What labor strife? When it comes to football, there's never an off-season on opinions from readers -- and Tony Grossi.
John Kuntz / The Plain DealerPeyton Hillis could be the Browns' long "difference maker" right now, while the Steelers and Ravens have several such players, says Tony Grossi. Hey, Tony: The offense-defense debate over the draft pick is irrelevant. The Browns simply need difference-making players who can change a game. Do you think we have any right now? How many more do we need to be remotely worrisome to the Ravens and Steelers? -- David King, Joelton, Tenn.
Hey, David: By the strictest definition, I don't think the Browns really have a difference-making player. If you stretch the definition somewhat, I might put Peyton Hillis in that category. Potentially, Joe Haden and T.J. Ward might get there, but they not right now. I think the difference-makers on the Ravens are Ray Lewis, Ed Reed, Ray Rice and, yes, Joe Flacco. The Steelers have Ben Roethlisberger, James Harrison, LaMarr Woodley, Troy Polamalu, Mike Wallace and Rashard Mendenhall.
Hey, Tony: One or the reasons the Browns are bad every year is poor drafts. What draft do you think was the worst and set the Browns back the most? -- Robby Whitmyer, Louisville, Ohio
Hey, Robby: The 2009 draft. Because it was the most recent bad draft. Of course, the first two in 1999 and 2000 probably did the Browns the most damage because they squandered 14 extra picks given to them in their expansion deal. So sad.
Hey, Tony: I hope you and Mary Kay are getting some rest, as you have had a very busy "off-season." It is a shame that we let Billy Cundiff go. He is a tremendous kicker, both in touch-backs and field goals. I know things are all up in the air with the CBA, but any chance the Browns would be interested in resigning him? I think he is a free agent. -- Nancy, Baltimore
Hey, Nancy: Cundiff was re-signed by the Ravens. He had a monstrous season in 2010. The difference in his numbers were extraordinary. Very strange. But I would take Phil Dawson any day over him for his consistency and ability to kick in bad weather.
Hey, Tony: Many years ago the Browns were in a scouting cooperative in order to save money and cover more prospects. Are there any such cooperatives today and if so, are the Browns in one? P.S. Aren't you tired of strength-of-arm questions? -- Ted Belak, Sierra Madre, Calif.
Hey, Ted: Many years ago the Browns were a member of a scouting service called CEPO that eventually changed its name to National. They now are one of about eight NFL teams not affiliated with either National or BLESTO, the other scouting service. P.S. The answer is yes.
Hey, Tony: Colt McCoy has been out making the rounds at the Super Bowl. He has been quoted saying that he is working with Pat Shurmur on the offense. He said that he will start working with the WR's in the offseason if there is a lockout. I have not heard an official word that Colt has been named the starter. I think it shows initiative. What is your thought? -- Chuck Claypool, Dallas
Hey, Chuck: In a story I wrote in December, President Mike Holmgren said, "At the very least, Colt has earned the right to compete for the starting job." So I think that's where things stand. I couldn't even name who's competing against him at this point because Jake Delhomme might not be back and Seneca Wallace is unsigned.
Morry Gash / Associated PressSorry, but Aaron Rodgers won't be playing because it's his designated "off week" when the NFL goes to an 18-game schedule ... yeah, that's going to go over well with Green Bay season-ticket buyers. Hey, Tony: It seems to me that there's a very simple solution to this whole 18-game schedule mess. The NFL would just have to make a rule that each player can only be active for 16 games. That way the players don't technically play any more games, and they get two weeks off. Second stringers will get more playing time and a chance to shine too. Plus, the record books wouldn't be made obsolete. It would be a win-win situation for both the players and owners. -- Brad Grzyb, Cleveland
Hey, Brad: I applaud you for suggesting something I have not seen or read before. Outstanding. There are a number of problems with your idea, however. What happens if you have injuries at, say, quarterback, and your starter already has played his 16 games? Another is how do you "sell" two games in New England that Tom Brady doesn't play? Or two in Green Bay that Aaron Rodgers doesn't play? I don't think GMs and coaches -- and probably not even players -- would go for it.
