Josh Tomlin's quality start in his MLB season's debut was not enough as Cleveland Indians lost to Minnesota Twins, 4-1, Saturday night.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Right-hander Tyler Duffey allowed one hit in six scoreless innings and Eddie Rosario and Chris Herrmann hit back-to-back homers as the Minnesota Twins defeated the Cleveland Indians, 4-1, Saturday night at Target Field in Minneapolis, Minn. Tribe shortstop Francisco Lindor went 2-for-3 with a walk, an error and a spectacular defensive play.
The Indians slipped to 54-61; the Twins improved to 58-58.
Here is a capsule look at the game after a DVR review of the Fox SportsTime Ohio telecast:
Welcome back: Tribe right-hander Josh Tomlin, making his season's debut in the majors after April shoulder surgery, allowed two runs on five hits in 6 1/3 innings. He walked none and struck out five.
Adjusting for bad umpiring, Tomlin allowed one run on four hits in 6 1/3 innings.
Left fielder Rosario, a left-handed batter, led off the fifth inning with an improbable homer. He swatted at an 0-2 fastball (89 mph) that was letter-high and inside and shot it into the right-field seats for the game's first run.
Fox SportsTime Ohio analyst Rick Manning said: "I can't believe he hit it. I can see if it were a low pitch; not one like that.''
Fox SportsTime Ohio play-by-play voice Matt Underwood said: "It's crazy that he even swung at that pitch.''
Catcher Chris Herrmann, a lefty, rallied from a 1-2 count to crush a 3-2 hanger (82) into the right-field seats.
Tomlin should have struck out Herrmann with a 1-2 curve on the inner third at the knees, but plate umpire Sam Holbrook missed the call. Herrmann spit on a 2-2 curve in the dirt, then pounced on what appeared to be a cut piece that floated instead of cut.
The Twins made it 4-0 in the eighth on Brian Dozier's two-run homer off Bryan Shaw. The Tribe's run came in the ninth, when Roberto Perez singled to drive in Carlos Santana.
Defensive gems: With a runner on third and two outs in the Minnesota fourth, Torii Hunter hit a dribbler toward third. Giovanny Urshela charged, fielded with the barehand and threw out Hunter to prevent a run.
With a runner on first and one out in the Minnesota sixth, Lindor dived to field Trevor Plouffe's smash in the hole. Lindor hopped to his feet and triggered a 6-4-3 double play.
(Lindor's error occurred when he threw low to first on a routine grounder by Joe Mauer leading off the fourth.)
Too good: Duffey, making his second MLB start after a rocky debut at Toronto, did not allow a hit until Lindor doubled with one out in the sixth. Duffey finished with five walks and seven strikeouts.
The Indians were powerless against Duffey's breaking pitch, which came from moderate cross-fire action and featured good depth. Duffy did an excellent job of teasing at the knees with the pitch and snapping it into the dirt.
Duffy and three relievers combined to hold the Tribe to four hits -- two singles and two doubles.
The Twins' staff benefitted greatly from facing a lineup that was missing Jason Kipnis and Michael Brantley, who are injured.
Here is the outcome of the plate appearances against Duffy:
First inning
(L) Jose Ramirez -- called strikeout (2-2 breaking pitch).
Skinny: Ramirez got a raw deal from Holbrook: The 82-mph pitch was outside.
Manning said: "It's a backdoor breaking ball....It looked like it wrapped around the plate, but, close enough that he gets the call. Good pitch.''
Manning, a terrific analyst, is a former MLB position player. He would have been upset that the pitch was called a strike on him. Ramirez deserved better from Holbrook.
(L) Francisco Lindor -- walk (3-0 fastball outside).
(R) Yan Gomes -- fielder's choice 5-4 (0-2 breaking pitch).
Skinny: Twins narrowly miss turning double play.
(L) Carlos Santana -- pop to third (1-1 fastball).
Skinny: Santana missed a pitch (91) to hit.
Second inning
(R) Giovanny Urshela -- (3-1 fastball up and in).
(L) Abraham Almonte -- 0-2 breaking pitch).
Skinny: Nasty down and in.
(R) Roberto Perez -- swinging strikeout (2-2 breaking pitch).
Skinny: Nasty down and away. Fastball foul set it up.
(L) Lonnie Chisenhall -- pop to third (0-0 fastball).
Skinny: Chisenhall tied up by pitch (91) on inner third.
Third inning
(R) Mike Aviles -- swinging strikeout (0-2 breaking pitch).
Skinny: Nasty in dirt. Fastball foul set it up.
(L) Jose Ramirez -- grounder to first (1-0 fastball).
Skinny: Quality plate appearance resulted in an out because of Joe Mauer's diving stop to his right.
(L) Francisco Lindor -- grounder to third (1-2 breaking pitch).
Skinny: Lindor, in protect mode, lined a backdoor pitch (81) toward Trevor Plouffe, who made a slick pick of the short hop. Lindor's hustle turned it into a close play. Pitch wrapped around plate, but Lindor was forced to swing because of Holbrook's call against Ramirez in first inning.
Fourth inning
(R) Yan Gomes -- swinging strikeout (3-2 breaking pitch in dirt).
Skinny: Duffey continued subtracting getting the strikeout at 78 mph.
Underwood said: "Rick, why can't they lay off the breaking ball?''
Manning said: "I don't know....When he gets to two strikes, he's getting guys to expand their zones.''
(L) Carlos Santana -- grounder to first (1-1 fastball).
(R) Giovanny Urshela -- walk (3-1 fastball down and away).
(L) Abraham Almonte -- grounder to first (0-1 breaking pitch).
Skinny: Mauer, having held on Urshela, fielded the chopper with dive to his right at cut of grass.
Fifth inning
(R) Roberto Perez -- swinging strikeout (1-2 fastball).
Skinny: On previous pitch, Perez missed a breaking pitch to hit and fouled. It served to set up the heater above the belt.
(L) Lonnie Chisenhall -- walk (3-0 fastball low).
(R) Mike Aviles -- GIDP 5-4-3 (1-1 fastball).
Skinny: Aviles chopped a pitch (89) with sink.
Duffey at 70 pitches.
Sixth inning
(L) Jose Ramirez -- grounder to second (3-2 fastball).
(L) Francisco Lindor -- double to right-center (2-2 fastball).
Skinny: Lindor put a good swing on a pitch (91) down and in. First Cleveland hit.
(R) Yan Gomes -- swinging strikeout (1-2 breaking pitch in dirt).
Skinny: Gomes flailed at another hook (81).
(L) Carlos Santana -- walk (3-1 fastball inside).
Skinny: Good discipline by Santana to lay off close pitch.
(R) Giovanny Urshela -- grounder to short (0-1 fastball).
Skinny: Urshela missed a pitch (90) to hit: over plate above the knees.
(Casey Fien relieved to begin seventh inning.)