Reds righty Johnny Cueto pitched a complete game in a 9-2 victory over the Indians on Tuesday.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- The Indians played the Cincinnati Reds in the finale of a two-game series Tuesday. Here is a capsule look from The Plain Dealer reporter Dennis Manoloff:
Game: 113.
Opponent: Reds.
Location: Progressive Field, Cleveland.
Time of day: Night.
Time elapsed: 2 hours, 48 minutes.
Attendance: 22,068.
Result: Reds 9, Indians 2.
Records: Reds 57-56, Indians 57-56.
Scoreboard watch: The Indians dropped to 6.5 games behind first-place Detroit (62-48) in the AL Central. The Tigers defeated the Yankees, 4-3, in 12 innings in the Bronx. The Indians remained 2.5 behind in the race for the second wild card because Toronto (60-54) lost at home to Baltimore, 9-3.
Streaks snapped: The Tribe had won four in a row.
The Reds won at Progressive Field for the first time in 11 games. The Tribe's 10-game winning streak had been its longest active at home against any opponent.
Time for Skyline Chili: The teams head to Cincinnati for a two-game series beginning Wednesday night. The Indians lead the all-time series, 45-42, but are 10-19 at Great American Ballpark.
Bottom line, up front: A starting-pitcher mismatch on paper that favored Cincinnati played out as such. Tribe right-hander Josh Tomlin, who entered at 5-7 with a 4.47 ERA, allowed six runs -- five earned -- on eight hits in 4 1/3 innings. Reds righty Johnny Cueto, who entered at 12-6 with a 2.05 ERA, gave up the two runs on five hits in a 117-pitch complete game.
Cueto, Cincinnati's version of Corey Kluber, has allowed three or fewer runs in 11 consecutive starts.
In one sense, the Indians can dismiss the loss as a blip, coming as it did against a terrific pitcher. But the mismatch of Cueto against Tomlin underscores why many aren't taking the Indians seriously as a contender, even if the math does. The Indians' rotation beyond Kluber and, to a certain extent, Trevor Bauer, is highly questionable.
Embarrassment factor: On Monday night, the Indians and Kluber took it to the Reds, 7-1. Cincinnati manager Bryan Price labeled his club's effort "unacceptable,'' citing multiple mental lapses. Where Tuesday's game was concerned, Indians manager Terry Francona could have done the same. The Tribe made several absent-minded plays, including being victimized by Chris Heisey racing home while catcher Brayan Pena was tagged out between first and second in the fifth.
Once they fell behind, 5-1, after 3 1/2, the Indians and their body language suggested they weren't all in. They allowed an offensively challenged opponent to score nine in their house. The Reds out-executed, out-hustled and otherwise outperformed the hosts.
Inexcusable: The Indians -- third baseman Lonnie Chisenhall -- gift-wrapped a run for the Reds in the first.
With Todd Frazier on first and one out, Ryan Ludwick doubled into the left-field corner. Mike Aviles quickly secured the carom and threw to shortstop Jose Ramirez, who tossed to Chisenhall. Frazier was not going to move from third until Chisenhall took his eye off the ball and had it bounce off his glove and roll into foul territory.
As Frazier raced for home, Chisenhall grabbed the ball and made an off-balance throw that actually was in time. But when catcher Yan Gomes caught the ball and put his glove down near the plate, he missed the head-first-sliding Frazier. By the time Gomes located Frazier's body, it was too late -- the hand was in.
Surprise, surprise: Reds No. 9 batter Ramon Santiago ambushed Tomlin with a three-run homer in the second. It gave the Reds a 4-1 lead.
With Cueto on the mound, that translates to Game Over.
Santiago batted with runners on first and second and one out. In preparation for the first pitch, Gomes set up on the outer half and obviously wanted it down. Tomlin missed over the plate at the belt, and Santiago hammered it over the right-field wall. Even for a hitter such as Santiago, the pitch was a cookie. Tomlin can't afford to miss over the plate that badly against anybody.
As the ball sailed over the wall, SportsTime Ohio play-by-play man Matt Underwood said: "Are you kidding me?''