Hey, Tony: I was wondering what other head coaches in the league call their own plays? I mean can't we just hire a coach and an offensive coordinator like most teams? Don't get me wrong, I'm optimistic, but it seems like it's always something with the Browns, you know? -- Jason Smith, Santa Rosa, Calif.
Hey, Jason: Start with Green Bay's Mike McCarthy, the Super Bowl-winning coach. Other head coaches who called their own plays last year include: Houston's Gary Kubiak, San Diego's Norv Turner, Buffalo's Chan Gailey, Philadelphia's Andy Reid, Dallas' Jason Garrett, New Orleans' Sean Payton, Arizona's Ken Whisenhunt. Also, before they were fired, Denver's Josh McDaniels and Minnesota's Brad Childress. So that's nine of 32. Not that unusual.
Hey, Tony: I'm probably late to this realization but it just hit me that the biggest thing that the Browns lost from not existing from '96-'98 was the loss of a continuity of culture. When Ozzie Newsome left for Baltimore everything about the Cleveland Browns left with him. Recreating the 49ers, the Cowboys, and the '91-'95 Browns/Belichick Patriots was like trying to transplant a non-matching kidney into someone. Of course if I owned the team from a way back, Marty Schottenheimer would be going into his 27th year with the team. Any thoughts? -- Walter Schonhardt, Hawthorne, Calif.
Hey, Walter: You're right. When the Browns restarted in 1999, they tried to transplant the 49ers culture in Cleveland. That created a wobbly foundation from which the franchise has never recovered. I think Schottenheimer was great for his time, but I wouldn't have brought him back. The organization needs to create a new winning atmosphere, not try to replicate an old one.
Hey, Tony: I know in the past there was some debate about Gary Collins getting into the HOF. Collins' numbers are similar to Lynn Swann's. Do you ever see a time that the Seniors Committee would consider Collins? Also, from a journalistic point of view, why do so many local newspapers and television stations from around the country send people to cover the Super Bowl. I can see reporters from the cities of the teams playing, but from everywhere else? It would seem like it would be a lot cheaper to use wire services or network feeds. Is it really necessary? -- Joe Bailey, Newark, N.Y.
Hey, Joe: Collins was a great receiver and punter from an era totally different from what we're seeing now. His numbers are dwarfed by the stats put up by the receivers of the 2000s. Since so many receivers with significantly higher statistics are now routinely denied -- or delayed -- induction into the Hall of Fame, I fear Collins' candidacy might never receive another thorough review. The Seniors Committee is buried in a backlog of some 75 overlooked yet deserving players and most of them are defensive players because the hall has such an offensive slant. On your second question -- a very fair one -- I would answer that it's important for the top newspapers to send their beat writer to cover the Super Bowl. For a few reasons -- to pursue stories of particular interest to the writer's team and market, to cultivate league sources that typically congregate at the Super Bowl, and to establish its newspaper as a player in league issues that affect its team and market.
Hey, Tony: You keep claiming the Rooneys are the reason for the Steelers' success. If you did your homework you would see the Rooneys ran a laughingstock team for 40 years in Pittsburgh before they hired Noll. It is Noll who turned things around and changed the culture. The Browns had a ton of success before they started changing coaches like shirts, in fact all of our titles came under two coaches that covered nearly 30 years. Now we change every few years and kill ourselves. Noll had one win in 1969, but no one ran him and it took off. Before you tell me "times have changed" Jimmy Johnson had one win 20 years later in '89 and he did well. -- Michael Spitale, Galena, Ohio
Hey, Michael: Noll had a ton of help from his personnel director, who authored some of the greatest drafts in the history of the NFL. His name: Art Rooney Jr. I don't know what your point is about Noll and Johnson winning one game in one season. Changing coaches is not the problem for the Browns. Choosing wrong coaches is the problem. I once asked Dan Rooney his philosophy on choosing coaches. He answered, "Find the right coach and keep him."
