There are plenty of topics in this week's reader mailbag for beat writer Paul Hoynes.
Hey, Hoynsie: Do you think the Indians would be willing to trade Carlos Santana for a starting pitcher? He seems to be the most expendable with good trade value at this time. Yan Gomes looks more than capable to take over the catching duties. — Don Grubbs, Painesville
Hey, Don: I think the Indians would be willing to talk trade about any player on their roster, but I believe it would be hard to deal Santana. He is signed to a club-friendly contract through 2016 with a club option for 2017. Finding a pitcher the Indians could control for that long who could match Santana in value would not be easy.
I think they’ll also need Santana in the future to help the offense, regardless of what position he plays, once players like Mark Reynolds, Jason Giambi and Ryan Raburn go elsewhere.
Hey, Hoynsie: What is the Indians’ record with Drew Stubbs in center field? — Brad Stricker, Willoughby Hills
Hey, Brad: The Indians, entering the weekend, are 20-10 with Stubbs starting in center.
Hey, Hoynsie: With Jeremy Guthrie having pitched against the Tribe for Kansas City last week, it had me trying to recall what happened to him in Cleveland. He’s not a superstar, but was a first-round pick and has started 30 plus games in every season since we released him. We could have used a guy like that the past few seasons. — Philip Stevens, Philadelphia
Hey, Philip: The Indians’ handling of Guthrie is still a head-scratcher. They drafted him as a starter, paid him a $4.5 million signing bonus, including a four-year major-league contract, and only had him start one game in the big leagues. His other 15 appearances were as a reliever.Signing Guthrie to a major-league contract did not help matters. Guthrie ran out of options quicker and that’s why the Indians had to put him on waivers.
Guthrie didn’t help matters by under-performing with the Tribe and he has certainly taken his lumps as big-league starter, especially in Baltimore. But he definitely could have helped the Tribe.
Hey, Hoynsie: If the Phillies offer the Indians Cliff Lee for Francisco Lindor, will they do it? — Angelo Costanzo, Cleveland
Hey, Angelo: No. Not unless the Phillies want to pay the majority of Lee’s contract, which calls for $25 million in 2013, $25 million in 2014, $25 million in 2015 and a $27.5 million vesting option in 2016.
I don’t think the commissioner would allow that to happen, but Angelo, maybe you could help the Dolans pay Lee’s salary.
Hey, Hoynsie: In regards to what the Indians should do with Trevor Bauer for the rest of the season, any thoughts about having him in the bullpen, especially if they are in a playoff push down the stretch? — Bryan, Solon
Hey, Bryan: Bauer walks way too many people as a starter. As a reliever, his lack of control would be a disaster.
Hey, Hoynsie: How can the Indians draw more fans when all the sports talk shows do is talk Browns and Cavs, even when the Indians are in first place? — Ron Spyker, Wapakoneta
Hey, Ron: Just keep winning.
Hey, Hoynsie: The Indians are stockpiling middle infielders at the lower levels. Do you see any with the power potential to play first base, third base or a corner outfield position? Or are the Indians potentially using them as trade bait to replenish the pitching in the farm system? — Will Saunders, Pittsburgh
Hey, Will: Ronnie Rodriguez and Dorssys Paulino have shown power and could eventually move to third base. They already moved Tony Wolters from second base/shortstop to catcher.As for making a deal, anytime an organization has depth at a certain position, it makes it easier for it to make a trade by using that depth.
Hey, Hoynsie: Drew Stubbs seemed dismissive the other day discussing the value of trying to bunt for a hit from time to time. If he had 20 bunt hits last year for the Reds, it would have raised his average to a more acceptable .253. Don’t you think Terry Francona should insist that he try to bunt more, if for no other reason than to cut down on his strikeouts? — Greg Boveington, Crofton, Md.
Hey, Greg: You say dismissive, I’m sure Stubbs would say he’s being realistic. It sounds like Francona would like him to use the bunt more, but Stubbs is the guy with the bat in his hands. As a manager, you want your players to play with confidence, but certain situations dictate certain actions.
When Stubbs homered, singled and drove in four runs Thursday, would you rather have had him bunting for a hit?
Hey, Hoynsie: What is with the bullpen? It seems like every game they almost blow the lead and a lot of the time they do. How will they look to improve the bullpen? — Ari Ross, Shaker Heights
Hey, Ari: I think the Indians are hopeful that having the back end of the bullpen reunited is going to help. The key will be the effectiveness of Vinnie Pestano and Chris Perez and the ability of the rest of the pen to get them a lead.
