Horse racing experts Bill Murphy and Bob "Railbird" Roberts pick their top five thoroughbreds in the history of the King of Sports.
CLEVELAND, Ohio - The heralded Triple Crown horse races launch Saturday with the Kentucky Derby. It is the beginning of an annual quest to determine which three-year-old in a crowd of talented thoroughbreds is the best in the business that year.
I'll reveal my Kentucky Derby picks in The Plain Dealer on Saturday morning, but the larger question might be which mighty four-legged warriors were the most talented Triple Crown horses of all time. I recruited two of the most astute horseplayers in the country at Monday's season opener at ThistleDown Racino to come up with an answer.
Bill Murphy of Bainbridge served as general manager of Thistledown and South Florida's Gulfstream Park and is presently the vice-president of player development for XpressBet. Bob "Railbird" Roberts has chronicled the Sport of Kings for most of his life, including a long stint at The Plain Dealer.
Serving as moderator for the two deep thinkers of thoroughbred racing, the top choice was obvious. Well, perhaps not everyone. Horse racing fans are encouraged to comment on their all-time favorites, as well.
Here are their picks for the greatest three-year-old thoroughbreds of all time:
Secretariat's record-setting Triple Crown season of 1973 was in a class by itself. Big Red set the speed marks for the Kentucky Derby, Preakness Stakes and Belmont Stakes that still stand. Burned into every horse player's memory, whether they were at Belmont Park or not, was Secretariat's stunning 31-length victory in the Belmont Stakes. The 2:24 win cut two full seconds off the track record for the 11/2-mile race.
Secretariat was on the cover of Sports Illustrated, Time and Newsweek the week before he won the Belmont Stakes. For the record, Secretariat didn't save the farm for owner Penny Chenery, as portrayed in the movie version of Secretariat's Triple Crown season. In 1972, Chenery won the Kentucky Derby and Belmont Stakes with Riva Ridge, a tremendous horse whose Triple Crown hopes were dashed on a sloppy track in the Preakness Stakes. At the same time, Secretariat was bringing home the bacon, winning the top two-year-old stakes.
The only horse to go undefeated on the road to the Triple Crown, every time Seattle Slew stepped on the track in 1977 he was the odds-on favorite and "Slewmania" broke out. The black colt won his three starts as a two-year-old and went six-for-six as a three-year-old, including the Triple Crown races.
Seattle Slew should not have lost another race. Murphy revealed that against the wishes of trainer Billy Turner, after the Belmont Stakes victory owners Karen and Mickey Taylor were lured into shipping Seattle Slew to California for the $400,000 Hollywood Gold Cup. Seattle Slew ran out of gas and J.O. Tobin and jockey Billy Shoemaker ended his undefeated career.
The terrific duels between Affirmed, the last Triple Crown winner, and rival Alydar in 1978 were the stuff of legends. Many experts are certain in almost any other year, Alydar would have swept the Triple Crown races.
Despite Affirmed's 4-2 margin in two-year-old matchups, three-year-old Alydar was the 6-5 favorite to 9-5 Affirmed in the Kentucky Derby. Alydar closed strong, but couldn't catch Affirmed.
The Belmont Stakes was a thriller as the colts battled neck and neck, pulling away from the field. Alydar managed to push his nose in front at mid-stretch, but teen jockey Steve Cauthen went to a left-handed whip for the first time and Affirmed responded for a scant nose victory.
Toss out the Kentucky Derby when considering Man o' War. The big colt wasn't in the Kentucky Derby because owner Samuel Riddle didn't like racing in Kentucky. Man o' War lost just once in 10 starts as a two-year-old, a time when there was no starting gate and the horses circled until the starting flag dropped. In 1920, Man o' War won all 11 of his three-year-old races.
The son of Fair Play was so powerful in the Preakness that after posting a track record of 1:38.3 for the mile, the chestnut colt was eased by jockey Clarence Kummer and posted a leisurely seven-length win. The Belmont Stakes was a shorter race than today at 1 3/8-mile, and Man o' War set an American record for the distance with a 20-length victory in 2:14.20.
Winner of the Triple Crown in 1948, the experts were most impressed with Citation making an astounding 20 starts as a three-year-old, winning 19. Citation's speed was evident in his two-year-old season when he broke the Arlington Park record over five furlongs in the second start of his career.
Citation won eight of nine as a two-year-old and beat older horses at the beginning of his three-year-old season, which would be an incredible feat today. When jockey Al Snider drowned while fishing in the Florida Keys, Hall of Famer Eddie Arcaro took Citation's reins and promptly lost to Saggy in the Chesapeake Trial Stakes. It was the last race Citation lost over almost two years, as Arcaro easily guided him to victories in the Triple Crown races.