The Browns found a sure thing in offensive coordinator Kyle Shanahan. Waiting on Seattle's Dan Quinn to interview a second time for the head coaching position would've been the opposite -- a risk with no guarantees.
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Spend enough time in a sports town stuck on the outside looking in at 48 Super Bowls, you’re not surprised what people were thinking after Seattle’s defense, coordinated by Dan Quinn, shut down Peyton Manning and the Denver Broncos on Sunday.
Why didn’t the Browns wait?
The answer is obvious. Waiting would've cost them one coach: Mike Pettine and maybe even a second, Kyle Shanahan. (More in a minute on Shanahan, who would’ve been a good hire in early January but is especially so this late in the process.)
Pettine didn’t want to keep Buffalo head coach Doug Marrone hanging and told the Bills' flagship station he probably would’ve removed his name if told the search would extend beyond the Super Bowl.
The Browns hadn’t spent nearly as much time with Quinn as they’d spent with Pettine. Certainly not enough time to know for sure that he was their man. Or that they were his team.
Despite Quinn saying after the Super Bowl he would’ve loved to talk to the Browns again, and that he considered the opportunity “big-time,” what if the Browns’ job didn’t offer him the money and/or the responsibility he sought?
Then what? Coach by committee for 2014? Bring back Chud on an interim basis? Coach Banner?
Jimmy Haslam, acting on a guuuut feeling, hires Butch Davis?
Twice in the last quarter century – yes, it’s almost been that long since Bill Belichick – the Browns waited until after the Super Bowl and hired the defensive coordinator from the latest dynasty-in-the-making. Belichick was the first. Still trying to catch the wave that swallowed them, the Browns bet on the Belichick connection again with the hiring of Romeo Crennel to replace Davis.
How’d that work out?
(By the way, speaking of Belichick, do yourself a favor and watch Frank Caliendo’s ESPN mockumentary on Richard Sherman. The Belichick impersonation is beautiful.)
There’s no guarantee Quinn will become a better head coach than Pettine. And no guarantee he won’t. Just because he’s watching Pete Carroll do it right in Seattle doesn’t mean he could replicate it here. Carroll didn't get it right his first time around.
The angst over the Browns wrapping up their search before Quinn interviewed a second time should be mitigated, in some way, by the fact that moving ahead allowed the Browns to come to terms with Shanahan.
I’m not saying there was another offensive coordinator job out there for him. But he was looking for work, and maybe wouldn’t have been Quinn’s choice had Quinn taken the job.
Shanahan has worked with mobile quarterbacks (Robert Griffin III and Kirk Cousins to a lesser extent) and not so-mobile quarterbacks (Matt Schaub). He’s had six years of offensive coordinator experience in two cities. His hiring should bring a sense of relief, if not comfort, for one side of the ball. Whatever you think of Rob Chudzinski’s shortcomings as a head coach, players respected him and Norv Turner for their grasp of offense.
Shanahan helps fill that void and blunt the shock that comes when a new regime pledging to bring stability turns things upside down 11 months later.
We won’t know about Pettine until next fall. We won’t know about Quinn until 2015 at the earliest. Shanahan is the surest hire the Browns made. Surer than Dan Quinn.
SPINOFFS
• Brett Favre made a pre-Super Bowl TV appearance in which he dismissed the notion that Peyton Manning had to win a second Super Bowl to cement his legacy as one of the all-time greats.
“Absolutely ridiculous,” said Favre.
Who won one Super Bowl.
• Former big-leaguer Fernando Tatis is a prolific Tweeter. After the Super Bowl, he gave the Broncos a poke:
He did exactly that, hitting two grand slams in an inning once. Tatis took some heat for his Tweet. But cut him some slack. Most of what Tatis Tweets is humorous. So he won’t mind if we point out he also had eight RBI for the season in 2006.
And six RBI for the season in 2010.
• Hearing speculation of the Browns trading for Washington’s Kirk Cousins because of the Kyle Shanahan connection.
The Browns already have that quarterback. His name is Brian Hoyer and he’s better.
• Apparently some see the standard for good quarterback play as being able to beat the Browns. Cousins is 1-0 in that department. He threw for over 300 yards against them in a 2012 victory.
All that really makes him is John Skelton, who threw for 313 in Arizona’s 2011 win over the Browns.
• In three consecutive starts to end the 2013 season, Cousins threw four touchdowns and five interceptions.
If that makes him “must-have,” we owe Brandon Weeden, Colt McCoy and a lot of other quarterbacks who’ve started here since 1999 a heartfelt apology for ushering them out of town.
• Joakim Noah was ejected Monday night but not before he sought out three refs individually and told each what he could do to himself. He later apologized.
“I’m really disappointed,” Noah told reporters. “I shouldn’t have acted that way.”
Bulls coach Tom Thibodeaux said he did not believe Noah would be suspended as a result of his expletive-laden tirade.
Which must mean they’ve done away with suspensions under new NBA commissioner Adam Silver.
• The Cavs lost to Dallas 124-107 Monday night. It is widely viewed as progress.