Hey, Tony: The NFL is often described as a copycat league, having said that, why don't other teams copy what Pittsburgh does? -- Mike B, Dover, Ohio
Hey, Mike: Green Bay has, to an extent. So has Arizona. One of the biggest oversights the Browns have made is trying to copy Baltimore instead of Pittsburgh. Why have Ohio natives Dick LeBeau and Dom Capers never worked for the Browns? Yet the Browns anoint Ozzie Newsome rejects like Phil Savage and George Kokinis and hire every Bill Belichick assistant coach that leaves New England? Mind boggling.
Hey, Tony: I see that your expectations are for the Browns to improve next year with at least one more win. Don't you think that is unrealistic? This current team is old and lacking talent, playing in a tough division, having to retool the entire defense, and add significant players in a new system to the offense. Do you think Holmgren realized this and that is why he did not return to the sideline? After two more years of losing, but an upgrade in talent, would Holmgren then come in and coach? If a miracle happens and the Browns have a winning record, Shurmur stays. But if we continue our losing ways, but improve the team, Holmgren takes over as coach. It's a win-win for him. Your thoughts? -- Bill Reinke, Cape Canaveral, Fla.
Hey, Bill: Six wins unrealistic? Teams have gone from one win to division champion overnight. Yes, they're in a tough division, but Cincinnati unseated Baltimore and Pittsburgh just two years ago. So it can be done. Holmgren has decided that he doesn't have the energy to be a head coach any longer. I don't see his energy level increasing in two years.
Chuck Crow / The Plain DealerHas Eric Wright played his last game with the Browns? Tony Grossi thinks it's a possibility. Hey, Tony: Eric Wright has never been a strong cornerback for the Browns. He was burned countless times and even benched last season. How many years are left on his contract? Is he still a viable starter for the Browns in 2011? -- Dustin S., Washington, D.C.
Hey, Dustin: His contract is up and I believe he will leave in free agency.
Hey, Tony: I know Mike Holmgren is president and everyone wants to make an issue of Bob LaMonte's influence, but it seems to me the one person with a connection to all new hires is Tom Heckert. Is this accurate or just my imagination? -- Chris Crandall, Estero, Fla.
Hey, Chris: Heckert, also a LaMonte client, clearly has had a major influence in the reshaping of the football operations. He worked with Shurmur in Philadelphia and reshaped the personnel department with several new hires. New defensive coordinator Dick Jauron, however, is clearly a Holmgren hire, as Jauron was on Holmgren's coaching staff in Green Bay and did not join the Eagles till Heckert already was in Cleveland.
Hey, Tony: Can you recommend a good book about the AFL-NFL merger? Do you know of any good books about the USFL? -- Kevin Zerbey, Rocky River
Hey, Kevin: The best and most authoritative book I've seen on the old AFL is "The Birth of the New NFL," by Larry Felser, long-time columnist of the Buffalo News. On the USFL, the only book I've seen is "The $1 League: Rise and Fall of the United States Football League" by Jim Byrne.
Hey, Tony: I want to know plain and simple what it would be like if the Browns made it to the Super Bowl? Would it be the same as if the Cubs were in the World Series? We would have to be the underdogs everybody around the nation would be rooting for, right? -- Justin Sacco, Phoenix
Hey, Justin: Remember what it was like when the Indians reached the World Series in 1995 and 1997? Multiply it by 10. That's would it be like.
Hey, Tony: I can understand somewhat why the Dallas Cowboys hired Rob Ryan, but what did the Miami Dolphins see in Brian Daboll? -- Mark Di Vincenzo, Newport News, Va.
Hey, Mark: He speaks the language of coach Tony Sparano. Also, I'm sure he was recommended highly by Bill Parcells through Eric Mangini. Despite the Miami owner's gesture of giving Sparano a multi-year contract extension, the truth is Sparano and his staff are on a one-year trial. If the Dolphins don't make a big splash in 2012, they all will be gone, I believe.
Hey, Tony: At the time of the hiring of Dick Jauron, it was suggested Cleveland knew where to get the players to change from a 3-4 to a 4-3 defense. If/when the collective bargaining situation is resolved, won't there be many more free agents available than in previous years, due to the lead up to a potential labor conflict this year? Could that be what Holmgren, Heckert and Schurmur mean? Though free agency has not been any gold mine in the past, would the larger number of potential free agents make this a better year to find quality players? -- Wayne Hopewell, Colorado City, Colo.
