Gay's hit was far worse than the hotly debated hit that 49ers linebacker Ahmad Brooks put on New Orleans' Drew Brees on Nov. 17.
CLEVELAND, Ohio - NFL officials blew it when they missed Steelers cornerback William Gay drilling Jason Campbell in the head during Sunday's loss to the Steelers -- and it cost the Browns a realistic shot of getting back in the game.
Gay's whack on Campbell's facemask -- which led to a concussion -- was far worse than the hotly-debated hit that 49ers linebacker Ahmad Brooks put on Drew Brees Nov. 17th. Brooks was not only penalized for the blow, but fined $15,750 for that hit last week.
In that instance, Brooks clotheslined Brees in the chest area with his forearm, and then rode up to his neck and chin to drive Brees to the ground. He was flagged 15 yards for unnecessary roughness, and the penalty negated a strip-sack.
The Saints capitalized on the penalty, and went on to kick a game tying field goal. They kicked another to win 23-20 as time expired. The victory was crucial for the Saints (9-2), who maintained a one-game lead over the Panthers (8-3) in the NFC South.
Two days after the controversial call -- which incensed players and had analysts such as Ray Lewis offering to chip in on Brooks' fine -- NFL vice president of officiating Dean Blandino made an appearance on NFL Network to explain that the officials got it right.
"You can't make forcible contact to the head or the neck area, even if the contact starts below the neck and rises up," Blandino said. "If there's force to that contact, it's a foul. Watch the initial contact, maybe around the shoulder, but it rides up into the neck area and brings the quarterback down with force. That's why the flag was thrown for unnecessary roughness."
When Blandino watches Gay clobber Campbell in the facemask on a corner blitz, he'll see the Campbell's head snap to the side and the ball slip out of his hand. Then, he'll watch him go to the ground with enough force that the back of his helmet smacks off the ground.
Campbell writhed on the ground for a few minutes and then wobbled off the field and later onto a cart, where he was driven to the locker room, his head hanging low. Coach Rob Chudzinski argued with the officials that Campbell was struck in the head, but was told that Gay hit him in the shoulder instead.
Even Browns linebacker Paul Kruger observed, "It doesn't seem like they miss that call very much.''
Back on the field, the blown call drastically changed the course of the game.
Instead of an unnecessary-roughness penalty that would've given the Browns a first and 10 at the Steelers 24, Pittsburgh's Will Allen scooped up the loose ball and ran it back 49 yards to the 4, where he was tackled by Chris Ogbonnaya. A play later, Ben Roethlisberger found Emmanuel Sanders in the end zone on a post-route to make it 20-3 with 7:43 left in the third quarter.
Brandon Weeden was forced to take over with the Browns trailing 20-3, instead of down 13-3 and already in field goal range. Even if the Browns didn't budge, Billy Cundiff would've lined up for a 42-yard field goal, and had already made a 49-yarder in the first quarter. It was no sure thing, but Cundiff was in the midst of a 12-kick streak that included six field goals of more than 42 yards.
At worst, the score probably would've been 13-6 -- a one-possession game -- with more than seven minutes remaining in the third quarter. At best, Weeden could've hit Jordan Cameron or boy-on-fire Josh Gordon with a TD pass to make it 13-10.
With the Browns' trailing 20-3, Pittsburgh pinned their ears back and Weeden was forced into catchup mode instead of trying to run a balanced offense.
"This is a game of inches and those plays make a world of difference when a call's missed or you miss a play,'' said Kruger. "Anything can happen in a football game.''
Chudzinski sent a tape of the hit and most likely Campbell's wobbly journey to the sidelines to the league office for clarification. Teams are not permitted to share the results of their inquiries so the two sides can engage in open dialogue, but Gay should certainly be fined for the hit -- at least as much as Brooks was.
If not, the officials will have blown it once again.
"Those are the plays in the games that are important,'' said Chudzinski. "Certainly, hopefully, we'll have Jason back soon."
Unfortunately for the Browns, who slipped to last place in the AFC North at 4-7 and saw their playoff hopes fizzle, they'll never get the opportunity back.