Manager Terry Francona on third base: "I don't think there's anybody who would argue that Lonnie (Chisenhall) deserves to be playing third base."
CLEVELAND, Ohio – The cat-and-mouse game is over.
Lonnie Chisenhall is the Indians' third baseman and there's no telling when Carlos Santana will get another shot at the hot corner. Along those same lines, it seems like Santana is the first baseman and there's no telling when Nick Swisher will get a chance to reclaim that job on a full-time basis.
"To be honest with you, we're trying to put the best team out there that we can," said manager Terry Francona, before Sunday's 10-4 loss to Detroit. "I don't think there's anybody who would argue that Lonnie deserves to be playing third base.
"We don't do the positions based on what guys want to do. Lonnie has done a great job."
The chronology among Santana, Chisenhall and Swisher is interesting.
-Santana ended last season as the full-time DH/backup catcher after losing the starting catcher's job to Yan Gomes. He spent all winter working out at third base and won the job in spring training. Santana opened the season as the starting third baseman and backup catcher, but still spent time at DH and first base.
Today Santana is the regular first baseman and sometimes DH. He has not played third since May 22 and has not caught since suffering a concussion on May 25 at Camden Yards.
Of course, if Santana didn't get off to the worst start in his career at the plate, he'd probably still be the regular third baseman. After Sunday's game, he's hitting .202 (47-for-233) with 15 doubles, one triple, 11 homers and 29 RBI. It's just the second game in which Santana has been above .200 since April 10 when he had only 32 at-bats.
-Chisenhall ended last season in a platoon at third base with Mike Aviles. He made the team out of spring training as an extra player. While Santana couldn't buy a hit in the first two months of the season, Chisenhall is hitting .355 (71-for-200) with 18 doubles, eight homers and 33 RBI despite going 0-for-4 Sunday. Since June 7, he's started 14 straight games at third base.
As to who's the better third baseman, Chisenhall made his 11th error Sunday. Santana has six.
-Swisher ended last season as the regular first baseman, a job he kept this season until going on the disabled list with a hyper-extend left knee on May 27. Before going on the DL, Swisher made 46 starts at first, but he's made only one in the last nine games since being activated.
He received cortisone shots in both knees during his DL stay and is still moving gingerly. Francona said it's best that he stays at DH for now.
Santana, for his part, might be a better defensive first baseman than Swisher as this stage of his career. Swisher, whose knee problems have limited his range, has made six errors at first. Santana hasn't made an error in 18 starts at first.
"What is kind of cool about all the work Carlos put in at third base is that I think it has made him a better first baseman," said Francona. "He's more active. He's more agile. So we'll see where it goes."
As always, performance drives a manager's lineup card. Santana and Swisher have struggled at the plate. Chisenhall, 5-for-22 (.227) during the homestand, has flourished overall.
Swisher is 4-for-37 (.108) since coming off the DL. Overall, he's hitting .194 (43-for-222) and has not had his average above .231 since the first day of the season.
"Players dictate how you write the lineup out by the way they play," said Francona.
Check-up: Outfielder Nyjer Morgan (right knee) will come to Cleveland on Monday for a check up. He's been rehabbing in Goodyear, Ariz., and his eight to 12 week timetable for recovery has not changed.
Finally: The three-game series with the Tigers drew 100,280 fans to Progressive Field. The last time the Indians drew over 100,000 for a three-game series was Aug 26-Aug. 28, 2011 against Kansas City. . .Jason Kipnis went 1-for-14 against Detroit this weekend and 3-for-26 (.115) for the homestand.