The Indians had plenty of offense but nowhere near enough pitching Sunday against the Twins. The Tribe lost, 10-7.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- The Indians played the Minnesota Twins in the finale of a three-game series Sunday at Progressive Field. Here is a capsule look from The Plain Dealer reporter Dennis Manoloff, who filed from the DMan Cave in Northeast Ohio after watching the SportsTime Ohio telecast:
Game: 6
Opponent: Minnesota Twins.
Location: Progressive Field.
Time of day: Afternoon.
Result: Twins 10, Indians 7.
Records: Indians 3-3, Twins 3-3.
Quality performances: Twins -- DH Chris Colabello (2-for-5, 4 RBI, R), 1B Joe Mauer (3-for-4, BB, 2 R), 2B Brian Dozier (0-for-2, 3 BB, 3 R), RF Jason Kubel (2-for-4, RBI, R). Indians -- RF David Murphy (4-for-5, RBI), 2B Jason Kipnis (2-for-5, 3 RBI, R), LF Michael Brantley (3-for-5, RBI, R), 3B Carlos Santana (2-for-3, 2 BB), 1B Nick Swisher (2-for-4, BB, R).
Forgettable games: Indians -- RHP Justin Masterson (3 2/3 IP, 7 H, 6 R/5 ER, 3 BB, 4 K), RHP Blake Wood (2/3 IP, H, 3 R, 2 BB), SS Mike Aviles (0-for-5, R, 19 pitches). Twins -- SS Pedro Florimon (0-for-5, 19 pitches).
No Twinkies for you: The Indians fattened on the Twins last season, winning 13 of 19. The Twins are one-third of the way to their 2013 season-series victory total after winning two of three in the Tribe's house.
Tough to take: The Indians lost despite their offense having delivered seven runs on 15 hits and six walks, and their defense having turned three double plays. The Tribe was 3-for-16 with runners in scoring position and left 12 on base.
Too many freebies: Seven of the Minnesota runners who scored had reached via walk or hit by pitch.
Fast fact: The teams combined to throw 390 pitches -- 196 by Cleveland, 194 by Minnesota.
Unhappy trails: The Indians played from behind for the fifth consecutive game.
The season opener in Oakland was scoreless until the ninth inning, when the Tribe scored twice in the ninth and won, 2-0. Since then:
• Game 2 @ Oakland: Trailed after one (1-0), two (3-0) and three (5-0). Lost, 6-1.
• Game 3 @ Oakland: Trailed after one (2-0). Won, 6-4.
• Game 4 vs. Minnesota: Trailed after one (2-0). Won, 7-2.
• Game 5 vs. Minnesota: Trailed after one (3-0) and after 2 1/2 (5-0). Lost, 7-3.
• Game 6 vs. Minnesota: Trailed after 1 1/2 (2-0) and after three (5-2). Lost, 10-7.
Non-starters: On Opening Day, Masterson gave up three hits in seven innings. The Tribe's next five starts -- by Corey Kluber, Zach McAllister, Danny Salazar, Carlos Carrasco and Masterson -- have produced a combined line of 22 1/3 innings, 35 hits, 21 runs, 19 earned runs. None of those five has reached the seventh inning.
Not masterful: In his second start, Masterson essentially was a one-pitch pitcher -- and he didn't even have his typical command of that one pitch, the sinker. His occasional four-seamers were ineffective, and he lacked a feel for the slider until the third inning. The changeup was a non-factor. He periodically struggled with his release point.
Masterson pitched poorly, no question, but his defense let him down on several occasions.
Numbers game: Masterson needed 97 pitches to get his 11 outs. He threw 44 balls. The next three Tribe pitchers, Scott Atchison, Wood and Marc Rzepczynski, needed 47 pitches to get the next seven outs. It meant that Tribe pitchers used 144 pitches (67 balls) in six innings.
The igniter: Leadoff man Dozier, a solid player, inflicted Rickey Henderson-type damage in the series.
On Friday, Dozier was 3-for-5 with a run. He led off the game with a double. On Saturday, he was 1-for-4. He led off the game with a homer. On Sunday, he didn't have a hit in the first or any inning but still disrupted.
Mixed bag: Gomes hit a two-run homer in the second, which kept him out of the forgettable-game column. Nonetheless, he would have liked to have this game back.
