Indians right fielder Brandon Moss is 6-for-47 (.128) in his past 14 games.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Billy Butler hit a two-run double in a three-run eighth inning as the Oakland Athletics defeated the Cleveland Indians, 5-4, Saturday night at Progressive Field. Tribe right-hander Carlos Carrasco allowed two runs in seven innings and first baseman Carlos Santana went 2-for-4 with a two-run homer.
Here is a capsule look at the game after a DVR review of the Fox SportsTime Ohio telecast:
Streak busted: The Indians (42-45) had won four straight.
Ouch: Some losses sting worse than others.
The Indians need to/must win when they score four times in a home game against a struggling opponent. But they didn't, which is one reason they are 42-45.
The Athletics (40-50) are 22-24 on the road.
Yikes: The All-Star break can't come soon enough for Tribe right fielder Brandon Moss.
Moss went 0-for-3 with a hit-by-pitch and costly throwing error. He was 0-for-2 with runner(s) in scoring position, both times with two outs.
Since the second game of a doubleheader June 28 in Baltimore, Moss is 6-for-47 (.128) with four extra-base hits (double, triple, two homers), 10 RBI and 17 strikeouts in 14 games.
For the season, Moss is batting .221 with 14 homers, 46 RBI and a .726 OPS. With runners in scoring position, he is 17-for-92 (.185) with nine extra-base hits (six doubles, three homers). With RISP and two outs, he is 5-for-52 (.096) with two doubles and six RBI.
Making a mess: Three Tribe relievers factored in Oakland's three-run eighth.
Zach McAllister relieved Carlos Carrasco to begin the inning. The score was tied, 2-2.
McAllister retired the first two and had lefty Stephen Vogt down in the count, 0-2. Vogt served a fastball off the plate to left for a single.
Tribe manager Terry Francona signaled for lefty Marc Rzepczynski, meaning Ben Zobrist would switch to being a right-handed batter. Zobrist entered the night with a better OPS as a lefty than as a righty (.791 to .715) and more homers (5-0). And he was 2-for-11 with four strtikeouts against Rzepczynski. Oh, well: Zobrist slapped a 1-0 fastball to right for a single, Vogt stopping at second.
The Indians still had a matchup they wanted -- lefty specialist Rzepczynski against lefty Josh Reddick -- but it unfolded in four straight balls. Rzepczynski never made Reddick sweat to reach base.
This season, lefties against Rzepczynski are 11-for-47 with one double, one homer, five RBI, five walks and a HBP. All of last season, lefties were 18-for-100 with two doubles, seven RBI, seven walks and a HBP.
Francona signaled for righty Bryan Shaw to face righty Billy Butler with the bases loaded. After Butler fouled a curve, Fox SportsTime Ohio analyst Rick Manning said: "A lot of times, he will stay right on that baseball and try to hit a little line-drive to right field.''
Shaw and catcher Roberto Perez recycled the signs twice. With Perez set up on the inner half, Shaw threw a cutter that scraped the knees on the edge of the outside corner. Butler stayed firm enough to punch it inside the line beyond first for a double.
Even though Shaw appeared to miss his spot, the result seemingly was a good pitch. But, as Manning intimated, Butler has been a productive hitter over the years partly because of his willingness to go the other way.
Butler drove in two, which should have been the extent of Oakland's damage, at least at that moment. However, as Reddick stopped at third and Butler eased into second, Moss threw toward second base. The ball struck Butler and caromed into the outfield, enabling Reddick to jog home and make it 5-2.
Why Moss threw to second is puzzling. Butler was cruising into second with no one near him when Moss threw. When the ball struck Butler, Tribe shortstop Francisco Lindor was behind him.
Santana's two-run homer in the bottom of the inning accounted for the final margin.
Don't blame Cookie: Carrasco gave up six hits, walked one and struck out seven. He threw 69 of 103 pitches for strikes.
Here is a pitch-by-pitch look at his start:
FIRST INNING
(L) Billy Burns -- 95 fastball swinging strike (up); 96 fastball foul (belt); 94 fastball high and away; 89 changeup, swinging strikeout (down and in).
Skinny: Terrific arm action on changeup.
(L) Stephen Vogt -- 96 fastball down and away (barely); 96 fastball called strike; 89 changeup, double to left (hanger).
Skinny: Changeup tailed onto Vogt's swing plane.
(L) Ben Zobrist -- 94 fastball called strike; 93 fastball, single to right (inner half at belt; Vogt stops at third).
