St. Edward finishes the regular season with a win against St. Ignatius and as the unanimous choice for No. 1 in the cleveland.com high school football Top 25.
CLEVELAND, Ohio – St. Edward finishes the regular season with a win against St. Ignatius and as the unanimous choice for No. 1 in the cleveland.com high school football Top 25.
Mentor's loss to Elyria surprised staffers and resulted in a drop for the Cardinals and a few new teams earned votes this week.
Voters are Tim Bielik, Nathaniel Cline, Matt Goul, Joe Noga, Scott Patsko and Robert Rozboril. Below are individual ballots for each voter, as well as an explanation for some of their decisions.
Share your take and/or your Top 25 in the comments section below.
Bielik's ballot
1. St. Edward, 2. Benedictine, 3. Midview, 4. Stow, 5. Archbishop Hoban, 6. Avon, 7. St. Vincent-St. Mary, 8. Mayfield, 9. Glenville, 10. Solon, 11. Mentor, 12. St. Ignatius, 13. Nordonia, 14. Aurora, 15. Hudson, 16. Euclid, 17. Madison, 18. West Geauga, 19. Copley, 20. Buckeye, 21. Perry, 22. Berea-Midpark, 23. Elyria, 24. Woodridge, 25. Bay.
Bielik's ballot explanation
St. Edward’s win against rival St. Ignatius meant the Eagles secured the top spot in my final ballot. St. Edward has been extremely impressive all season considering the amount of talent it had graduate. Because of its win against Archbishop Hoban, Benedictine flipped spots with Midview from No. 3 to No. 2. Stow benefited from the two teams in front of it last week losing in Week 10 and thus moved all the way up to No. 4. Archbishop Hoban's loss only cost it one spot in my ballot. Mentor ends the season just outside of my top 10 at No. 11 after its stunning loss at Elyria, which returned to my ballot at No. 23. This was the first time since 2010 Mentor has lost three games in the regular season. St. Ignatius also ended the season outside of my top 10, finishing at No. 12 and missing a playoff spot. Berea-Midpark' s fourth loss in its last six games pushed the Titans down to No. 22, the lowest-ranked team in my ballot that was in last week's ballot. Woodridge and Bay were the final two teams to make it into my final ballot.
Cline's ballot
1. St. Edward, 2. Benedictine, 3. Midview, 4. Archbishop Hoban, 5. Stow, 6. Avon, 7. Mentor, 8. St. Ignatius, 9. St. Vincent-St. Mary, 10. Berea-Midpark, 11. Madison, 12. Mayfield, 13. Glenville, 14. Euclid, 15. Aurora, 16. Solon, 17. Hudson, 18. Nordonia, 19. West Geauga, 20. North Olmsted, 21. Olmsted Falls, 22. Perry, 23. Buckeye, 24. Copley, 25. Elyria
Cline's ballot explanation
St. Edward, the defending Division I state champ, is clearly in my eyes the leader for this year's Top 25. The effort by the team on defense in combination with the talent has been a good recipe for success. Now it’s on to the playoffs for the Eagles. Benedictine's defense is what I've grown fond of watching when it comes to the Bengals and after their win over Archbishop Hoban I moved them up one spot and switched them with Midview in my final ballot. I also dropped Mentor three spots after a disappointing loss to Elyria. As a result, Hoban, Stow and Avon moved up one spot. St. Ignatius played a strong team in St. Edward, but I didn't see reason to move the Wildcats farther down looking at the teams behind them in the rankings. Brecksville drops out of my poll after picking up its fourth loss due to a combination of Hudson's strong performance and the Bees missing key players like quarterback Luke Strnad and receiver/cornerback Tyler Tupa. Elyria returns to take the final spot in my ballot after the team's win against Greater Cleveland Conference opponent Mentor.
Goul’s ballot
1. St. Edward, 2. Benedictine, 3. Midview, 4. Stow, 5. Avon, 6. Archbishop Hoban, 7. Glenville, 8. St. Vincent-St. Mary, 9. Euclid, 10. Hudson, 11. Aurora, 12. Solon, 13. Madison, 14. Mayfield, 15. Copley, 16. Mentor, 17. Nordonia, 18. St. Ignatius, 19. West Geauga, 20. Perry, 21. Buckeye, 22. Cleveland Heights, 23. North Ridgeville, 24. Brecksville, 25. Kirtland.
Goul’s Top 25 explanation
Benedictine’s win vs. Hoban shrunk the gap between the Bengals and St. Edward, but not enough for me to leapfrog them over the Eagles. Hoban drops from fourth to sixth in my ballot. That might be the shortest drop I’ve given a team this season after a loss. The toughest area for me to rank is Nos. 15-18. This begins a stretch where a lot of teams suffered Week 10 losses, which compelled me to reward Copley after a 9-1 regular season. One loss, just seven points, to Aurora. Enough said. I anticipate St. Ignatius’ positioning might still be the hot topic. I dropped the Wildcats just one spot, which is befitting for a 35-28 loss to the No. 1 team. Finally, Cleveland Heights vaults into my Top 25. You go out and win a league crown without your best player, make the playoffs and do this to cap a tumultuous season, you’ve earned your spot. My bubble teams are Berea-Midpark, Columbia and Woodridge.