Hey, Hoynsie: Given the Tribe’s poor attendance numbers in Cleveland with an ever-declining population and bleak economic future, at what point will the Dolans get serious about relocation? Wouldn’t the organization fare better in a 21st century city like Charlotte, Oklahoma City, or Boise? — Chris Niklas, Hudson
Hey, Chris: Boise, really?
Hey, Hoynsie: Anibal Sanchez went to Detroit last year and helped them tremendously. I know Ricky Nolasco doesn’t have Sanchez’s strikeout capabilities, but he is another solid Miami pitcher, and has been for some time. Miami might well part with him.
Would you consider trading for him? What about Matt Garza or Kyle Lohse? — Geoffrey Lee, Strongsville
Hey, Geoffrey: The Indians always talk about doing their due diligence concerning trades. I’m sure they’ve considered the pros and cons of those three pitchers.
Hey, Hoynsie: During last Sunday’s Tribe game, it was mentioned that as the White Sox continue to tumble, everyone could be available. Do you think the Tribe could put together a package to get Chris Sale? The cost would be heavy. I’m sure the Indians would have to include Francisco Lindor. Yet, putting Sale at the top of the rotation with Justin Masterson could solidify the Tribe as contenders this year and next as well as send a strong message to the fans. — Jack Bacevice, Cleveland
Hey, Jack: I love Sale and wish the Indians would have drafted him when they had the chance, but they took Drew Pomeranz instead. There is no way the White Sox trade Sale. But if Robin Ventura keeps letting him throw over 120 pitches in a losing effort as he did last Sunday, Sale might not be as valuable as I think.
Hey, Hoynsie: Yan Gomes to me looks like a real good ballplayer. He’s also very young. I like to see the Indians keep him around for a long time. What do you think the long-term plans are for him? — Johnny D’ambrosia, Garfield Heights
Hey, Johnny: Gomes is a keeper. I would not be surprised if he’s the Tribe’s starting catcher come 2014.
Hey, Hoynsie: Can you ask some non-catcher or pitcher on the Indians why baseball is so fatiguing these days? Far less standing or sitting than a desk or retail job? Far fewer swings than tennis or golf? Virtually no running? — Tony Little, Cleveland
Hey, Tony: I sense some sarcasm here. The last time I looked, I didn’t see Tiger Woods sprinting 90 feet every time he hit a shot. And no one was throwing a 95 mph fastball at his head when he was lining up a putt.
Hey, Hoynsie: Do you see the Indians bringing back Grady Sizemore this year? He could be the fourth outfielder and a left-handed bat on the bench for a small price. — Ryan Smith, Fort Wayne
Hey, Ryan: I think the that train has pulled out of the station. Sizemore, however, is scheduled to work out for teams around the All-Star break. Here’s hoping he’s healthy enough to play again. Grady’s a good guy and deserves some good fortune.
Hey, Hoynsie: My wife and I have noticed that the pants of Mark Reynolds, Nick Swisher and Asdrubal Cabrera vary from down/up game to game. Is there a story here? Or is each of them whimsical? — Keith Conklin, Twinsburg
Hey, Keith: Most of it has to do with hot and cold hitting streaks. If a player starts hitting with his pant legs up or down, they usually stay with that look for as long as the streak lasts. It can be the same with wins and losses.
Hey, Hoynsie: Recently the Cubs made a couple of trades that included “international bonus slots.” What the heck are those? I’ve never heard of them nor of them being traded. — Jeff Walker, Independence
Hey, Jeff: For the first time this year, under terms of the 2011 basic agreement, teams can trade portions of their bonus pool for signing international free agents. The period for signing international free agents started Tuesday (July 2) and runs through June 15, 2014. Each team is given a bonus pool based on the reverse order of the 2012 standings, which gives the Indians the fifth largest pool at just over $3.6 million.
Instead of simply trading cash portions of their pools, teams have each been assigned four slot values. The total of those four slots, plus a $700,000 base allocation for each team, equals their bonus pool. Slot values can be included in trades for big league players.
For more information I suggest going to baseballamerica.com.
Hey, Hoynsie: Why do Tom Hamilton and Jim Rosenhaus take innings off during the game, but Matt Underwood and Rick Manning don’t? I’ve read that it happens a lot with radio guys but not TV. — Jeff Kascsak, Olmsted Township
Hey, Jeff: I’m guessing Hamilton and Rosenhaus have better agents. Not really, just being a wise guy.
Hamilton has it in his contract that he’ll do seven innings of play-by-play and two innings of color every game. On the flip side, Rosenhaus does two innings of play-by-play and seven innings of color. While it may sound as if there’s only one announcer in the booth, they’re almost always both there.
The dynamic between announcers on TV is different, so the play-by-play duties aren’t interchangeable.
— Hoynsie