Johnny Manziel threw for 270 yards and a touchdown in leading the Browns over the 49ers and earning a grade of A-: DMan's QB Report.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Quarterback Johnny Manziel went 21-of-31 for 270 yards and one touchdown as the Cleveland Browns handled the San Francisco 49ers, 24-10, Sunday afternoon at FirstEnergy Stadium. Manziel was intercepted once and sacked twice.
Here is a capsule look at Manziel's performance after a DVR review of the Fox Sports telecast:
Prelude: The Browns (3-10) snapped a seven-game losing streak. The 49ers (4-9) were coming off a victory over the Bears in Chicago.
Locked in: Manziel started for the first time since Week 10 at Pittsburgh. He had been demoted during the Week 11 bye and was the No. 3 QB for Week 12 against Baltimore and No. 2 for Week 13 against Cincinnati.
No question that Manziel faced a bad outfit, and he received plenty of help. Regardless, Manziel deserves unconditional credit for a game well-played and for his contributions to the decisive victory.
Manziel improved to 2-2 this season, 2-4 in his two-year career.
Periodically checking stats, or waiting for the final book, was not necessary to judge Manziel's performance. He easily passed the eye test.
His attributes were tangible and intangible. Among them:
* Command of the offense. He was decisive with his movements, and teammates followed his lead. Decisiveness fueled good tempo, which benefitted the rushing (230 yards) and passing attacks. The Browns possessed the ball for 37:39.
* Poise. He did not panic against the various looks from 49ers defensive coordinator Eric Mangini. Manziel played fast, but not in a hurry.
* Pocket production. He made numerous plus-plays from between the tackles, which must happen for an NFL QB to be successful over the long haul. He resisted the temptation to tuck and run at the first sign of trouble.
* Quick-thinking. He created an assortment of plays by using his mind.
* Arm strength. He powered the ball to all areas, including the all-important boundaries.
* Patience. With the interception being the notable exception, he didn't try to force the issue and took what the defense gave him.
* Elusiveness. He used athleticism to avoid losses or gain yards by pass or run.
Final grade: A-
Summary: Manziel made a glaring mistake -- the interception -- and several high throws. He occasionally was uncertain in the pocket. On balance, though, Manziel and the Browns have every right to be pleased with what transpired. One game does not a franchise quarterback make (especially against the current edition of 49ers), but Manziel continued to take positive steps on the field. At the very least, he created ample intrigue for his trip to Seattle in Week 15, when the Browns play a formidable Seahawks team that is on fire.
Piece by piece: Here is a breakdown of each Browns pass play:
FIRST QUARTER
First possession (0-0)
1st-and-10 @ Cleveland 20
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun in empty backfield, complete to WR Travis Benjamin on left for 8 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Manziel unfazed against pressure up middle from a four-man rush. Manziel might have hit his right fingers on LG Austin Pasztor's helmet on release; he was shaking fingers after throw.
Fox Sports analyst and former Browns quarterback Brady Quinn said: "One of the best things about Johnny Manziel is his ... footwork, and he also keeps a solid base. That's where he gets a lot of his power. He's not the biggest guy, but he gets every bit of power and strength into his throws, utilizing his whole body.''
1st-and-10 @ Cleveland 31
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun in empty backfield, incomplete intended for WR Brian Hartline on short right.
- Skinny: OUT OF POCKET by design. Manziel play-faked jet sweep to Benjamin and rolled right. Hartline unable to catch fastball that was throw across Manziel's body.
2-and-10 @ Cleveland 31
- Result: POCKET. Manziel, from shotgun, complete to RB Isaiah Crowell on left for 9 yards.
- Skinny: Misdirection screen. Crowell made catch at Cleveland 27 and sifted through traffic.
1st-and-10 @ San Francisco 48
- Result: POCKET. Manziel, from under center, complete to TE Gary Barnidge near left sideline for 23 yards.
- Skinny: Play-fake. Wide-open Barnidge made catch outside numbers at San Francisco 30.
Quinn said: "Nice play design by offensive coordinator John DeFilippo. Used Travis Benjamin to help clear out room on that side of the field for Barnidge.''
2nd-and-9 @ San Francisco 24
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, incomplete intended for Benjamin on short left.
- Skinny: POCKET. Throw sailed high and wide.
3rd-and-9 @ San Francisco 24
- Result: POCKET. Manziel, from shotgun, incomplete intended for RB Duke Johnson Jr. on short left.
- Skinny: Throw sailed high.
Quinn: "Watch (Manziel's) feet: He's going to read the right side of the field first. He starts coming back to the left, but he doesn't really get the feet all the way back toward the sideline in order to make a more accurate throw... Maybe still a little rust getting back into it.''
(Travis Coons field-goal attempt blocked.)
Second possession (0-0)
2nd-and-6 @ San Francisco 11
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun in empty backfield, complete to Hartline over middle for 10 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Manziel looked right before spotting Hartline open for what appeared headed for a touchdown. However, Hartline fumbled after being wrapped up in front of goal line. Hartline recovered at 1.