Noga's ballot
1. St. Edward; 2. Midview; 3. Benedictine; 4. Stow; 5. Mayfield; 6. Avon; 7. Archbishop Hoban; 8. St. Vincent-St. Mary; 9. Mentor; 10. St. Ignatius; 11. Solon; 12. Glenville; 13. Euclid; 14. Madison; 15. West Geauga; 16. Aurora; 17. Chardon; 18. Perry; 19. Hudson; 20. Nordonia; 21. Buckeye; 22. Woodridge; 23. Copley; 24. Berea-Midpark; 25. Elyria.
Noga's ballot explanation
For the second straight season, St. Edward is the undisputed No. 1 on my ballot. The Eagles adapted to a new coach, a new quarterback and met the challenge of the toughest schedule in Ohio. Undefeated teams Midview, Benedictine and Stow round out the top four. I dropped Archbishop Hoban three spots to No. 7 and Mentor four spots to No. 9 after losses in Week 10. Chardon made the biggest move on my final ballot, leaping eight spots to No. 17. Nobody wants to face the scrappy Hilltoppers in the postseason. Brecksville falls off my ballot and Elyria sneaks in for the No. 25 spot after upsetting Mentor and earning a playoff bid.
Patsko’s ballot
1. St. Edward, 2. Benedictine, 3. Midview, 4. Archbishop Hoban, 5. Stow, 6. St. Vincent-St. Mary, 7. Avon, 8. Glenville, 9. St. Ignatius, 10. Madison, 11. Mayfield, 12. Solon, 13. Mentor, 14. Euclid, 15. Hudson, 16. Aurora, 17. Nordonia, 18. Copley, 19. Buckeye, 20. North Ridgeville, 21. Elyria, 22. West Geauga, 23. Chardon, 24. Berea-Midpark, 25. Cleveland Heights.
Patsko’s poll explanation
We made it! Ten weeks later (actually 11 with the preseason poll) and we’ve – well, I - determined that St. Edward is the best team in Northeast Ohio. Easy choice. The rest of my top five, however, got a bit of a shakeup in the final week. Benedictine vaults two spots to No. 2 after defeating Archbishop Hoban. The Bengals were impressive, not just on offense, where RBs Dontez Rash and DeCavilon Reese always seem like they’re shot out of a cannon, but also defensively, hounding QB Danny Clark all game. Too bad we can’t have the Bengals and Eagles square off. Yep, that’s St. Ignatius at No. 9. How can I have Wildcats ranked in the top 10 when they didn’t even make the playoffs? Easy. This poll doesn’t have anything to do with the playoffs, and the Wildcats are as good as anybody in the Top 25. Thanks to its big Week 10 win against Mentor, Elyria hops back on my ballot, along with Lake Erie League champ Cleveland Heights. Brecksville, Rocky River and Highland don’t survive final cuts. That’s a wrap.
Rozboril's ballot
1. St. Edward, 2. Benedictine, 3. Midview, 4. Glenville, 5. Stow, 6. Archbishop Hoban, 7. Avon, 8. St. Vincent-St. Mary, 9. Euclid, 10. Hudson, 11. Aurora, 12. Copley, 13. Mayfield, 14. St. Ignatius, 15. Solon, 16. Nordonia, 17. Perry, 18. Elyria, 19. Mentor, 20. Madison, 21. North Ridgeville, 22. Olmsted Falls, 23. Westlake, 24. Berea-Midpark, 25. Brecksville.
Rozboril's ballot explanation
Mentor drops considerably after losing to Elyria, which in turn jumps in at the No. 18 spot. Benedictine and Midview switch places as the Bengals earned a convincing win against Hoban while the Middies only beat North Ridgeville by a touchdown. The Pioneers have had back-to-back impressive wins and, despite their less than impressive record, have proven to be a tough team to beat. Hoban doesn't move after losing to Benedictine, which I had ranked three spots ahead of the Knights going into Week 10. Brecksville falls considerably after being shut out by Hudson. Westlake, having played multiple talented teams tough this year and coming off an upset of Berea-Midpark, jumps into my ballot at No. 23. All of the movement at the bottom of the ballot pushes Olmsted Falls to No. 22 and squeezes Highland and North Olmsted out after losing to Kent Roosevelt and Avon Lake, respectively.
Follow our high school sports Twitter account @NEOvarsity and tag your high school sports Tweets and score updates with the #NEOVarsity hashtag.