Sadly.
• A man who claims former Patriots tight end Aaron Hernandez once shot him in the face in Florida was shot again in an incident outside a Hartford nightclub.
For the first time since his arrest on murder charges, Hernandez has a believable alibi.
• If there’s a greater case of culture shock than a Jamaican bobsledder being dropped onto an icy track in Sochi, Russia at the Winter Olympics, it’s Luol Deng leaving the Bulls for the Cavaliers.
• Browns defensive end Desmond Bryant Tweeted pics of his Super Bowl seats, high above Met Life Stadium. They were, in his words, a “bum-ass view.” He later deleted the Tweet.
Bryant said he paid for the seats. If so, he deserves to complain. But he probably won’t get much sympathy here, given the Super Bowl view Browns’ fans have had for the past 48 years.
• Surprised no one has submitted the obvious Separated at Birth: Eva Gabor in “Green Acres” and Joe Namath at the Super Bowl.
• Ray Guy became the first punter elected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
Since punters participate in about 2 percent of all plays from scrimmage, I guess what we’re saying is, don’t give up hope Ryan Pontbriand, you might still have a chance.
• Russell Wilson expects to make an appearance at the spring training camp of the Texas Rangers, who selected him in the December Rule 5 draft.
If he’s trying to prove he’s better than Brandon Weeden in two sports, that’s just rubbing it in.
• The Super Bowl MVP press conference was interrupted by a protester who shouted his belief that Sept. 11 was “perpetrated by our own government.”
My only fear when I hear these kinds of stories of ridiculous public spectacle in the national spotlight -- aside from the security lapse that allowed the person entry: don’t let it be a “You Said It” contributor.
• A Newark Star Ledger story on tax breaks afforded the NFL for bringing the Super Bowl to New Jersey points out the league brings in approximately $255 million in revenues annually while generating billions in broadcasting and licensing deals.
Roger Goodell made $29.4 million in 2011.
So, obviously, you can see why the league has nonprofit status with the IRS.
• Richard Sherman says the Seahawks cracked Peyton Manning’s code, knew what routes he favored in certain situations and even intercepted some of his hand signals at the line of scrimmage.
“Me, Earl (Thomas), Kam (Chancellor), we’re not just three All-Pro players, we’re three All-Pro minds.”
In three short weeks, Sherman has gone from screaming at the top of his lungs about Michael Crabtree’s inferiority, to a much quieter approach.
Still there's no greater trash talk than saying you’re smarter than Peyton Manning.
• The Houston Texans are said to be leaning toward using the No. 1 overall pick in the May draft on quarterback Blake Bortles or Johnny Manziel.
And if they’re saying that in February, two weeks before the scouting combine and three months before the draft, it must be true?
• An employee at Purell, based in Akron, made a joke about the Broncos playing like the Cleveland Browns in Super Bowl XLVIII, and many Browns fans did not like it. Who can blame them? When a hand sanitizing product makes fun of your football team, them’s fighting words.
Twitter is sacred ground where Browns fans take a pledge to only make fun of their team to each other.
YOU SAID IT
(The Expanded Super Bowl Hangover Edition)
Bud: What was more embarrassing? The way the Broncos played in the Super Bowl or Joe Namath’s fur coat? -- Angelo
I’d have to say Namath’s coin toss getting intercepted.
Bud: Is it true Kyle Shanahan's offenses almost always almost finish in the top 10 in the NFL? – Vince G, Cincinnati
The only pressure he’ll feel here is to lose less than seven straight to end the season.
Bud: Have U.S. Olympians been advised to not let Vladimir Putin try on their medals? – Tony Supan
Where were you when Bob Kraft needed you?
Bud: Is there a picture of Mike Lombardi in the Browns' media guide? – Pat Lee.
I believe it's either a picture of him or of Keyser Soze.
Bud: Did Chris Christie shut down Peyton Manning’s passing lane? – William Adams
Not sure. I just know if you come to a bridge in a car with Denver center Manny Ramirez don't let him throw the toll into the coin basket.
Hey Bud: I $ee Roger Goodell i$ entertaining the idea of expanding the NFL playoff$ by adding more team$, claiming it would boo$t the competition. You don’t think the commi$$ioner ha$ ulterior motive$ do you? Your thought$ would be appreciated. – RJM, Fairview Park
$hocked.
Hey, Bud:
Any truth to the rumor that Broadway Joe was just wearing the fur until Anthony Kiedis from the Chili Peppers needed it? -- Jim G.. Bay Village
I believe he was hoping to share it with Suzy Kolber.
Bud: Heard a rumor a new commercial will show Papa John tossing Peyton Manning a pizza box when he isn't looking and it sailing over his shoulder and out of the back of the restaurant. – Eddie Vidmar
First-time “You Said It” winners receive a T-shirt from the Mental Floss collection.
Bud: With the bad first snap in the Super Bowl, was that just Manny being Manny? -- Ted, Concord.
Repeat winners are in error if they think they’re getting another shirt.