Browns apparently willing to part with a third-round pick if Kaepernick restructures his current deal. But questions abound.
BEREA, Ohio - Adam Schefter's tweet about Colin Kaepernick wanting to play for the Browns created excitement and confusion Friday morning.
Was it a fake Twitter account? Had one of football's most respected insiders been hacked? The answers to both were "no."
Naturally, it led to a third question: Why would the disgruntled Niners quarterback, who lost his starting job to Blaine Gabbert, prefer the rebuilding Browns to the Super Bowl champion Broncos? Those are the two teams expressing the most interest.
Browns over Broncos is one of several aspects of the Kaepernick rumors that don't make much sense.
The Broncos, minus a few free-agent defections, are loaded and run by John Elway and Gary Kubiak. The Browns were 3-13 last season and lost 40 percent of their offensive line in free agency.
Maybe Kaepernick prefers the Browns' bolder shade of orange. (Thank you, Alec Scheiner, thank you.) In fact, he has great respect for new Browns coach Hue Jackson, according to Schefter, and that's what is fueling his desire. Jackson has coveted Kaepernick since he coached the Raiders in 2011 and saw the Niners trade up to select him No. 36 overall.
Here's a sentiment not many have shared recently: Colin Kaepernick wants to play in Cleveland. Respects Hue Jackson. Browns-Niners talking.
-- Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) March 11, 2016
But if the Browns are willing to part with a third-round pick, as cleveland.com's Mary Kay Cabot reports, why allow two of their best offensive linemen, Alex Mack and Mitchell Schwartz, escape in free agency? The club failed to retain four valuable starters in what appears to be the first stage of a lengthy franchise rebuild.
Related: Browns willing to part with third-round pick for Kaepernick
Kaepernick's game, in decline the past two seasons, fell apart in 2015 when the Niners began a similar makeover. Whispers about the quarterback's leadership and commitment to the playbook and film study started to surface. Even at his dynamic best, Kaepernick struggled to work through his progressions and play from the pocket.
Does this sound vaguely familiar to a quarterback the Browns released on Friday?
Of course, the 28-year-old Kaepernick doesn't have the off-field baggage requiring six hotel bellhops to move him into Berea. He's no Johnny Manziel. He's a sculpted 6-foot-4, 225-pounder who takes pride in displaying his six pack, not drinking it.
Kaepernick, who had the Niners within five yards of a Super Bowl title in 2012, would be an immediate upgrade over 36-year-old Josh McCown. He's younger and more mobile. Jackson is noted for his work with quarterbacks and confidence in himself. So you understand the coach's belief he can get Kaepernick playing to his 2012-13 levels when he won three road playoff games - as many as Joe Montana and Steve Young combined.
It's also worth mentioning the quarterback's collapse last season came after coach Jim Harbaugh and gifted offensive coordinator Greg Roman left town.
But as NFL analyst Ross Tucker observed Friday, the passer's QB rating and yards per attempt have dwindled in each of his four seasons as a starter. There are similarities with Robert Griffin III, another dual-threat quarterback who took the league by storm in 2012 and could not sustain his success because he failed to evolve as a pocket passer.
Kaepernick YPA last 4 years: 8.3, 7.7, 7.0, 6.6
Kap Passer Rating last 4 years: 98.3, 91.6, 86.4, 78.5
He's "GOING THE WRONG WAY"
-- Ross Tucker (@RossTuckerNFL) March 11, 2016
While Kaepernick's rushing attempts increased, he's not necessarily nimble. He doesn't extend plays in the pocket like Russell Wilson or Ben Roethlisberger with a deft step here or there. He's a strong runner and it's fair to wonder how much longer a quarterback requiring three off-season surgeries can maintain that style of play.
Kaepernick also was not a core leader on a club that made three consecutive trips to the NFC title game. (Alex Smith guided them to the 2011 conference final.) Frank Gore, Justin Smith, Patrick Willis and Joe Staley were the respected voices of the Niners' room. Kaepernick struggled to make that transition a year ago as he assumed more responsibility.
As the elite defense and solid running game disappeared, Kaepernick could not rally his teammates. He was benched with a 2-6 mark, completing 59 percent of his passes and sporting one of the league's worst QB ratings (78.5).
Could he emerge as a leader here with Jackson's backing and offensive knowledge? Even with a supporting cast as suspect as the one in San Francisco? Perhaps. But if the Browns get Kaepernick to restructure his contract - apparently a must for any deal to be finalized - he still resembles a bridge quarterback.
It would be a mistake for the Browns not to use their No. 2 pick on either Carson Wentz or Jared Goff. Neither is a sure-fire pick, but the organization hasn't been in this position to select the top QB since 1999. Such a scenario leads to another question: Would Kaepernick mentor an heir apparent? The guess here is no.
Kaepernick views himself as a franchise quarterback. He's still attempting to refine his game as evidenced by his 2015 off-season workouts with Kurt Warner. Entering his sixth season, however, Kaepernick is likely a finished product for better or worse.
Maybe Jackson thinks that's enough to revitalize the Browns' offense. All good coaches have egos and they believe in their abilities to shape and remold talent.
We'll see how the coming days play out and if the Browns can craft a deal. I might be willing to part with a third rounder for Kaepernick provided they draft a quarterback. But there's still plenty about this pursuit that doesn't make a ton of sense on the surface.