Another Sunday, another loss. Jason Campbell doesn't bear all the blame, but he left too much on the field.
CLEVELAND, Ohio – Jason Campbell performed poorly in the Browns’ 38-31 loss to the Bears on Sunday afternoon at Cleveland Browns Stadium. Recognizing that weather conditions were not easy to navigate, and that his receivers could have played better, Campbell left much too much on the field in going 23-of-39 for 273 yards and one touchdown. He was intercepted twice.
Campbell’s day was in stark contrast to that of the previous Sunday, when he went 29-of-44 for 391 yards and three TDs in a 27-26 loss at New England.
Upon dvr review of the Fox Sports telecast, here are some other observations:
Browns vs. Bears
- Five observations from the Cleveland Browns' 38-31 loss to the Chicago Bears
- Video: Analysis of Cleveland Browns 38-31 loss to the Bears with Mary Kay Cabot and Tom Reed
- Despite two defensive touchdowns, the Browns fall to the Bears, 38-31, in home finale
- Cleveland Browns' defense falters yet again in another fourth-quarter collapse
- Cleveland Browns' Tashaun Gipson contributed big plays, but rues the one he didn't make
- Cleveland Browns have little hope without Josh Gordon playing a big role - Bud Shaw
- Cleveland Browns post-game scribbles: Davone Bess has dropped the ball this season - Terry Pluto
- Edwin Baker steps up in first NFL game, but offensive woes continue: Cleveland Browns Insider
- Cleveland Browns home season ends with a shiver, a shrug and another loss: Terry Pluto
Points not made: Campbell’s offense accounted for 17 points, seven of which came with the Bears in command late in the fourth quarter. The Bears are not pushovers defensively, but they aren’t exactly stingy, either. One of the reasons is the injury list: Among those sidelined against the Browns were standout cornerback Charles Tillman and linebacker Lance Briggs.
Quality lacking: On a subjective rating scale of 1 (lousy) to 3 (standard-issue) to 5 (superb), Campbell managed two 4s and one 5. He had seven 2s and three 1s.
A total of 35 attempts were graded. Reasons for not grading an attempt included throwaway; QB hit; receiver slip; QB/WR miscommunication.
The lone 5 occurred on Campbell’s final throw – a 43-yard TD to Josh Gordon with 59 seconds left. No question Campbell made a terrific pass into a tight window along the left sideline, but Chicago having led by two touchdowns at the time of the drop-back diluted the impact.
One of the 1s came on the final play of the first half. The Browns had first-and-10 at the Chicago 47 with the score tied, 10-10. As the Browns huddled in advance of a desperation heave, analyst Brian Billick, a former NFL head coach, said: “It used to irritate me in practice, when you’d say, ‘Look, we’re going to take our shot’ – and then the quarterback comes in and throws it out of bounds. Well, hey, if you’re going to do that, man, tell me. I’d have handed it off so we can get more running stats or something. But don’t just throw the Hail Mary out of bounds.’’
Billick proved prophetic. Campbell stepped up in the pocket against a three-man rush and fired down the left sideline intended for tight end Jordan Cameron. Bears safety Craig Steltz caught the ball a couple of feet out of bounds at the 2.
Such throws are difficult and very much up for grabs, which is why they typically don’t warrant grades. But this one necessitated a 1 because it went out of bounds, thereby giving Cameron no shot at even a fortuitous tip. (The Browns need help on the desperation deep stuff. Two weeks earlier against Jacksonville, their last play of the game when trailing by four came from the Cleveland 48. The formation basically was the same: Gordon, Greg Little and Davone Bess on the right; Cameron on the left. Brandon Weeden threw to the right and gave his guys a chance in the end zone -- except that Gordon was the only Brown anywhere near the ball. One of five Jaguars to have surrounded Gordon knocked the ball away to preserve a 32-28 victory.)
Distance issues: With his final pass as the most notable outlier, Campbell struggled mightily to make plays downfield. Campbell went 3-of-14 for 67 yards on passes that traveled 10-plus yards from the line of scrimmage. The TD and picks were part of that group.
A 3-for-14 inefficiency is inexcusable, especially when one of the targets is the heretofore sizzling Gordon.
Campbell’s 1s other than the Hail Mary also resulted from throws 10-plus yards in the air:
• Second quarter, second-and-5 at Cleveland 33: Interception by cornerback Zack Bowman at Chicago 40 on pass intended for Cameron. Yes, Campbell was forced to hurry after defensive tackle Stephen Paea beat center Alex Mack. Yes, Cameron appeared to be running in slow motion as he came out of his break on a wheel route along the left sideline. Regardless, that pass never should have been thrown. As Campbell loaded, Cameron turned upfield at the Cleveland 40 and immediately encountered traffic. Bowman, who had peeled off Little in a zone scheme, was in excellent position two steps ahead of Cameron while watching Campbell’s eyes. Campbell, though, didn’t seem to see Bowman.
Play-by-play man Thom Brennaman summed up the decidedly imperfect pass perfectly, saying: “Campbell just throws into coverage, and easily intercepted by Zackary Bowman. Poor decision there by Campbell.’’
• Third quarter, second-and-6 at Chicago 44: Incomplete intended for Gordon deep down the left sideline. This particular misfire would not have been so problematic for Campbell and the Browns if interference had not been called on Bears corner Isaiah Frey. But because the throw was so bad – it sailed out of bounds inside the 10 while Gordon was wide-open at the 15 -- referee Jeff Triplette said: “There is no foul for defensive pass interference, as the ball is uncatchable.’’
Frey, realizing he had been beaten by Gordon on a go-route, began to put up the arm bar at the 30 and didn’t let go until the 20.
