Rich Gannon has seen some good things in Johnny Manziel but isn't ready to christen him a completely different player yet.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- While the world is poised for the new and improved Johnny Manziel Thursday night against the 7-0 Bengals on NFL Network, CBS analyst Rich Gannon pumped the brakes on that narrative a bit.
Asked if he feels a lot better about Manziel heading into this game than he did last year, the former NFL MVP quarterback told cleveland.com, "no, how could I? He's played only a handful of snaps in our league. We're not really going to know until we see more of his body of work.''
He hopes last year was humbling for Manziel, but he can't say for sure.
"He went through a very difficult time,'' said Gannon. "You hope that changed his study habits, his preparation, the attention to detail.''
But to win the respect of his teammates and coaches, Gannon said, Manziel has a long way to go. He's started only two games since his disastrous debut against the Bengals last season, a 30-0 route on Dec. 14th that wrecked the Browns' playoffs hopes.
"Johnny has to play at a high level and do it on a consistent basis,'' said Gannon, who studied all of the Browns games this season and called their game in Baltimore. "No one's going to say if he goes out Thursday night and throws for three touchdowns and 300 yards that this guy has arrived. That would be foolish, but you want to see gradual, steady improvement.
"You want to see a guy that's trending in the right direction. You can't throw for three touchdowns one week and three picks the next. He's got a ways to go before he'll be at that point.''
In breaking down Manziel's 28-14 victory over the Titans in week two, his first career victory, Gannon saw some things that encouraged him. That day, Manziel completed only 8-of-15 attempts, but two were touchdowns of 60 and 50 yards to Travis Benjamin.
"That first TD touchdown pass was as good as it gets,'' said Gannon, a four-time Pro Bowler and Super Bowl participant. "Everything about it was good. He's working from under center, takes a nice good deep drop, he's in rhythm, he trusts his feet, the ball comes out on time. The pocket collapses around him, there's no sense of panic.
"You can see it in his body, he does a great job with the read and getting the ball up and down quick. And there's no indecision and that's what you want to see. You want to see more of those throws from Johnny in the pocket. When I saw that throw, I thought to myself, "my gosh, if you see more of them that's terrific.''
But he's not ready to say Manziel is a completely different player from the one who was thoroughly humiliated last year by the Bengals just yet. Old habits die hard, especially when the pressure is on.
"I don't know how you could say that when he hasn't played enough,'' said Gannon. "The biggest concern I have with this guy is if you really go back and study his film, at Texas A&M, so many of the big plays came off of movement, came off of scrambling. They weren't rhythm plays. He didn't drop back three steps and throw the ball. He didn't drop back five steps and release the ball. He dropped back and made a guy miss and ran around and threw the ball 30 yards across the field.
"I want to see him throw in rhythm. I want to see him trust the protection. I want to see the ball come out on time. I want to see the anticipation, the accuracy, the decision-making, all of these things that you need to have to function in a pro-style offense. I'm not being critical, but in fairness, how much have we really seen of the guy?''
Pettine, for one, seems to be all in on Manziel these days, despite the fact his second-year pro was recently involved in a disturbing roadway incident, admitted to drinking, and is under review by the NFL for a possible violation of the league's personal conduct policy.
"He's a different player,'' said Pettine, who's working closely with the offense this year. "We saw that this year when he had to go into the Jets game. I thought he did some good things, made some mistakes, put the ball on the ground then had a week of preparation to get ready for Tennessee and went out and executed a gameplan.''
He said the biggest improvement has been in his demeanor in the pocket.
"It wasn't as frenetic, that his feet were calm. He has a really good understanding of what we're doing, understands the plays, 'If I get pressure, I know I'm working this side, if I get zone I'm going to work a high-low against this defender.' All the intricate details, he has a much better grasp of and it's shown when he's been out there."
Even Manziel is confident he's come a long way since that beatdown by the Bengals, who roughed him up all day and jubilantly rubbed their fingers together in the now-defunct money sign. After Bengals coach Marvin Lewis called Manziel "a midget'' on a radio show that week and later apologized, an unprepared Manziel completed 10-of-18 attempts for 80 yards with no touchdowns and two interceptions for a 27.3 rating. He also rushed five times for only 13 yards.
He was sacked three times and went three-and-out on six of his 10 possessions. He managed just five first downs, and converted 1-of-10 third downs. He produced just 107 yards, fewest since the Browns dropped 26 on Buffalo in 2004.
Afterwards, he admitted it was an epic fail on his part.
"Obviously, that was not the first career start I would have hoped for or expected when the Bengals came to our stadium last year,'' he said Wednesday. "I did learn from it and I feel much more confident in my abilities now because of the progress I feel like I've made over this season. My experience in that game from last year should help me (Thursday) night."
Gannon believes the Bengals -- bolstered by the return of disruptive weakside linebacker Vontaze Burfict -- will try to squash Johnny Football just like they did last year. In addition to Burfict, Manziel will have to deal with a strong push up the middle from Geno Atkins, who's five sacks are tied for the NFL lead for interior linemen, and defensive end Carlos Dunlap, who's fifth in the league with 6.5 sacks. Manziel has already fumbled four times in his limited play this season.
"The big thing is, you've got to hit him,'' said Gannon. "He's not the biggest guy and you've got to hit him and try to get the ball out. But he's got to play smart. There will be some times where he'll get fooled, there will be some plays that look ugly and you just want to make sure that you don't turn a mistake into a huge, huge issue.
"If you miss a hot read or something is not there, throw the ball away and live for another down. Don't turn one mistake into a traffic accident where you miss something and you throw it and it gets returned for a touchdown.''
Although the Bengals are 22nd in total defense and 23rd against the pass, they're seventh in the NFL in points allowed (18.9) and second in TDs in the red zone.
"They get push up the middle and they get speed off the edge and against a quarterback like Johnny, you want to make sure there's no rush lanes,'' said Gannon. "A lot of quarterbacks, you know exactly where they're going to be in the pocket. With this guy you don't, and even when you think you have him, he can make you miss. His escapability his maneuverability are as fine as there is and that's a big part of who he is. But you look at the last game, Cincinnati had a really really good plan for how to deal with him.''
Bengals defensive coordinator Paul Guenther revealed to Bengals.com after the shutout that he had studied Manziel's Texas A&M games against LSU and Missouri and noticed that they bottled him up on the left side.
"They kind of moved him one side and kept him in the pocket,'' he said. "Those were his worst two games in college, so you could see obviously what their plan was, to keep him in the pocket or move him to a side where he wasn't throwing. You had to go look at all of the resources of everything to try to get a feel for this guy."
Since that time, Manziel has attempted only 50 more NFL passes, including a career-high of 24 in the opening day loss to the Jets in relief of a concussed Josh McCown. With the Browns struggling to run the ball this season, Manziel might be forced to throw a lot more than he ever has -- and he won't have Brian Hartline or Andrew Hawkins, who are both out with concussions.
"Every time out is going to be a new learning experience for him, and every time out is going to be a new learning experience for the playcaller (John DeFilippo) because you think you know what he's good at, but until you really see how he responds, you don't know,'' said Gannon. "I think they've got a pretty good sense what he's comfortable with, and I think you really try and formulate a gameplan that accentuate his strengths and minimizes his weaknesses.''
You can bet Guenther and his guys know exactly what those are.