second easiest schedule in the AL. Olney wrote, "On paper, Cleveland has a chance to get off to a good start."
5. Not much has been made of Trevor Crowe barely being able to throw after having elbow surgery. Even healthy, Crowe is a long shot to make the team. But he does give them depth in center field, where Grady Sizemore (microfracture knee surgery) is not certain to be ready for the opener. Brantley will start in center. But after him, the Indians have no one. Choo played a little center early in his career with the Mariners, and struggled.
6. While the Indians are making some optimistic noise about Anthony Reyes making a real bid to be the fifth starter, he must be a tremendous long shot. His arm surgery was a major elbow reconstruction. He has battled arm problems for years. Mitch Talbot might also be a concern. He says he is healthy, but he missed two months in 2009 with elbow problems. After June 10, he was 2-9 with a 5.65 ERA as he battled some back and other minor injuries. The Indians point out Talbot was 2-2 (2.89) in four September starts.
7. Josh Judy, who has impressed manager Manny Acta, could be a surprise addition to the bullpen. The right-hander looked good in Arizona last spring, then had minor arm problems. But after June 1, he was 2-0 with a 2.03 ERA between Class AA Akron and Class AAA Columbus. He was drafted in the 34th round in 2007. Judy, 25, has 244 strikeouts in 216 minor-league innings with a 2.74 ERA.