Hey, Wayne: Everyone knows the April draft is strong in defensive linemen. They can pick up two linemen in the draft, one in free agency and perhaps another in trade. Free agency is the least desirable method because it's the most expensive and it's proven to not be a panacea. Very, very few are the free agents who go on to help their team to the Super Bowl. Reggie White and Charles Woodson come to mind, but there have been few in 18 years of NFL free agency.
Hey, Tony: The Super Bowl showed you can beat the Steelers and Ravens with the West Coast Offense. Now it's up to the front office to get the right players. What do you think is the top 3 positions to fill and who would you like to see us get? -- Joe Maloney, Saramento, Calif.
Hey, Joe: The obvious needs on offense are wide receiver (two) and running back. Think touchdowns. I can't give you names because it's not yet known if free agency will take place this year and which players would qualify.
Scott Shaw / The Plain DealerCris Carter has a Cavaliers jersey while being honored during the team's Black Heritaage Celebration, but he's yet to get a yellow blazer from Canton. Hey, Tony: As a member on the Hall of Fame committee, can you explain why Cris Carter is not a HOF member yet? This just absolutely baffles me. -- Pete North, North Olmsted
Hey, Pete: He is deserving. But so were the seven members elected on Feb. 5. The problem most people don't consider is the bylaws of the Hall of Fame call for a minimum of four new members and a maximum of seven. When there are clearly more than seven deserving candidates, some will be shut out for another year. That's what's happened to Carter for two years now. What also hurt Carter was the logjam at receiver involving him, Andre Reed and Tim Brown. They seemed to divide votes among the 44 selectors. In the last meeting, there was a tad more support for Reed than for Carter. It's not all about the numbers, but Carter's are hard to ignore.
Hey, Tony: Would you agree that the success of the Green Bay franchise is a strong argument in favor of localized, public ownership, as opposed to the tradition of self-indulgent, absentee private ownership of sports teams? -- Steve Gaylo, Thompson
Hey, Steve: The Green Bay situation is unique. One reason is it's legislated to be unique. No other team in the NFL is allowed to have community/public ownership. But think about the concept and ask why doesn't the NFL allow it -- no single owner, accountability to shareholders, with all profits funneled back into team operations. Seems to me the way to go.
Hey, Tony: Presumably the Browns are switching to a 4-3 but I don't think anything has been formally announced. Is it possible that a reason might be that the staff is evaluating the talent on the roster and what's available via the draft before making this determination? -- Ken Knapp, Hallandale Beach, Fla.
Hey, Ken: No, I think the lack of any formal announcement has to do with the organization's continuing inability to recognize the importance of delivering its message and plan to its fan base. The head coach should have been making the media rounds by now. The assistant coaches should have been formally introduced by now. These easy steps would serve the team's fan base better than to have endless speculation about the new coach's plans. They are intending to field a 4-3 defense and a West Coast offense.
Hey, Tony: Do you see the Browns drafting a wideout as the first pick? -- Johnny D'ambrosia, Garfield Heights
Hey, Johnny: I see the Browns drafting a defensive lineman, though I reserve the right to change my mind.
Hey, Tony: Don't you think the fix was in with Shurmur signing? You said Holmgren wanted a young offensive lackey to mentor, so why a selection committee? Why Fewell? Holmgren had said he has know Shurmur for years and they spoke last season about QBs. Don't you think if Mangini had been let go last year that Shurmur would have been the lackey appointed then? What about the contract, did the lackey get more $$ than Mangini? -- Redd Schmitt, Erie, Pa.
Hey, Redd: Maybe Holmgren wanted Shurmur to get a second year of experience with the Rams as an offensive coordinator. Terms of Shurmur's contract have been kept under wraps so far. The going rate for a first-time head coach is about $9 million over four years. That would be less than what Mangini got.
Hey, Tony: Please don't predict that the Steelers are in decline again next season. I can't stand to see them in another Super Bowl! -- Walt Goodfield, Mentor
Hey, Walt: One of my all-time brain camps, I suppose.