(L) Josh Reddick -- 94 fastball low; 94 fastball foul; 95 fastball foul (down); 96 fastball foul (up); 90 changeup foul (hanger; drilled down right side); 88 changeup, sacrifice fly to left (Zobrist to second).
Skinny: Michael Brantley's high throw missed cutoff man, enabled Zobrist to move into scoring position.
(R) Billy Butler -- 94 fastball called strike; 93 fastball low and inside; 94 fastball foul; 88 slider, swinging strikeout (outside corner).
(19 pitches)
SECOND INNING
(L) Ike Davis -- fastball called strike; 94 fastball outside; 94 fastball foul; 95 fastball down and away; 90 changeup foul; 94 fastball, called strikeout (outside).
(R) Mark Canha -- 94 fastball down and in; 87 slider, grounder to first.
(L) Eric Sogard -- 94 fastball outside; 87 changeup outside; 94 fastball outside; 92 fastball outside; 94 fastball, liner to second.
(13 pitches)
THIRD INNING
(R) Marcus Semien -- 85 slider swinging strike (outside corner); 92 fastball foul; 89 slider, swinging strikeout.
(L) Billy Burns -- 88 changeup called strike; 94 fastball foul; 82 breaking pitch foul; 89 changeup down and in; 95 fastball outside; 87 slider, called strikeout.
(L) Stephen Vogt -- 95 fastball foul; 94 fastball foul; 88 slider, swinging strikeout (down and in).
(12 pitches)
FOURTH INNING
(L) Ben Zobrist -- 93 fastball outside; 87 slider foul; 82 curve down and in; 94 fastball outside; 93 fastball foul; 87 changeup foul; 94 fastball, grounder to first.
(L) Josh Reddick -- 94 fastball called strike; 88 changeup, single to center.
(R) Billy Butler -- 85 slider swinging strike; 90 changeup in dirt; 92 fastball, GIDP 6-4-3.
(12 pitches)
FIFTH INNING
(L) Ike Davis -- 92 fastball called strike; 84 breaking pitch swinging strike; 85 breaking pitch down and in; 90 changeup in dirt; 94 fastball, single to left-center (up; beat shift past diving shortstop Francisco Lindor).
(R) Mark Canha -- 93 fastball called strike; 87 off-speed down and away; 86 slider called strike; 94 fastball, swinging strikeout (running down and in).
(L) Eric Sogard -- 93 fastball called strike; 93 fastball, fielder's choice/6-4.
(R) Marcus Semien -- 91 fastball called strike; 87 slider called strike (outside corner); 86 slider foul; 95 fastball outside (Sogard caught stealing).
(15 pitches)
SIXTH INNING
(R) Marcus Semien -- 86 slider down and away; 86 slider swinging strike; 94 fastball inside; 94 fastball, fly to center.
(L) Billy Burns -- 87 changeup, grounder to first.
(L) Stephen Vogt -- 93 fastball called strike; 83 breaking pitch down and in; 88 slider, grounder to first.
(8 pitches)
SEVENTH INNING
(L) Ben Zobrist -- 93 fastball outside; 87 changeup called strike; 90 changeup inside (barely); 94 fastball swinging strike (away); 86 slider foul (ripped right side); 82 breaking pitch, liner to right.
(L) Josh Reddick -- 95 fastball outside; 94 fastball outside; 92 fastball, double to center (over plate at knees; hit wall).
Skinny: Reddick now 5-for-5 with homer career against Carrasco.
(R) Billy Butler -- 93 fastball inside; 88 slider down and away; 87 slider in dirt; 93 fastball called strike; 94 fastball inside, walk.
(Tribe pitching coach Mickey Callaway visits mound.)
(L) Ike Davis -- 94 fastball inside; 93 fastball, RBI double to left-center (Butler to third).
Skinny: Carrasco got underneath sinker, causing it to flatten out and stay up. Pitch tailed onto swing plane.
(Infield in.)
(R) Mark Canha -- 94 fastball swinging strike; 94 fastball high; 87 slider down and in; (Catcher Roberto Perez talks to Carrasco); 94 fastball swinging strike (down and in); 94 fastball, grounder to short.
Skinny: Credit Carrasco and catcher Roberto Perez for sticking with the fastball.
(L) Eric Sogard -- 94 fastball called strike; 94 fastball called strike (outside corner); 95 fastball, fly center.
(24 pitches)