Gomes went 0-for-3 with runners in scoring position and, for the second straight day, was shaky behind the plate.
With Dozier on third, Mauer on first and one out in the third, Gomes was too eager to trigger a double play on Colabello's dribbler in front of the plate. Gomes pounced and threw the ball over vacated second base and into center field. Jason Kipnis and Mike Aviles, based on their depths, didn't have time to get to the bag.
Yes, such a play is easy to second-guess, especially after replays, but ... Gomes could have caught Dozier, who was too far down the line, with a straight throw or pump-fake. At worst for Cleveland, it would have been first and second with two outs. Instead, the Twins had a three-run inning.
Later in the game, Gomes missed an opportunity to throw out Dozier attempting to steal because the ball popped out of his glove on the transfer.
Bad-ball magic: Murphy has made a good living from converting pitches out of the zone into hits. He definitely did so twice, and a third instance was borderline.
In the second inning, Murphy ripped a down-and-in sinker from righty Ricky Nolasco into the right-field corner for a double. It featured Murphy's best swing mechanics of the season. Catcher Kurt Suzuki, set up away in a 1-1 count, had reached for a pitch that umpire Jerry Meals could have called a ball or strike.
In the fourth, Murphy essentially one-handed a 1-2 low changeup, fllcking it into right for a single. In the fifth, he reached for a 1-2 fastball down and away from righty Anthony Swarzak and dumped it near the left-field line for an RBI double. In the seventh, Murphy returned to the conventional against lefty Caleb Thielbar, staying on a fastball up and away and lining it to left for a single.
Murphy flied out in the ninth. The 4-for-5 raised his average from .143 to .316.
Return to comfort zone: Both of Kipnis's hits resulted from sending fastballs away hard to left field. The opposite-field stroke is what served Kipnis so well in his All-Star season of 2013.
With the bases loaded in the fourth, Kipnis ripped the first pitch off the left-field wall for a three-run double. Moments earlier, Twins pitching coach Rick Anderson had visited Nolasco. Pitchers almost always throw a fastball immediately after the pitching coach visits, regardless of situation, and Kipnis was sitting on it.
In the sixth, Kipnis lined a single to left off Swarzak.
Kipnis had been thoroughly frustrated in the third inning. With Swisher on first, Kipnis put a good swing on a 2-2 off-speed pitch and sent it high and deep to right. Kipnis thought he had homered to pull Cleveland within 5-4 -- and so, it seemed, did Nolasco -- but Kubel caught the ball on the track. A cool breeze blowing in helped keep it in the field of play.
Missed foul: With one out in the sixth and the score tied, 6-6, Wood threw a fastball up and in to Dozier, who spun out of the way. Umpire Jerry Meals called the pitch a ball, but replays conclusively showed the ball glanced off the barrel.
Who knows what might have happened if Wood had Dozier in a 1-2 count instead of 2-1. (Based on the way Dozier was handling the bat and Wood was pitching, Dozier might have reached, regardless.) What did happen was Dozier took a strike, then two balls for a walk.
The Twins, well aware that Wood is vulnerable to the running game, wasted no time. On the first pitch to Mauer, Dozier raced for second and beat a good throw by Gomes. Dozier eventually scored the first of three runs on a double by Colabello to make it 9-6.
Hungry pitchers: Meals did not have one of his better days, his zone floating for both teams. The fastball above the belt, in particular, gave Meals trouble: One inning, it was a strike; the next, a ball.
Curious decisions: The Indians struggled to defend against Mauer, a three-time A.L. batting champion. After Dozier's leadoff walk in the third, Mauer, on a hit-and-run, punched a single through a spot vacated when Aviles went to cover. For the shortstop to cover when a lefty bats is standard, but Mauer is no ordinary lefty. He loves to go to left and left-center, a task made that much easier because Masterson's sinker is going to tail away from him.
In the eighth, the Indians shifted against Mauer, Santana playing well off third. Mauer noticed and punched an inside pitch over third for a double.
Short-circuit: The game's shortstops, Aviles and Florimon, combined to go 0-for-10. They were 0-for-4 with runners in scoring position.
Memo to STO: Bring back the pitch-speed and K-box graphics.