Brennaman and Billick said the officials were correct in discussing, then waving off, the penalty.
Non-supporting cast: Not all of Campbell’s failures were on him. His line struggled periodically to adjust to Chicago’s blitzes, especially those coming late from the second level, and his top three wide receivers have had better days.
No. 3 Bess continued his thoroughly disappointing season with as many drops (one) as receptions (one for 9 yards). The drop was ginormous, coming as it did in the first quarter on third-and-8 from the Chicago 17. Campbell put the ball where it needed to be -- low and away from the defender -- only to have Bess mishandle at the 7. The Browns settled for a field goal and 3-0 lead.
No. 2 Little led the Browns with 68 receiving yards (on four catches), but his miscommunication with Campbell early in the third quarter proved costly. On first-and-10 from the Cleveland 30, Campbell threw to a spot beyond the sticks at the sideline. Bowman was wide open and returned it 43 yards to give the Bears a 17-10 advantage.
The replay showed Little running straight to the Cleveland 47 and turning hard to the inside. By then, the ball was in the air and Bowman locked on it, breaking to the sideline as if he were the receiver.
After the game, Browns coach Rob Chudzinski said Little “was running his route’’ and that Campbell threw the ball too early. Perhaps. But Billick’s words and Campbell’s body language suggested otherwise.
Billick said: “This is just a miscue between Jason Campbell and Greg Little….Little turns in, as though he was expecting the ball to be a deep in. The ball was thrown to the outside….Zack Bowman saw the comeback and took it the distance.’’
When another replay showed Campbell raising his arms in disbelief upon realizing Bowman had make the pick, Billick said: “You can see Jason Campbell thinking….He thought that Little was going to break to the outside on a comeback. He can’t understand why Little did not. Obviously, a miscue. You zigged when you should have zagged.’’ Little would be easier to exonerate if this was the first time he and a quarterback did not see eye-to-eye on a route. It isn’t.
No. 1 Gordon rescued what would have been a shockingly bad stat line with the 43-yard TD, which enabled him to finish with three catches for 67 yards. Still, Gordon did not bring his ‘A’ – or ‘B’ -- game. His performance had the feel of Week 7 against the Packers, when he caught two passes for 21 yards.
To have expected Gordon to maintain his record-setting pace of the previous four weeks was unrealistic. To have expected more than what transpired in non-garbage time Sunday was not.
Campbell and Gordon were inches from several big completions, including on third-and-14 from the Cleveland 10 with 9:37 left in the fourth. The score was tied, 24-24, when Campbell threw a split-finger fastball to a wide-open Gordon at the Cleveland 26. Gordon had dropped to his knees to wait for the pass to arrive; when it finally did, the ball scraped the ground before Gordon secured it with his gloves. Campbell’s pass needed to be much more crisp, no doubt, but Gordon probably would have been better served falling forward and cradling it into the body.
Near-misses are one thing. Near-misses on routes over the middle are another.
On second-and-8 at the Cleveland 34 in the third quarter, Campbell threw what at first glance appeared to be an awful pass intended for Gordon. Campbell led Gordon too far and safety Chris Conte almost intercepted at the Chicago 45. The replay was less kind to Gordon, who seemed to be distracted by Conte at the last instant.
Brennaman said: “Gordon may have been hearing footsteps right here.’’
Billick: “Deion Sanders would call that a business decision.’’
Brennaman: “The question is, what would Rob Chudzinski call it?’’
On first-and-10 from the Cleveland 32 late in the fourth, Gordon failed to make a sliding catch at the Chicago 48. Conte popped him.
Brennaman said: “We have to take a look at what may or may not have happened there. Gordon has not been all that excited about going into traffic during the course of this game.’’
Billick: “We’ve seen a couple of these deep in-routes that, whether he’s anticipating them to be a little flatter, or he’s just a little hesitant to go in there….Of course, if you said, ‘a little hesitant to go in and get your head knocked,’ I’d certainly understand it.’’
Then Fox sideline reporter Laura Okmin talked about the minor accident involving Gordon’s vehicle on Saturday night, when the car in front of him evidently swerved in icy conditions. Gordon was evaluated and cleared to play.
On third-and-10 from the 32, Campbell’s pass intended for Gordon was broken up by corner Tim Jennings at the Cleveland 45. Gordon flapped his left arm over his head in disgust as he went to the sideline.
Billick said: “There seems to be a level of frustration between him and (Jason) Campbell, as to where the ball is going to be thrown.’’ Billick called Campbell “Josh,’’ confusing him with the Bears’ Josh McCown, but the point was made.
Receivers are entitled to nondescript afternoons, but they are glaring for those who enter with 1,400 yards in their first 11 games. At the same time, Gordon needed more accuracy and velocity from his quarterback and more emphasis early from his quarterback and offensive coordinator (Norv Turner). Why Gordon wasn’t even targeted until 1:51 remained in the second quarter did not compute, especially after Fox showed replays of Gordon getting open repeatedly.
Overall grade for Campbell: F
Analyze it yourself! Here is a database of all the Browns passes Dennis Manoloff and a squad of assistants are tracking this season. You can select criteria in the form below and get all the matching throws
How to use the database
- First, choose a quarterback.
- After that, choose one or more of the other options for comparisons, such as Receiver, or Pressure, or Direction of throw. (Tip: Don't choose too many.)
- Click search. You will need to scroll right and left to see all the matched results.
You can sort the results and look for more patterns by clicking on the heading of any. Click on "Throw #" at far right to put the throws back into their original order. - You can see the pass results as a graph, too.