The homer was Santiago's first of the season in 50 games and fourth in 223 games since the beginning of 2012.
Tomlin has allowed 17 homers, including four three-run shots. Tomlin has given up more homers than walks (11).
Shift backfires: Indians second baseman Jason Kipnis, pulled in because of a runner at third and none out in the fourth, made a diving stop to his right to deny Santiago an RBI single. Billy Hamilton followed with a swinging strikeout, but the Reds finally cashed when lefty Jay Bruce tapped an outside changeup past Tomlin for an RBI infield single and 5-1 lead. Ramirez, forced to come a long way because the shift had placed Kipnis in short right, fielded but couldn't get the ball out of his glove. If Ramirez had been able to throw, the play would have been bang-bang.
The Indians, as is the case with most teams, are proud of themselves for their adherence to spray charts. But the harsh reality of the two-game series was, Bruce had five hits, and a case could be made that four were made possible because fielders vacated spots because of the shift.
Two-ball special: The Indians were undone by two baseballs on the field at the same time in the bottom of the seventh.
With David Murphy on first and Chisenhall on third and none out, Gomes doubled off the Cincinnati bullpen fence in right. As Chisenhall scored and Murphy approached second, a pitch from a Reds reliever sailed out of the bullpen and into short-center. Murphy rounded third, saw the ball on the field and hesitated. Reds shortstop Zack Cozart, who had caught the relay, spotted Murphy off third, hesitated and fired to third baseman Santiago, who tagged out Murphy.
The Indians settled for the one run and trailed, 6-2.
The Tribe and its faithful can chalk up the play to bad luck; to a large degree, they are correct. But Murphy can't wander that far down the line -- especially when he makes no commitment to sprint home. (Third-base coach Mike Sarbaugh appeared to be directing Murphy back to the bag. But even if Sarbaugh was late with the directive, Murphy needed to be closer to the bag until he was certain what was happening.)
The Reds were fortunate on another front. Cozart began raising his arms, presumably to call timeout, after Gomes slid into second, but second-base umpire Will Little was watching Gomes and not Cozart.
Spotlight on ... Indians center fielder Michael Brantley: He entered at .324 with 16 homers and 71 RBI. He had 26 multi-hit games since June 1.
First inning (runner on second, one out) -- 89-mph changeup high, ball; 88 changeup up, called strike. 91 fastball outer half, foul; 88 changeup down, foul; 92 fastball inside corner, RBI single to right.
The skinny: Plate umpire Greg Gibson did Brantley no favors by calling the borderline second pitch a strike. Instead of being in command of the count, Brantley needed to be more defensive. Before the decisive pitch, Reds catcher Pena set up on the outer half. As Cueto began his delivery, Pena hopped to the inside corner. The attempted peripheral-vision deke didn't work, Brantley ripping the fastball into the hole at second. Right fielder Bruce, who possesses a good arm, wanted to erase Aviles attempting to score. However, first baseman Todd Frazier recognized the throw would not get Aviles and jumped to cut it off. Frazier's decision ended up being wise; Aviles was going to score and Frazier trapped Brantley attempting to get to second.
Third inning (runner on first, two outs) -- 92 fastball outer half, foul; 93 fastball inside corner, called strike; 90 hard changeup*, grounder to short/fielder's choice.
The skinny: Cueto evened the head-to-head matchup, 1-1, primarily because a superb second pitch: a comeback fastball, with sink, that was a ball for 50 feet. Entering Tuesday, batters against Cueto were 18-for-125 (.144) with 61 strikeouts after an 0-2 count. Cueto retired Brantley using a hard changeup (*or, Cueto took something off the fastball to get more movement).
Sixth inning (none on, one out) -- 91 fastball up, ball; 81 curve, grounder to short.
The skinny: Cueto dusted off the curve, and Brantley made solid contact. He wasn't robbed, though: It was a routine groundout.
Eighth inning (none on, two outs): 92 fastball outside corner, grounder to second.
The skinny: Not one of Brantley's finest ABs. The pitch had good tailing action -- but Brantley knew that.
Brantley's streak of multi-hit games ended at five.