The Cleveland Indians have blunted the criticism heard late in spring training when they failed to reach a contract settlement with pitcher Justin Masterson.
CLEVELAND, Ohio – In the past two years, the Indians have committed $200 million to Nick Swisher, Michael Bourn, Jason Kipnis, Michael Brantley and Yan Gomes.
That won’t suddenly make the fan base embrace Paul Dolan as the Monopoly Man -- cash spilling from his pockets as he adjusts his top hat.
The signings have a more important and practical benefit beyond helping repair ownership’s image as penny pinchers. The Indians have 16 players under contract through 2016. And, even better, some of them are pretty good.
The side benefit: The signings have managed to blunt the criticism heard when the Indians failed to reach a contract extension with No. 1 starter Justin Masterson late in spring training. Or at least it should.
It doesn’t mean the Indians are any more likely to sign players who stand to strike it rich on the free-agent market. They aren’t. What it means is they’re investing in a core group of everyday players who can help them survive inevitable defections.
One of the anti-Dolan arguments I heard after talks with Masterson ended was that they were sending the wrong message to a clubhouse that came together last season, bought into Terry Francona, and came back looking to revive the good vibes that carried them to a historic finish and into the postseason for the first time in six years.
And, somehow, not signing Masterson was jeopardizing that.
With whom? Swisher, who signed for four years and $56 million last year, and who is so positive he could probably find something nice to say about Cleveland’s potholes (“I needed a new axle anyway, bro.”)?
Bourn? Who signed for four years and $48 million?
Brantley? Gomes?
Kipnis, who knew his day was coming?
"It's the ownership, the top, showing us that they believe in us, that we've got the guys who can win games now and we want them stick around," Kipnis said after signing his deal. "I'm excited about being a part of that. The decision to sign was a lot easier knowing we’re going in the right direction.”
“This is not a one-and-done organization anymore,” Swisher told reporters Friday. “The moves we’re making are all the right moves. It not only helps in the locker room, but it helps the fan base. We’re starting to create an identity.”
Swisher said ownership was “putting their money where their mouth is.” Some will say they won’t speak loudly enough until they sign one of their own established stars, as the Reds did in retaining Joey Votto and the Tigers did in signing Miguel Cabrera and the Twins did in keeping Joe Mauer.
You could make the argument the Indians haven’t had a hitter as good as those three in recent years, but that would suggest they’d have kept them if they had.
Nobody is suggesting the Dolans couldn’t use an investor (or three). But until that happens they’re going about it the best way they can in a sport with no salary cap and in a modest market where attendance is lagging (to be as kind as possible).
It might never make sense for the Indians to sign a player who accounts for 20 percent or more of their payroll, but if they do it should be a position player.
If it’s a pitcher he’d better be their answer to Clayton Kershaw. In the meantime, the Dolans have built a winning team around a two-time World Series champion manager.
They’re going to be together, generally speaking, for the next couple years. There’s still a chance Masterson is part of that, though when players get the sniff of free agency they don’t often close the windows and pull the drapes.
For now, signing the players they’ve signed doesn’t turn Paul Dolan into Bill Gates. Just as not signing Masterson doesn’t portend more of the same backsliding.
That’s at least a change for the better.
SPINOFFS
• Kyrie Irving took to Twitter to address speculation – you can’t even really call it a report – that he wants out of Cleveland.
Two things:
I don’t blame him for lashing out.
And since he doesn’t say in any of his Tweets that he plans on signing a max deal and being here long term, he should expect to hear it until he does.
• Making the playoffs (unlikely now, to be kind) would be a good experience -- ff you discount one dangerous message it would send: A lack of effort most of the season can be overcome with six weeks of actual trying.
• An Indians fan debated the validity of Chief Wahoo as an acceptable team logo with a Native American protestor at Friday’s home opener.
You don’t need a strong opinion on the subject to offer the fan some advice for next time.
One would probably have a better chance convincing a Native American that the Chief is a harmless cartoon and not an insensitive stereotype if you are not in red-face and wearing a head dress while the conversation is taking place.
• DeSean Jackson emphatically told ESPN, “I am not a gang member.”
Jackson admitted he’s lifelong friends with guys who have belonged to gangs. So we suspect the Eagles did not release him on the basis of a personal profile where he lists “West Side Story” as his favorite Broadway play.
The question remains: Why would a team trade away a player at the top of his game allegedly because of his associations?
Asked Ron Harper.
• Not long after getting good news from the courts on his “Johnny Football” trademark battle, Johnny Manziel is applying to trademark the phrase “The House That Johnny Built.”
And still some NFL coaches -- like Minnesota’s Mike Zimmer -- wonder if Manziel is too interested in the celebrity and riches that go with being a NFL quarterback.
• The catch for Manziel in the latest trademark issue is that Fitch Estate Sales has already applied for the trademark. Nate Fitch, the owner of the company, is known as Uncle Nate. He was at Manziel’s side for autograph sessions that landed Manziel a half-game suspension this past season.