(Crowell rushed twice, the second for a 1-yard touchdown. It was Cleveland's second offensive TD in first quarter in past 11 games, and third rushing TD this season.)
Third possession (Browns, 7-0)
1st-and-10 @ Cleveland 33
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, complete to Barnidge near right sideline for 30 yards.
- Skinny: OUT OF POCKET by necessity. Manziel escaped pressure up middle from four-man rush and rolled right. Barnidge made catch at San Francisco 45.
Quinn said: "This is what makes Johnny Manziel so dangerous. You just can't prepare for this. Manziel scans the field, gives a pump-fake to freeze the defense, and does a tremendous job of keeping his eyes downfield.''
(Drive ends with RB Glenn Winston fumble.)
SECOND QUARTER
Fourth possession (Browns, 7-0)
1st-and-10 @ Cleveland 36
- Result: Manziel, from under center, complete to Benjamin near right sideline for 24 yards.
- Skinny: OUT OF POCKET by necessity. Manziel escaped pressure from four-man rush, rolled right and threw a fastball on run to Benjamin, who was open because Manziel extended the play.
Quinn said: "Watch Manziel work the pocket... Look at him rip that ball. Like it.''
2nd-and-2 @ San Francisco 32
- Result: POCKET. Manziel, from shotgun, complete to Benjamin on right for 0 yards.
- Skinny: Screen. 49ers closed in a hurry.
3rd-and-2 @ San Francisco 32
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, complete to WR Marlon Moore on right for 12 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Big-time play in big spot. Manziel scanned field before locating Moore, who made catch at San Francisco 26. Manziel lowered release point.
Quinn said: "This is the maturation process that we're seeing with Johnny Manziel. He's going to read the left side of the field, he's not going to see anything, but he's patient. He doesn't leave the pocket, doesn't panic, and ends up finding Moore open for the third-down conversion... Look at his eyes -- works them across. These are the sorts of things you're looking for in a young quarterback trying to make his case to be the quarterback of the future.''
2nd-and-13 @ San Francisco 23
- Result: Manziel, from under center, complete to Hartline on right for 13 yards.
- Skinny: OUT OF POCKET by design. Manziel, off boot action, rolled right and threw on move. He made it look easy. Hartline caught pass outside the numbers at San Francisco 13.
2nd-and-goal @ 14
- Result: Manziel, from under center, complete to Johnson on right for 6 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Basic screen.
3rd-and-goal @ 8
- Result: POCKET. Manziel, from shotgun, incomplete intended for Barnidge over middle/right in front of end zone.
- Skinny: Wisely low throw to covered Barnidge.
Quinn said: "Nowhere to throw the football.''
(Coons kicks field goal.)
Manziel game totals: 10-of-14 for 135 yards.
Fifth possession (Browns, 10-0)
1st-and-10 @ Cleveland 22
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, incomplete intended for Benjamin over middle/right.
- Skinny: POCKET. Benjamin seemingly should have made catch at Cleveland 39, but he gator-armed.
3rd-and-7 @ Cleveland 25
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, sacked by Arik Armstead for minus-8 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Armstead overpowered Pasztor. Manziel had little-to-no chance.
Sixth possession (10-3)
Quinn said: "You look at Manziel in the pocket, and he's moving his feet and getting through his progressions as you would like to see. And he's able to get outside and run and make some of those big, elusive plays that we kind of know him for from his time at Texas A&M.''
1st-and-15 @ Cleveland 15
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun in empty backfield, sacked by Quinton Dial for minus-11 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Manziel given plenty of time against three-man rush but uncertain about what he wanted to do. Johnson wide-open near left sideline on wheel route but Manziel never saw him.
2nd-and-26 @ Cleveland 4
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, incomplete intended for Johnson over short middle/left.
- Skinny: POCKET. Dangerous pass. Off Johnson's hand.
3rd-and-26 @ Cleveland 4
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, sacked by Corey Lemonier for safety NULLIFIED by Lemonier facemask.
- Skinny: POCKET. Browns fortunate. 49ers five-man rush was effective even as Johnson had pancake block on LB NaVorro Bowman.
2nd-and-9 @ Cleveland 20
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun in empty backfield, complete to Hartline on right for 6 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Basic underneath.
3rd-and-3 @ Cleveland 26
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, complete to Benjamin on left for 9 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Throw off back foot. Benjamin wide-open on slant in part because inside receiver, Moore, ran an excellent pseudo pick route.
(2-minute warning)
2nd-and-7 @ Cleveland 38
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, incomplete intended for Johnson on short left NULLIFIED by LB Gerald Hodges interference.
- Skinny: POCKET. Hodges too tight against Johnson.
1st-and-10 @ Cleveland 40
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun in empty backfield, complete to Hartline over middle for 12 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Quality throw under pressure against five-man rush.