Hey, Tony: I know that a lot of fans want the Browns to go with a WR in the first round, but I couldn't help to notice that no receivers from Green Bay were drafted any higher than the second round. Our receivers are second rounders for a reason. So I would have to think that talent-wise, they cant be much less or much more talented than Green Bay's receivers. Do you think our guys have the talent? Perhaps a change in offensive philosophy will show their true skills? -- David Johnson, Lorain
Hey, David: Yes, I believe the new offense being implemented will benefit the receivers and expose their true talent level. I think they're better than shown in the past offense. I'm not sure how much better, however.
Hey, Tony: The middle linebacker spot is one the most important cogs in any defensive scheme. In our current transition we lack not only depth, but players who could log significant playing time. Is this a more important need than people think? Tom Heckert seems to favor larger players at the position like Stewart Bradley, which makes players like Casey Matthews less likely. Any ideas what direction they are heading? -- Chris Zanon, Canton
Hey, Chris: You're right in saying the MLB spot -- or lack thereof -- is an important need under the radar. I think Heckert is totally aware of it and probably would fill that position with a veteran acquired in trade, free agency or release from another team. I agree that Casey Matthews is not a good fit in a 4-3.
Hey, Tony: Between articles and comments I see a lot of people say draft a QB. I want Colt to get his shot. With the Browns he has a ton of upside. Have you heard much about Tyrod Taylor of Virginia Tech? I think he would be a good fit in the West Coast. I'm not a Jake Locker fan; he lacks a lot of intangibles. -- Chris Cheney, Elyria
Hey, Chris: He's an interesting player -- extremely mobile, not quite as accurate as you'd like, and shorter than McCoy. A late-round prospect. Probably not the answer.
Hey, Tony: Any character issues with A.J. Green? By character issues I mean is he considered a diva like Braylon Edwards was coming out of college? I am aware that he missed several games for selling merchandise, but that doesn't really bother me as I see that as the player's personal property. It's the "I'm bigger than the team" attitude that truly worries me. -- Mike P, Mayfield Village
Hey, Mike: I will get a good read of Green from my personal observations at the NFL combine in Indianapolis later this month.
Hey, Tony: I'm not smart enough to know how strong a QB's arm needs to be, but watching Aaron Rodgers in the Super Bowl certainly raised arm strength questions. I'm wondering if Colt McCoy has the ability to zip short passes into tight spaces with enough speed to get the ball past an outstretched defender. It seems to me that with the coverage talent in our division, that's where arm strength is important (rather than deep routes). -- Stan Himes, West Des Moines, Iowa
Hey, Stan: You're right on point. Rodgers had Troy Polamalu spinning around this way and that way, one step late all game. I'm anxious to see McCoy perform in the new offense and hopeful it will maximize what he does well and limit what he doesn't or can't.
Hey, Tony: Once again I am sitting here after another Super Bowl watching someone elses team win and feeling super depressed. So I decided recently to put myself on a five-year plan where all the things I would like to see and have happen in my life kind of line up where I would like them to be -- this includes the Browns getting to the Super Bowl and (hopefully) winning it. If you were to make any kind of prediction on where you think the Browns might be as a team in five years, what do you see, and what are your expectations? -- Eric Myers, Victoria, Minn.
Hey, Eric: Good lord, I can't even correctly predict what they'll do in a given game, let alone five years down the road. I will say this: For Browns fans to see their team in a Super Bowl in five years, Mike Holmgren and Tom Heckert are going to have to bat around .800 on every personnel decision they make. They also have to get lucky on a few players nobody expects to be big contributors. Like a future Josh Cribbs or Peyton Hillis.
Hey, Tony: You said Rodgers makes throws that McCoy may only dream about making. What throws were they? There is no doubt that Rodgers is an amazingly talented quarterback. But, the most impressive thing was his accuracy and hitting his receivers in stride. I believe McCoy has that ability and it should only get better as he gets more experience. McCoy is an accurate passer and can make the throws necessary to run the style of offense that Green Bay used to beat the Steelers. What am I missing? Is it strictly the lack of "arm strength" he supposedly doesn't have? -- Matthew Yoder, Newark, Del.