Despite that suspension, there’s yet no move to trademark the phrase “Pulling the wool over the NCAA’s eyes.”
• Russell Wilson says he wants to be the best quarterback in the NFL history.
Meanwhile, you get the impression Manziel’s goal is to have his big hands imprinted on the Hollywood Walk of Fame.
• Jason Kipnis turned 27 Thursday, then signed a contract guaranteeing him $52 million Friday. Seems like an easy decision but it wasn’t.
He had to accept he’d never make a newspaper reporter’s salary and was probably best off settling for half a hundred mil.
• The last three women to appear on the cover of Golf Digest: Paulina Gretzky, the fianceé of PGA Tour pro Dustin Johnson; actress Kate Upton (with Arnold Palmer) and Golf Channel's Holly Sonders.
What do they have in common? If your first thought was that they can all teach you how to hit a fade from a hook lie, keep guessing.
• The LPGA isn’t exactly thrilled with Golf Digest’s choice, since none of the three cover girls are Tour players and the last time a LPGA player appeared on the cover was 2008.
I don’t want to say they have a point, but the SI Swimsuit Issue thinks Golf Digest is a little too obvious in pandering to its male readership.
• Golf Digest editor Jerry Tarde answered the criticism by saying, “Sports figures, celebrities and models have appeared on Golf Digest covers since the magazine's beginning. Paulina ranks at the high end of the golf celebrity scene today, and she has a compelling story to tell. She also might get some new people interested in the game."
And by that he means interested in checking out the gallery while Dustin Johnson plays.
• The Mets’ Daniel Murphy left the team to be at his wife’s side for the birth of his child and took heat from WFAN co-host Boomer Esiason for abandoning his teammates. Because nothing says a player can be at his wife’s side for three days after the birth of a child.
Except common sense and the collective bargaining agreement.
• Esiason, who does great work with the March of Dimes, apologized for suggesting Murphy’s wife, who had a C-section, should’ve scheduled it before the season.
As if C-sections are haircut appointments.
• Teddy Bridgewater and Manziel worked out for New England.
Either Bill Belichick is going to make a major move on draft day or one of these quarterbacks is going to fall far enough to make Brady Quinn’s wait in the green room look like a two-minute drill.
• Alshon Jeffery, former South Carolina star receiver, says the Gamecocks’ Jadeveon Clowney will dominate the NFL.
Which is quite the guarantee, since he didn’t dominate college football last year.
• South Carolina quarterback Connor Shaw says Clowney was in a lose-lose situation with the expectations heaped on him by “all the media.”
The bigger issue: His coach, Steve Spurrier, didn’t exactly rave about his work ethic. And Spurrier is the guy who was casual enough to have adopted “HBC” as his title when he was head coach of the Redskins.
“Head Ball Coach.”
It said on the golf cart he used to get around.
• Spurrier bristled at the notion he ran a country club as NFL head coach. My favorite defense of that came in a 2002 AP story:
“As expected, Spurrier keeps shorter hours and makes his practices less physically demanding than most NFL coaches. But it's a misconception to think he doesn't work long and hard between his rounds of golf.”
Between his rounds of golf.
Beautiful.
• Browns head coach Mike Pettine weighed in on the knocks against Clowney: “I think if you’re strong and assertive as a coach, you can get that guy to be more focused and get him to be much more consistent.”
In different words, Pettine was speaking for every woman who’s ever said, “I can change him.”
YOU SAID IT
(The Expanded Weekend Edition)
Bud: Considering what a poor rookie season Anthony Bennett had this year, what do you think are his chances of winning "Comeback Player of the Year" next season? – Fred Corrigan, Orlando, Fla.
Who is this Anthony Bennett you speak of?
Sir: I am the Head of Operations at Dah Sing Bank, Hong Kong. I do not know if we can work together in transferring US$12.8 million from my bank to your bank account. If you are interested I shall provide you with more details – Song Chen
Great. What could go wrong?
Bud: Any chance we'll see Steven Seagal and Dennis Rodman as Exalted Ruler and First Lady, respectively, of some tiny Baltic country in the near future? – Jim Corrigan, Fairview Park
How did you make off with the script from the next Seagal movie?
Bud: If a smart guy tells a joke that only the dumb guy laughs at, is it really funny? -- Nate J, Brunswick
Asking me about humor is like asking Dennis Rodman about international diplomacy.
Bud: Do you need a degree to write Shaw’s Spin? -- Angelo
No. It just requires complete career resignation.
Bud: With Tiger Woods out indefinitely from playing the PGA Tour, can we expect mass layoffs of their Rules Officials? – Brian, Hudson
First-time “You Said It” winners receive a T-shirt from the Mental Floss collection.
Bud: Re: the A.J. McCarron-Katherine Webb engagement. Brent Musberger will be the Schwing Bearer – Kilgore Trout
Repeat winners get left at the altar.
Bud: Did Miguel Cabrera sign up for Obamacare before the deadline? -- Flo
If repeat winners have a shirt, they can keep their shirt. They just can't get another one.