1st-and-10 @ San Francisco 48
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun in empty backfield, scrambles up middle for 4 yards.
- Skinny: OUT OF POCKET by necessity. Manziel made something out of nothing.
2nd-and-6 @ San Francisco 44
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun in empty backfield, intended for Hartline over middle intercepted by S Jaquiski Tartt at San Francisco 31.
- Skinny: OUT OF POCKET by necessity. Manziel scrambled left and, near sideline, threw floater against his body. Tartt spied, easily picked and returned to Cleveland 44. Obviously, Manziel made a bad decision and throw. Moments later, while seated on the sideline, he whacked his head with a computer tablet multiple times in frustration.
Seventh possession (Browns, 10-3)
(Manziel kneels.)
Manziel totals at half: 13-of-20 for 162 yards, INT, two sacks.
THIRD QUARTER
Eighth possession (Browns, 10-3)
1st-and-10 @ Cleveland 11
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, complete to Hartline on right for 24 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. High snap. Quality throw (sidearm) and catch (fingertip). Hartline made reception at Cleveland 19.
Quinn said: "Johnny Manziel is so good at these quick-hitting plays. He does a nice job of getting the football in the shotgun, finding the laces, and delivering accurately upfield.''
2nd-and-9 @ Cleveland 36
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, complete to Moore over middle for 11 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Moore broke tackle at Cleveland 41, gained yards for first down.
2nd-and-9 @ Cleveland 48
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, incomplete intended for Benjamin on short left.
- Skinny: POCKET. Benjamin bobbled, CB Kenneth Acker PBU. Almost intercepted.
3rd-and-9 @ Cleveland 48
- Result: OUT OF POCKET by necessity. Manziel, from shotgun, scrambles left for 7 yards.
- Skinny: Manziel made a 7-yard gain must-see TV.
Manziel game totals: 15-of-23 for 197 yards, INT, two sacks.
Ninth possession (Browns, 10-3)
1st-and-10 @ Cleveland 22
- Result: Manziel, from under center, complete to Hartline on left for 34 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Double-play-fake. Hartline wide-open. Manziel knocked down after release.
2nd-and-5 @ San Francisco 39
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun in empty backfield, complete to Barnidge for 8 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Manziel beat zone-blitz pressure; 49ers ended up rushing four.
Quinn said: "Manziel's got that lightning-quick release.''
1st-and-10 @ San Francisco 31
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, complete to Hartline on left for 3 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Screen.
2nd-and-7 @ San Francisco 28
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, complete to Barnidge over middle/right for 21 yards.
- Skinny: OUT OF POCKET by necessity. Manziel given time in pocket, then extended the play and threw on the move.
1st-and-goal @ 7
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, incomplete intended for Barnidge over short middle/right.
- Skinny: POCKET. Manziel back-foot throw in face of pressure from seven-man rush. Pass too high and slightly behind.
2nd-and-goal @ 7
- Result: Manziel, from under center, complete to Hartline on left for 5 yards.
- Skinny: POCKET. Slant. Hartline exited holding front of left shoulder.
3rd-and-goal @ 2
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, complete to Barnidge for 2-yard TD.
- Skinny: POCKET. Superb play. Manziel backpedaled to avoid pressure from seven-man rush.
Quinn said: "Eric Mangini said: 'I want you to beat me when I pressure you with the blitz,' and Johnny Manziel did just that. He saw the quick throw, was able to get depth and take more time, and find Barnidge for the touchdown. Manziel didn't allow the blitzer to get to him on time. He understands where the free guy is coming from, drifts away from that ... and fires a strike.''
Manziel on drive: 6-of-7 for 73 yards, TD.
Manziel totals: 21-of-30 for 270 yards, TD, INT, two sacks.
FOURTH QUARTER
Tenth possession (Browns, 17-3)
3rd-and-2 @ Cleveland 17
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun in empty backfield, scrambles up middle for 8 yards.
- Skinny: OUT OF POCKET by necessity. 49ers rushed four, but one stood and waited to see what Manziel would do. Manziel given time, then slithered his way for important first down.
2nd-and-goal @ 6
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, incomplete intended for Moore on short left.
- Skinny: POCKET. Pass appeared to whistle through Moore's hands at 4.
3rd-and-goal @ 6
- Result: Manziel, from shotgun, incomplete on right sideline NULLIFIED by CB Marcus Cromartie holding.
- Skinny: OUT OF POCKET. Manziel extended play before a throwaway (supposedly intended for Darius Jennings). Manziel mixed it up with LB Ahmad Brooks afterwards. His ability to buy time likely forced the holding penalty.
(Crowell rushed twice, the second for a 3-yard touchdown.)
Manziel game totals: 21-of-31 for 270 yards, TD, INT, two sacks.
Eleventh possession (Browns, 24-3)
(No passes.)
Twelfth possession (Browns, 24-10)
(Three kneel-downs.)