Hey, Matthew: Did you see Rodgers laser the ball through the small windows of Pittsburgh defenders? The 21-yard TD to Greg Jennings at the goal line? The 31-yard play to Jennings in the middle of the field on third-and-10 in the fourth quarter? None of Rodgers' passes hung and gave Pittsburgh defenders time to make plays on them. That's what I'm talking about.
Hey, Tony: What are the odds that the Browns go after any big name free agent? There are a ton of young, great players available on both sides of the ball. Stephen Tulloch or Tamba Hali could be cornerstones in the new defense. Then there's obviously WRs like Sidney Rice or Vincent Jackson. Come on Tony, give me some hope! -- Stan I, Solon
Hey, Stan: They would serve the team better by producing a great draft. Anything in free agency would be gravy, but I wouldn't occupy resources with veteran players in free agency. There's obviously a need for bodies at certain positions, but don't count on free agents to lift the team out of its abyss. Needs to happen through the draft.
Hey, Tony: I think the Browns should go with a corner with the #6 pick. Both Patrick Peterson and Prince Amukamara are rated even higher than Joe Haden was last year. I understand the pressing need on our D-line, but picking a corner could upgrade two, possibly three positions in one pick. Sheldon Brown is getting a bit slow to run with fast receivers. So the new corner takes over his starting job, Brown moves to safety in place of Abe Elam, and hopefully Eric Wright has a bounce back year playing nickel behind possibly the best young corner tandem in the league. Would I make a good GM? -- Dan I, Mayfield
Hey, Dan: I think cornerback is second on the list of urgent needs on defense behind defensive line. Wouldn't surprise me if they took one of the two CBs first if he is rated ahead of the DLs on their board.
Hey, Tony: Regarding the labor issue, what I feel isn't being talked about is the fact the salary cap may not be included in a new deal. I love the parity. Without it, I'm afraid we'll see the Redskins and Cowboys with $160 million salaries and the Bills and Bengals carrying only $35 million in salaries. Welcome to MLB. What are you hearing about the salary cap and what does the future of the NFL look like without it? -- John Benson, Brecksville
Hey, John: I'm assuming any new deal will reinstitute the salary cap. The future of the NFL does not look healthy without it.
Hey, Tony: Obviously the Browns need to keep building on quality drafts. Is there any chance the Browns go after free agents Woodley or Ngata? -- Mark Lasher, Bangor, Pa.
Hey, Mark: Any question about free agency is impossible to answer at this time. If this were a regular off-season, I would say, no, there's no chance either player will be available.
Hey, Tony: How do teams decide on signing a player off an opposing team's practice squad? Do scouts attend other teams practices? Word of mouth? Hunch? Old film? During a season you see a lot of turnover. -- Dave Martin, West Harrison, Ind.
Hey, Dave: Just about every player on every team's practice squad has been scouted in the pre-draft process by every other team. So everybody has a scouting report. Scouts do not attend other team's practices, but they may have old film of them from college or in training camp.
Hey, Tony: To help you muzzle all of the holdover Mangini fans, you should not only remind them of his awful record during his tenure, but also of his utter incompetence during the 2009 draft. Recall that he sent our No. 5 pick (Mark Sanchez) to the Jets for their No. 17 (Alex Mack), 52 (David Veikune) and scrap-heap Jets Elam, Ratliff and Coleman. Just two years and several roster cuts later and only Mack remains of that not-so genius trade. While I really like Mack, we could have had our QB of the future in Freeman or Sanchez. Heck we could have anchored our defense with studs BJ Raji and Clay Matthews Jr. Do my fellow fans have that low of a Football IQ that they don't realize that he was just a marginal head coach at best? -- Hoa, Los Angeles
Hey, Hoa: Amen, brother.
Hey, Tony: Why are you so in love with big arms? Didn't we just have a guy whose passes could cut through the gusty winds of Lake Erie but couldn't spell his name in D.A.? Isn't there more to playing the position than arm strength? -- Devin Hernan, Concord Township
Hey, Devin: Every Super Bowl, I come away with the same observation: The Browns don't have a guy that can make that throw. Do you want to reach the Super Bowl or merely be competitive? That's the question you have to answer at the quarterback position.
-- Tony