Michael Brantley is either among the American Legaue's top three left-fielders, or among the three worst left-fielders -- take your pick.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Well, someone has it wrong.
Michael Brantley was nominated for a Gold Glove in left field. The other two American League candidates are Kansas City's Alex Gordon and Boston's Yoenis Cespedes.
Who picked them?
MLB's Lyle Spencer wrote: "Major League managers and coaches, voting only within their league and unable to vote for players on their own teams, account for 75 percent of the selection process. The other 25 percent goes to the sabermetrics community."
Ah yes ... the sabermetrics community.
I do like many of the advanced stats. Sabermetrics does help to evaluate players. For example, www.fangraphs.com rated second baseman Jason Kipnis and third baseman Lonnie Chisenhall among the worst at their positions in the American League. That is close to what most of us watched this season.
But get this: they rated Brantley as the THIRD worst left fielder in the American League. Only Rajai Davis and Shin-Soo Choo were rated below Brantley.
Out of the 15 left-fielders rated by fangraphs, Brantley came in 13th. Yet, he is in the TOP three according to the vote of the managers and coaches.
Fangraphs and the manager/coaches agree that Gordon and Cespedes are the top two left fielders. The only conflict is Brantley -- and a major one.
He's either very good or very bad.
I know that my judgment on Brantley can be biased. I have loved his game for years, and believed that he'd one day hit for power. I never imagined that he'd put together a season like 2014 (.327, 20 HR, 97 RBI, .890 OPS). But I know that most Tribe fans agree with me that Brantley has been a good player for several seasons.
And that includes the outfield. In 339 games in left field, he has two errors. Last season, he made no errors in left field and threw out 12 runners trying to take an extra base.
Maybe that's not pure Gold, but how can anyone look at Brantley and consider him a brick in the outfield?
Baseball people will tell you that the fielding ratings are still the most debated and subjective.
When it comes to Brantley, I can only go by what most fans also see: A very good left fielder.
Yan Gomes also was nominated for a Gold Glove as a catcher. Fangraphs also has him among the top three defensive catchers in the American League. So the debate centers on Brantley.
ABOUT ZACH MCALLISTER
In their post-season meetings, Terry Francona and his coaching staff were very encouraged by the late-season performance of Zach McAllister.
He was put in the bullpen in September, and responded by having a 2.77 ERA in 13 innings with 14 strikeouts. He walked only two.
The Tribe is taking the same approach to McAllister that they did with Carlos Carrasco, who lost an early season spot in the rotation and then found his confidence in the bullpen.
Carrasco finished the season back in the rotation, where he was 5-3 with a 1.72 ERA in 10 starts after the All-Star break. The Indians don't think something that dramatic can happen with McAllister, who doesn't have the variety of pitches that Carrasco brings to the mound.
But they do believe that McAllister can help in the bullpen. Coaches Mickey Callaway and Kevin Cash told McAllister just to come into the game and throw hard. Use one other pitch. Don't think a lot.
Suddenly, McAllister's velocity rose from an average of 91-92 mph to the 95-97 mph. His fastball was even clocked at 98 mph several times, something that never happened before.
McAllister was 4-7 with a 5.23 ERA overall. He spent part of last season in the minors.
In 2015, McAllister is out of options. He'll be 27 on December 26. They don't want to take a chance on losing him to another team because they believe the right-hander can really help in relief. He can throw multiple innings, and even be a spot starter.
A decent spring will secure a roster spot. In 2013, McAllister was 9-9 with a 3.75 ERA as a starter. The Indians want depth in the rotation, and they think McAllister made major progress as a reliever at the end of the season.
ABOUT NICK HAGADONE
Another Tribe pitcher out of minor league options is Nick Hagadone, and he also received good reviews from the Tribe after the season.
The lefty went up and down three times from the minors in 2014, before arriving for good on July 8. He finished the season with a 1-0 record and 2.70 ERA in 23 1/3 innings. He had 27 strikeouts compared to six walks.
Hagadone will be 29 on New Years day. The lefty has battled control problems. He had 42 walks in 67 big league innings entering 2014.
His average fastball is nearly 95 mph. He throws an 80-mph slider about 25 percent of the time.
Terry Francona loves to use relievers. He set a Major League record for going to the bullpen in 2014.
The manager is excited about the idea of three lefties in relief -- Kyle Crockett, Marc Rzepczynski and Hagadone.
ABOUT JOSH TOMLIN
A third pitcher out of options is righthander Josh Tomlin. He turned 30 on October 19. Right now, he would be considered the No. 7 starter.
The rotation begins with Corey Kluber, Carlos Carrasco, Trevor Bauer, Danny Salazar and T.J. House. McAllister is the No. 6 starter.
Then comes Tomlin, who was 6-9 with a 4.76 ERA.
One theory on Tomlin is that he was still building arm strength after having elbow surgery in August of 2012.
Tomlin was 5-6 with a 4.21 ERA before the All-Star break, 1-3 with a 6.33 ERA after. Did he simply wear down? Will he be stronger next season?
The Indians don't know the answers, but they like the idea of keeping Tomlin around in some role. He has pitched in relief, too.
But of the three pitchers out of options -- McAllister, Hagadone and Tomlin -- it is Tomlin who needs to have the best spring to make the team.
• See Terry's Talkin' Browns.
• See Terry's Talkin' Cavs.