Elflein could've left for the NFL after this season, but instead opted to come back for a fifth year as the Buckeyes center.
Watch video
SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. -- Tom Phillips kept looking at the picture. He couldn't help it.
Every time he started to tell a new story about Ohio State guard Pat Elflein, he would glance over his shoulder at the black-and-white photo of Elflein on the wall.
Coaches all across the country have those photos, Ohio State sends them out after players earn Player of the Game honors. Phillips' office inside the Pickerington Community School is sparsely decorated save for a few photos of former players. Elflein's photo has prime real estate, taped just above Phillips' computer. He couldn't avoid looking at it if he wanted to.
That's a good spot for it, because sometimes Phillips needs to look at it.
"I look at that thing when I've gotta get the warrior in me," Phillips told cleveland.com during an in-person interview earlier this month. "I always take a peek at that thing."
Phillips talks about Elflein, whom he coached for four years at Pickering North High School, the way high school coaches speak about a select group of players who come around every so often. The kind of guys who come out of central casting when coaches say, "Send me a football player."
Phillips loves Elflein. He knows him so well that two weeks before Elflein made the news official, Phillips had an inkling that his former player was going to come back for his fifth year at Ohio State. It didn't seem so cut-and-dry to outside observers. There was NFL money to be made.
But Elflein is coming back. That roster move is more important than any recruit Ohio State will sign this year.
"There's a lot of things that went into that, talking with the coaches and my family, just decided that the pros of coming back are greater than the pros of leaving right now," Elflein said Tuesday in Arizona, where Ohio State will play Notre Dame in the Fiesta Bowl on Jan. 1.
If that ended up being his last game in an Ohio State uniform, nobody would've batted an eye.
He's an NFL talent, he's been a two-time first-team All-Big Ten selection, he won a National Championship and as a fourth-year guy, most of his friends are leaving this year anyway.
"I love Ohio State, I love the coaches, I want to graduate," Elflein said. "There are still some things I want to accomplish here, as a team make another run for it, we definitely have the potential to do that again. I want to play for Ohio State again, play center."
That's the key to this whole thing, not only is he coming back, but Elflein will take over at center for Jacoby Boren. That's not totally surprising given Elflein has been the No. 2 center the last two years and there's better depth at guard than at center. But it's still difficult to overstate just how important that is going to be for Urban Meyer's offense. Without him coming back, Ohio State would've had just one returning starter on the offensive line, left guard Billy Price.
Now the Buckeyes have two guys back to mentor a young group, one a fifth-year senior with three-plus years of starting experience playing a vital position.
It's important to understand that making a decision like the one Elflein was faced with needs to be a selfish one. When the stakes are that high, it's OK to look out for No. 1. But Elflein also took into consideration just how big of a boost it would be to Ohio State if he came back.
"It's like signing a five-star recruit with three years of experience," offensive line coach and co-offensive coordinator Ed Warinner said.
Except not really. Elflein was never a five-star kid.
He was a lightly recruited three-star prospect who likely would've ended up at Northwestern if Luke Fickell didn't come through with an offer for Elflein late in the 2012 recruiting cycle.
Elflein is a prime talent now. After next season, he'll try to be the first center selected in the first round of the NFL Draft since Wisconsin's Travis Frederick in 2013. That's his goal anyway.
He's always been about goals. He wanted 12 varsity letters at Pickerington North, he got them playing football, wrestling and track and field. Phillips thinks some unfinished business when it comes to the goals Elflein laid out before coming to Ohio State might have played a role in why he came back.
"He was two-time first-team All-Big Ten? Hell, Pat probably wants three," Phillips said. "Pat will find his little mojo."
When he was in high school, that mojo was trying to prove he was big enough and strong enough to play at the Big Ten level.
Workouts before the sun came up were common. Coaches had to make sure Elflein wasn't doing too much trying to balance three sports and build up the bulk he felt he needed to play at Ohio State. Phillips said at one point Fickell came to him concerned that Elflein was putting on too much weight and doing it the wrong way. So they addressed it, and it stopped.
Phillips described Elflein as a blue-collar guy, the son of a father who runs a concrete business and a mother who works in the high school cafeteria. One of Phillips' first encounters with Elflein was when his father was putting in a patio at Phillips' home, and a young Pat was carrying buckets of wet concrete.
Ohio State's Pat Elflein (right) won't get another shot to win the Illibuck Trophy, but he's coming back anyway.Marvin Fong, The Plain Dealer
The work ethic is the kind of thing Phillips is talking about when calls Elflein a warrior.
Warinner used similar words to describe Elflein: "Tough, aggressive, high energy, loves football, rugged, coachable. High integrity guy, smart. He's the whole package."
Elflein is exactly the kind of guy Warinner will need in Ohio State's offensive line room next year. With such a young group and players in foreign roles, Elflein will need to be a little different than the captain he was in high school when he was sometimes hesitant to speak up.
It seems like he's willing to take on that challenge.
"I want to do that, come back and be the main guy in that group, be the leader, and help develop those young guys," Elflein said. "... I feel a responsibility to do that."
Tuesday was a day of reflection for Elflein. Because this was the first time he spoke since making his decision, he was asked about ever imagining getting to this point where he would even have the choice of leaving for the NFL early or coming back.
This might blow his mind. Last summer, Phillips was sitting inside that same office with the picture of Elflein on the wall when the Cleveland Browns came for a rare in-person chat about Elflein and other NFL prospects whom Phillips has coached.
Phillips has the thank you card the Browns sent him after the visit sitting on his window sill.
From the undersized kid carrying buckets of cement to a guy that NFL teams are inquiring about in a very serious way is a long journey. The Browns and everyone else will have to wait a little longer.
Elflein isn't going anywhere just yet.
"I was talking to Coach Meyer, and said I never would've thought I'd be sitting in your office talking about the NFL Draft and leaving early," Elflein said. "I never thought that's a conversation I'd be having. You come into this program, give it all you got and that's what's gonna happen to you."