With a 44-38 record, these Indians look about the same as the Tribe teams of the last two years. But this team is built not to fade down the stretch.
CLEVELAND, Ohio - Closing my eyes, I can see Terry Francona sitting almost straight up in a chair. His eyes were on fire, his voice was low and stern. He stared hard at a few reporters in the manager's office at Comerica Park.
The date was June 9, and the Tribe had just been swept in a three-game series in Detroit.
The Indians had lost seven in a row, 13 of 17 overall. They were 5 1/2 games behind the Tigers in the Central Division, and seemed to be sinking into an early-season baseball oblivion.
Someone mentioned last season, when the Tribe went from contention in July to an embarrassment in August and September.
Only now, it seemed to be happening in June.
"This is not last year, nor will it be," said Francona. "This is a different team."
It was one of those statements made where the implication was clear -- there will be no further discussion of the topic, no matter how many questions are asked.
The Indians lost the next day, 6-3, in Texas. The losing streak was eight, the overall record 30-33.
Then it all changed, beginning with two victories in Texas.
What looked like a June swoon became a team that came back from the dark side of the baseball moon. The Tribe has won 14 of 19 games, and enters Tuesday's action in first place with a half-game ahead of the Tigers.
Can it last?
Are the Indians a different team, a better team?
They have played slightly more than 50 percent of the 162-game schedule. Their record is 44-38.
Not bad at all.
But the Indians were 43-39 after 82 games last season . . . and finished 68-94.
They were 44-38 in 2011, and ended up 80-82.
Both years, they went from contention to dejection for the fans.
Will it happen again?
A lot will depend on the Tigers, who have roared in August and September in the last two seasons as the Tribe cowered in the Central Division corner.
But this season, the Tigers are 2-9 in extra innings, compared to 5-0 for the Tribe.
Detroit has lost five games when leading in the ninth inning; it's happened once to the Tribe.
The Indians are 17-7 in one-run games, the Tigers are 8-12.
Add it all up, and it shows Detroit has a bullpen crisis -- something that could keep the Tribe close all season.
The different bench
Consider this list:
Utility infielder: Jason Donald/Brent Lillibridge.
Extra outfielder: Aaron Cunningham/Shelley Duncan.
Backup catcher: Lou Marson.
That was the Tribe's bench for much of 2012.
Now this list:
Utility infielder: Mike Aviles.
Extra outfielder: Ryan Raburn.
Backup catcher: Yan Gomes.
That's the Tribe bench this season. Raburn and Aviles have been big-league regulars before.
Of that 2012 group, not a single player is on a current active Major League roster.
General manager Chris Antonetti and his staff didn't just overhaul the bench, they upgraded it.
Different is better
No need to dwell on the lineup from last season. Just know that Jose Lopez batted cleanup . . . 20 times. And he was placed on waivers twice in 2012.
The last four spots in the order were a true dead zone, often containing these names: Johnny Damon, Zeke Carrera, Casey Kotchman, Duncan and Jack Hannahan.
Kotchman is 0-for-20 with Miami and has battled injuries. Hannahan is hitting .188 as a reserve with the Reds. The others aren't even in the Majors.
The only significant loss from the 2012 lineup is Shin-Soo Choo, now with the Reds.
The Indians have added veterans Michael Bourn, Mark Reynolds, Nick Swisher and Drew Stubbs.
Bourn is hitting .299 with 11 stolen bases.
Reynolds has 15 homers and 46 RBI.
Swisher is batting .235 with eight homers and 29 RBI.
Stubbs is a .241 hitter with 30 RBI.
Not all the new acquisitions have met expectations, but the Indians now put out a viable Major League lineup that is tied for third in the American League in runs scored (with Detroit). The Indians were 13th in runs scored last season.
The Indians also are fourth in homers and tied for first with Boston in stolen bases.
As Antonetti admitted, "We're not a perfect team, but we have more power, more speed and better defense, especially in the outfield."
He then credited the Dolan family for allowing the team to sign free agents Swisher, Bourn and Reynolds. Ownership also kicked in $3 million to help the Choo trade go through, adding Matt Albers, Bryan Shaw, Trevor Bauer and Stubbs to the Tribe.
Bauer was the top prospect in that deal and has been a major disappointment so far, as his windup is a mess.
But given the fact that Choo will be a free agent (and not likely to re-sign with the Tribe), adding Stubbs to the outfield along with relievers Shaw and Albers is a nice haul for a player so close to free agency.
Experience matters
Then there's Francona.
He is a manager with enormous experience, two World Series rings from Boston and huge respect among players.
The front office also took his input, adding Aviles and Jason Giambi to the bench. The manager believed it's critical to have veterans who know they aren't going to be regulars, yet also realize how to be prepared to play at any moment.
Last season, the Tribe had the highest ERA (4.78) in the American League. This season, they are 12th at 4.28.
Not a major improvement, but better.
Justin Masterson (10-6) is having an All-Star season. Ubaldo Jimenez is 6-4, compared to 9-17 last season. Scott Kazmir, Corey Kluber and Zach McAllister have all had some nice moments.
"Our goal for this year was to put a competitive team on the field that plays meaningful games in August and September," said Antonetti. "We are moving in that direction. Terry (Francona) is a huge part of that, because he is such a strong leader and a great communicator."
Can the Indians collapse?
Of course it can happen. In three of the last four years, they have lost at least 92 games.
But will it happen again this season?
I'm with Francona on that point -- it won't.
This is indeed a different team.
Terry Pluto: terrypluto.com
Facebook: facebook.com/terrypluto
Faith stories: cleveland.com/pluto/faith